Monday, October 28, 2013

The South Dakota United Senate Race: All Risk All The Time

The Constant Commoner looks at the Republican primary and concludes the frying pan is preferable to the fire:
For all the intra-party intrigue, though, to me the race is still about who can best protect this seat from being influenced by the Republican Party's death-wishers, aka the Tea Party.  Former Governor Mike Rounds' comments (albeit after the fact) about the futility of  the Tea Party-orchestrated U.S. Government shutdown and near default on the federal debt give him the inside track as far as I'm concerned, so for now--I like Mike.  This doesn't mean I can't go into "I used to like Mike" mode.  I intend to stick with the candidate who will be utterly committed to South Dakota's, not the Tea Party's, best interests.  That mantle is still up for grabs.
Over at Madville, Cory has reached a similar conclusion:
I've complimented Rounds's pragmatism before. That pragmatism keeps him from signing silly pledges like Grover Norquist's no-new-taxes pledge. (And, again as Toby noted, even Norquist prefers Rounds's pragmatism to Cruz's/Noem's/Rhoden's/Nelson's/Bosworth's suicidal ACA obsession.) That pragmatism would have kept Rounds from casting what could have been the most destructive vote of the 113th Congress... a vote every Republican challenging him would have cast.
There are many reasons I could encourage my Republican friends to nominate someone other than Marion Michael Rounds. The uninspiring Larry Rhoden would be easier for Rick Weiland to beat. Stace Nelson would provide much more exciting debates with Weiland. Annette Bosworth's spontaneous combustion would make for much easier blogging.
But if Rick Weiland gets a record deal and moves to Nashville, Marion Michael Rounds is the safest, sanest choice for Senate.
I think I agree with both assessments. Watching and listening to Ted Cruz orchestrate the shutdown and show no concern for the harm caused must give one pause. Cruz having another syncofant in the United States Senate is a worrisome possibility. The United States will not well served by another elected official who cares only about repealing Obamacare.

And yet there exists a lingering doubt. Rounds is nothing if not a consummate insider, the epitome of an establishment politician. It was members of the establishment who created the system of trading derivatives and mortgage tranches that caused America to experience an economic downturn that the country had not experienced since 1929. The idea that Rounds would support efforts to keep his fellow elites from repeating that destruction is ludicrous.

I wish I could be sanguine about voting for rational destruction over irrational annihilation. I may have to do it, but the vote will make me queasy.

Sunday, October 27, 2013

Scripture And Song Of The Week: Galatians 3 Edition

Galatians 3
NIV
1 You foolish Galatians! Who has bewitched you? Before your very eyes Jesus Christ was clearly portrayed as crucified. 2 I would like to learn just one thing from you: Did you receive the Spirit by the works of the law, or by believing what you heard? 3 Are you so foolish? After beginning by means of the Spirit, are you now trying to finish by means of the flesh? 4 Have you experienced so much in vain—if it really was in vain? 5 So again I ask, does God give you his Spirit and work miracles among you by the works of the law, or by your believing what you heard? 6 So also Abraham “believed God, and it was credited to him as righteousness.”

Does The Tea Party Want To Win On The Issues Or Does It Want To Insult Liberals?

Constant Conservative has a recent post entitled "The Common Core is about Power." I have no quarrel with the title. I agree that the Core is about established elites maintaining power. The post has a video of someone named Bill Whittle, whom I had never heard of, asserting that the Common Core will produce cookie cutter students. Again, I agree with the assertion. Whittle urges conservatives to look at the big picture and not elements of the standards that they find personally objectionable. Here again, I agree.

Whittle, however, seems more interested in tossing red meat sops to his tea party audience than he does stopping the Core. In fact he acts more like a stereotypical smarmy insurance or used car salesman than he does in making the case against the Core. Washington DC is a den of "scum and villainy." Liberals are stupid, and Whittle is so much smarter than anyone else. Throughout the video, Whittle seems more intent on skewing his political opponents than making the case against the Core.

Whittle's desire to place slime above substance and ConCon's proclamation that Whittle's video makes the case in "excellent fashion" prompts a simple question: does the tea party want to produce policy or does it want to skewer political foes?

