Saturday, June 11, 2011

Art, Literature, and Moral Conunundrums

Alyssa Rosenberg is rapidly becoming one of my favorite bloggers.  Writing about whether art should solve moral conundrums, she contends
Is there any question that 24 did artistic work to justify torture? That a casual attitude towards abuse of prisoners in our most popular crime shows is corrosive to justice? That Michael Bay’s movies white-wash the military? But would it be better for us to have a world without those works if it means foregoing the condemnations of torture and meditations on the laws of war of Battlestar Galactica? The critique of traditional police work that is The Wire? The Hurt Locker‘s quiet tragedy? Art takes us to the places we can’t go. Sometimes it lies about what we’d find there, sometimes it misunderstands what it’s trying to see through the wavery glass of prison doors and tank windows. This is why it’s bad to read just one book, to read Gone With the Wind or Atlas Shrugged, or watch Birth of a Nation or Battleship Potemkin and nothing else. But it’s useful to read Gone With the Wind next to Uncle Tom’s Cabin: knowing that Confederate nostalgia is wrong, and racist, doesn’t obliterate the need to understand that people feel it, and are strongly influenced by those feelings. Resolving the moral conundrum is ultimately our work, not any one author of any one work’s, and it doesn’t make sense to fault fiction for that.

A New Form of Intelligence: Another Thing NCLB/Race To The Top Will Screw Up

David Livermore, president and partner at the Cultural Intelligence Center in East Lansing, Michigan, and . . . a visiting scholar at Nanyang Technological University in Singapore, writes,
What’s the number one predictor of success in today’s global economy? It’s not your IQ, not your résumé—not even your expertise. It’s your CQ (cultural intelligence quotient), a powerful capability that is proven to enhance your effectiveness working in culturally diverse situations.

CQ is the ability to function effectively in a variety of cultural contexts—national, ethnic, organizational, and generational. It is a set of capabilities and skills proven to give employees and their organizations a competitive advantage in our ever-shrinking world.
He goes on to break down the elements of cultural intelligence.
Academic research across more than 30 countries reveals four capabilities that consistently emerge among individuals who are culturally intelligent:

1. CQ Drive: They possess a high level of interest, drive, and motivation to adapt cross-culturally.
2.  CQ Knowledge: They have a strong understanding about how cultures are similar and different.
3. CQ Strategy: They are aware and able to plan in light of their cultural understanding.
4.  CQ Action: They know when to adapt and when not to adapt when relating and working cross-culturally. [emphasis in original]
One could boil those elements down to two qualities.  The first two require curiosity while the latter require a willingness to adapt.  Filling in the bubbles on a standardized DSTEP test will do little to test either quality.  Teaching to that test will do little to develop either quality.

More importantly, education should help students develop eudaimonia, a sense of fulfillment.  Alyssa Rosenberg writes,
One of the places cultural capital seems valuable is when it’s surprising, when two people doing a deal discover that, contrary to their expectations of each other, both love the same author, or a client finds out that the person who is responsible for entertaining them can talk knowledgeably about their favorite sports team. It’s the spontaneity of that mutual recognition that’s useful, and that’s hard to engineer or to hire strategically for. (HT Andrew Sullivan)
Once again, preparing students to fill in bubble tests won't help people to love Shakespeare, Hawthorne, or Flannery O'Connor.  It won't help students learn to know how to talk about the Minnesota Twins or Green Bay Packers.  It won't help them develop a love for jazz, appreciate a good rock guitar riff or the poetry inherent in Johnny Cash's songs.

Employers want students who are curious and can think globally.  Students who are curious and think globally have a better chance of developing a sense of fulfillment.  Why can't Arne Duncan and the rest of people shoving testing down people's throats understand that?

Friday, June 10, 2011

Stuff about School in the Summer: My Homework to Prepare to Teach Speech and Debate Class


Lifehacker's Melane Pinola lists several elements that plague sucky presentations.
Problem 1: Too many ideas on one slide
Problem 2: Cliches and Clipart
Problem 3: Lack of emphasis
Problem 4: Random design choices
Problem 5: No relationship to the audience
Pinola also offers several solutions.  First,
Remember this mnemonic: SLIDE

Simplify
Lose the cliches
Information needs emphasis
Designate elements
Empathy for the audience
More importantly,
Incorporate Storytelling Structure into Presentations for Added Drama and Effectiveness.

