Showing posts with label Conformity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Conformity. Show all posts

Thursday, July 5, 2012

Quotation Of The Day: Echo Chamber Edition

From this John T. Spencer post:

I am quick to point out that social media seems to push people toward extreme echo chambers. I sort Facebook by relevance. I choose Twitter friends who are teachers. I blog about education. However, these echo chambers have always existed. Whether they were Rotary Clubs, churches, neighborhoods, political parties or social clubs, they were always echo chambers.
I'm still concerned about echo chamber. However, I'm beginning to see that an echo chamber is often simply a community with shared values. Often, echo chambers become  a place to hash out the nuance on shared ideas. We need a few homogeneous spaces to let us geek out about interests that we share with others. It is part of thinking deeply about a topic. True, they can get myopic. However, it takes a certain level of narrow-mindedness to delve deeply into an idea.

It isn't always a bad thing to connect with others based upon shared experiences, interests or values. It only becomes dangerous when it becomes the only definition of "normal" or when it turns tribalistic toward outsiders. So maybe the solution isn't to bash the group. If I want to make a difference, I need to enter into other echo chambers and ask questions, tell stories and challenge the presuppositions of each community.

Monday, February 6, 2012

The Common Core And Conformity

The blog at TED.com has an interview with Sugata Mitra, an advocate of self-directed learning.  Mitra installed a computer in a hole in a wall in a New Dehli slum and let children operate it unsupervised.  He contends,
"Experiments show that children in unsupervised groups are capable of answering questions many years ahead of the material they’re learning in school."
I'm not sure how I feel about the idea of no adult direction in a classroom, but I do agree with Mitra's analysis about how and why our current system works like it does.
The existing Victorian system of education was created to mass-produce identical human beings, mainly to serve an aristocracy, and, in modern times, an industrial elite. Governments find it difficult to move away from this model, because it has worked.
Despair.com provides a succinct reminder and visual proof that schools succeed in their mass production efforts.


Writing in the Answer Sheet, Marion Brady, a teacher and curriculum designer contends that the Common Core standards will continue to produce conformity.  She calls the standards "a confusing, random, overwhelming, intellectually unmanageable assortment of facts, specialized vocabularies, disconnected conceptual frameworks, and abstractions — the whole too far removed from life as the young live it for them to care about it."
Later, she predicts,
When the CEOs and the politicians they’ve bought finish the simplistic “reform” they’ve started, when the claim that an order-of-magnitude improvement in learner intellectual performance has been dismissed as hyperbole, when all 50 states have been pressured to adopt the regressive Common Core Standards locking the knowledge-fragmenting 1893 curriculum in permanent place, when standardized subject-matter tests that can’t measure the qualities and quality of thought have been nationalized, when the “standards and testing police” are fully deployed and looking over every teacher’s shoulder, it’ll all be over. America and the nations that follow its lead in education will face a dynamic world equipped with a static curriculum.
I don't know which is worse: being unnecessary or helping mass produce conformists.