The answer is important because there are issues including NSA abuses and the Core that could have broad support across the political spectrum. The recent NSA march in DC had both liberals and libertarians. It seems, however, that some tea party conservatives don't want to win. They just want to insult perceived political foes.

A Quiz To Determine How Displaced You Are

Time  has a 10 question quiz to determine the state that best matches a person's personality. Apparently, I belong in Indiana. I'm not only politically displaced; I'm geographically misplaced.

Wednesday, October 23, 2013

Tweet Of The Day: What Politicians Don't Do Edition

@jamespoulos: Every politician demands we emphasize growth. Some demand emphasizing liberty. None demand emphasis on seeing one another as fellow humans---but if we do begin by seeing each other clearly that way, our radical freedom, always already present, comes dramatically into focus. Hmmm Shared via TweetCaster

Tuesday, October 22, 2013

Let's Stop Playing What's The Politician's Faith?

Via Madville, I see that Reverend Hickey unable to "detect" any "evidence" of President Obama's "Christian faith." I have no idea whether Reverend Hickey claims to possess the gift of discernment or how one discerns the sincerity of the faith of a politician one has never met.

I can remember more than a few good Christian folk who were upset that Jimmy Carter lusted in his heart and had an evening glass of scotch even though he taught Sunday school. Many of those same folks loved Ronald Reagan who rarely darkened a church door.

Bill Clinton broke both the adultery and false witness commandments. The second Bush took the nation to war under dubious pretenses. Obama is far from perfect, but I haven't seen any evidence of his committing similar, shall we agree to call them, errors.

I didn't vote for Obama in 2012; I haven't been satisfied with a President since Eisenhower, and I was three when he left office. I'm, therefore, not going to trust my personal memory on his second term.

From my displaced point of view, it seems that one's view of a public figure's faith is colored not by the public figure's faith and works but by beholder's political views.

When I was a young'un my mother used to read me the story of Samuel coming to Jesse to anoint one of Jesse's sons the new king of Israel. That son was the future King David who at the time was a runty, ruddy youth. The key verse of the story was I Samuel 16:7
But the Lord said unto Samuel, Look not on his countenance, or on the height of his stature; because I have refused him: for the Lord seeth not as man seeth; for man looketh on the outward appearance, but the Lord looketh on the heart.
I'm fairly certain that no human can can see another's heart. Perhaps, it would serve us all to refrain from commenting on the faith of public figures be they Presidents, U.S. Senators, or Popes. Those comments reveal more about the speaker than the public figure, and they rarely reflect well on the speaker.

Monday, October 21, 2013

Will SCF Santa Deliver For Rhoden, Nelson, Or Bosworth?

"Now that the Obamacare showdown is over, we will begin making candidate endorsements for the 2014 elections. Our goal is to elect true conservative leaders to the U.S. Senate who have the courage to stand up to the Washington establishment. If there is a lesson from the Obamacare debate, it's that we need more principled leaders in Washington who will listen to the voters and fight for their values.
"We have enjoyed working with Ted Cruz, Mike Lee, and Rand Paul on several policy issues this year, but we won't be asking them to support our candidates. These are our endorsements, not theirs, and it's time for Americans to take the lead and use the political process to change Washington." [italics in original]
Since SCF is checking its naughty and nice list, Stace Nelson, Larry Rhoden, and Annette Bosworth are likely hanging their endorsement stockings by their respective PAC endorsement chimneys with great care in hopes that an SCF endorsement soon will be there. The candidates likely can't sleep with all of the visions of sugar plum cash dancing in their heads.

Of course there's always the risk of either empty or coal filled stockings. All three candidates, but Nelson in particular, must also be hoping beyond hope that the SFC is not the Grinch that The Hill anonymously sourced last month:
While multiple conservative groups confirmed they’ve met with both Nelson and the other most prominent conservative challenger in the race, state Sen. Larry Rhoden, representatives privately admitted they’re not thrilled with either candidate.
“Stace probably shares our views, but [it’s] hard to see him being a credible candidate at this point,” one adviser to a national conservative group told The Hill.
SCF Santa has already endorsed Chris McDaniel in Mississippi and Matt Bevin in Kentucky, so the South Dakota candidates must be experiencing an excruciating wait.