The best presentations and speeches share a lot in common with stories: they move you with a mix of drama and tension, taking you from the status quo to what could be—your ideas blissfully realized. . . ,but basically you can make your presentation more engaging—even cinematic—by using a storytelling framework.
Most of this is pretty basic.  Coaches tell debaters to tell the judge a simple story before every round.  It's the simple, basic elements that usually cause the most problems, however.  This article was a fortuitous reminder

Poverty's Pernicious Effects

The New Republic has published a provocative article entitled "Why Can’t More Poor People Escape Poverty?: A radical new explanation from psychologists." (HT Big Boy Blogger Andrew Sullivan) Jamie Holmes reports that the answer is simple: poverty depletes willpower. 
Taking this model of willpower into the real world, psychologists and economists have been exploring one particular source of stress on the mind: finances. The level at which the poor have to exert financial self-control, they have suggested, is far lower than the level at which the well-off have to do so. Purchasing decisions that the wealthy can base entirely on preference, like buying dinner, require rigorous tradeoff calculations for the poor. As Princeton psychologist Eldar Shafir formulated the point in a recent talk, for the poor, “almost everything they do requires tradeoff thinking. It’s distracting, it’s depleting … and it leads to error.” The poor have to make financial tradeoff decisions, as Shafir put it, “on anything above a muffin.”
Later in the article, Holmes writes,
Many of the tradeoff decisions that the poor have to make every day are onerous and depressing: whether to pay rent or buy food; to buy medicine or winter clothes; to pay for school materials or loan money to a relative. These choices are weighty, and just thinking about them seems to exact a mental cost.
The most chilling result may be the loss of true freedom.  Holmes concludes,
The economist Amartya Sen, in his well-known volume Development as Freedom, notes how an individual’s “freedom of agency” is “constrained by the social, political and economic opportunities” available to them. He’s right: Fewer options do reduce freedom. But now, we may need to grapple with a new possibility: that poverty doesn’t simply reduce freedom by constraining an individual’s choices, but that it may actually alter the nature of freedom by reducing an individual’s willpower.
As if loss of freedom and will power were not destructive enough, this article points to a study that shows that poverty starts to inhibit learning is children as young as two. (HT @DianeRavitch)
Psychologists at the University of Texas at Austin gave a series of mental tests to 750 sets of young twins between 10 months and 2 years old. They found that half of the gains that wealthier children show on tests can be attributed to their genes. Fine. That's not shocking, but it's not the case for children from poorer families, who already lag behind their peers by age 2. That cohort in the study showed almost no improvements driven by their genetic makeup. If you are poor, then your mental development starts to stagnate before you even reach pre-school.

The lead author, Professor Elliot Tucker-Drob, makes a point of reminding us that his findings do not suggest that children from wealthier families are genetically superior or smarter. They simply have more opportunities to reach their potential. That's his lesson from this. So what exactly are those opportunities? That's what we need to know.

The study notes that wealthier parents are often able to provide better educational resources and spend more time with their children but doesn't conclude what factors, in particular, help their children reach their genetic potentials. That's the follow-up study Tucker-Drob is already planning. But these findings offer another a pretty obvious scientific example of why breaking the cycle of poverty is so difficult and why offering all children access to early childhood development programs is so important if we want to be a land of equal opportunity. [emphasis mine]
Studies like these make it abundantly clear that poverty leaves people behind at the beginning and makes catching up difficult if not impossible.

Thursday, June 9, 2011

One Party States: An Update

The cliche misery loves company must have an element of truth.  The fact that other states are suffering under single party domination provides a small bit of comfort producing commiseration.

The New York Times profiles Connecticut and Wisconsin.  Democrats dominate Connecticut; Republicans control Wisconsin.

The Times reports Connecticut's conservatives' complaints:

An editorial on Monday in The Republican-American of Waterbury, considered the state’s most conservative daily newspaper, was more blunt: “It now is fair to say the state of Connecticut has left the gravitational pull of planet Earth. Just when you thought state government’s policies couldn’t get any more absurd, they move to a new level of, well, absurdity.”
In Wisconsin, Democrats bemoan a lack of bipartisanship.
“There has been not even a pretense of trying to find a bipartisan agreement on important issues,” said Senator Mark Miller, the Democratic leader, who added that some measures were introduced and passed through committees in just a week’s time — a warp-speed timetable for any state government. “It’s the Republican agenda, and that’s it. The only negotiations now are among themselves.”
South Dakotans who are not in the Republican fold can empathize with the political minorities in both states; the recent legislative session has produced absurdity because the only negotiations took place between members of the majority party.

Comics as Myth

I haven't seen X-Men: First Class, but big boy bloggers and reviewers are elevating the movie from a comic book geekboy must see to myth.

It is apparently, a metaphor for the struggle for gay rights.  Writing in The Atlantic, Paul Schrodt opines,
In X-Men: First Class, one young mutant-human tells another, "You have no idea what I'd give to feel ... normal." It's a moment anyone who went to high school can empathize with, though it might mean something more to those who grew up gay—the adolescent experience when you discover, like the X-Men, something in your nature that makes you different from the majority of the people around you.

Parallels between the mutant experience and the gay experience pervade First Class, which opened on Friday to a weekend box-office haul of $56 million. The film, a prequel to the modern X-Men movie series, tells the franchise's origin myth: Genetic mutations create a cadre of young superheros who use their powers for good—in this case, by attempting to defuse the Cuban Missile Crisis. The mutants are, unmistakably, a social minority. The film's catchphrase is "mutant and proud," a playful riff on post-Stonewall self-acceptance, and a "don't ask, don't tell" joke even finds its way into the dialogue.
In the New York Times, Ta-Nehisi Coates writes that the movie is about race, even as it engages in historical revisionism that promotes musing in people of a certain age who possess a bit of historical knowledge.
When we left the theater, my son and I knew we had experienced the most thrilling movie of the summer. “First Class” is narratively lean, beautifully acted and, at all the right moments, visually stunning. But I had experienced something else. My son is 10 and a romantic, as all 10-year-olds surely have the right to be. How then do I speak to him of this world’s masterminds who render you a supporting actor in your own story? How do I speak of the Sentinels whose eyes melt history, until the world forgets that in 1962, the quintessential mutants of America were black?
This movie seems to explain and people seem to argue about its interpretation. Pantheon.org claims "myths and mythologies seek to rationalize and explain the universe and all that is in it. Thus, they have a similar function to science, theology, religion and history in modern societies."

Stan Lee, creator of the X-Men comics has always said the comic sought to expose bigotry.  Schrodt writes,
Lee has been coy about sexually identifying X-Men, calling it one of several stories directed “against bigotry of all sorts.” At the time the comic book first came out in 1963, it made more sense to think of the characters’ plight in terms of the civil rights movement. Since then, however, it’s become a natural echo of the growing LGBT movement, which is likewise based on a minority that’s “hidden” from public view.
When I go to see the movie, I'll be looking for the explanations of social ills and hopefully be seeing myth not just an adventure story

Local Media Is Suffering

I grew up on the North Dakota side of the Bison-Lemmon metroplex.  My family listened to KBJM Radio 1400 and read The Bismarck Tribune along with a local weekly.  In my increasingly unreliable memory, the media covered local issues fairly well.  Apparently, local issues now get short shrift.  According a New York Times article,
An explosion of online news sources in recent years has not produced a corresponding increase in reporting, particularly quality local reporting, a federal study of the media has found.

Coverage of state governments and municipalities has receded at such an alarming pace that it has left government with more power than ever to set the agenda and have assertions unchallenged, concluded the study, which is to be released on Thursday.
Quoting from the study, the Times reports,
“Breathtaking media abundance lives side by side with serious shortages in reporting,” it said. “Communities benefit tremendously from many innovations brought by the Internet and simultaneously suffer from the dislocations caused by the seismic changes in media markets."
I have a few quick observations.  First, I am aware of the irony of quoting the New York Times to discuss local issues.  Second, the report illustrates a need for blogs such as The Madville Times, An Inland Voyage, and  David Lias's blog.  Third, South Dakotans may complain about their local media, but for the most part, the local daily and weekly newspapers seem to cover most of the official government meetings.  They probably don't do as much investigative work as they should, but situations like this example from the NYT article probably don't happen.
In researching the report, he and his staff interviewed scores of journalists to develop a fuller picture of the state of media. What they found was sometimes alarming. At one newspaper Mr. Waldman [author of the study] visited in Tennessee, he recalled, he asked an editor about a list of story ideas that was posted in the newsroom.

“There was one up there that said it was about the regulatory board that dealt with incompetent doctors. And there was a little red X next to it. I said, ‘What does that mean?’ And he said, ‘Well, we’re not doing that one.’ ” The reason the editor offered: the paper used to have two reporters assigned to cover that area, and now it had only one.
Finally, the larger problem may be we media consumers who have lost all sense of place.  Front Porch Republic observes,
Little regard is paid to the necessity for those overlapping local and regional groups, communities, and associations that provide a matrix for human flourishing.
Perhaps, the problem is a little simpler than that.  Little attention is paid to human flourishing. Each of us have started to view everything and everyone as a commodity.  The economy might be terrible, but James Carville's famous maxim should probably be rephrased to state "It's the relationships, stupid."  That personal connection should create demand for increased local coverage.