I spent the day working with young debaters who have qualified for the National Speech and Debate Association National Tournament. The were arguing about NATO intervention in Ukraine or whether the United States should emphasize national security at the expense of citizens' digital privacy.
I guess the practice rounds at Brookings High School must have caused me to believe the school year was still in full swing because I started to think about, for lack of a better term, essay questions about South Dakota politics.
Answer whichever one of the following you choose in the comments. As with all essay questions support your answers with concrete examples and verifiable statistics.
Question 1: Will South Dakotans ever elect a pro-life Democrat or a pro-choice Republican to statewide office? (Debate coaches, that does sound a lot like an extemp question, so no triangles in the comments.)
Question 2: Although South Dakotans are open about a great divide between East River and West River residents, a far wider gulf seems to exist between Native Americans and those of European decent. What should be done to address those stark divisions? Bonus question: why do so few discuss the issue?
Question 3: Given that Republicans have maintained what amounts to a super-majority in the state legislature and the executive branch even though Democrats and Independents outnumber Republicans within South Dakota, what policy initiatives should Democrats initiate to gain the support of Independent voters?
Question 4: Question : Can a South Dakota politician be successful in a statewide race if he or she openly claims to dislike hunting and fishing?
Question 5: Why have those South Dakotans who claim the Second Amendment is under threat and who oppose background checks or a ban on assault weapons focus exclusively on firearms? Doesn't the right to "keep and bear arms" include all knives or collapsible batons which some localities restrict?
Tuesday, June 10, 2014
Monday, June 9, 2014
What Good Is $100 Million For Security Without An MRAP
Like others, I wondered why South Dakota needed more money per-capita than New York for homeland security.
As a South Dakotan used to my state getting its fair share or more of the federal government's security largess, I was, therefore, greatly troubled to learn that South Dakota is one of a handful of states that has not received a Mine Resistant Ambush Protected armored vehicle. This handy chart from the New York Times shows that all of our neighbors have at least one such vehicle.
Taken in that light, lack of an MRAP is probably a positive for South Dakotans' safety unless Montana,Wyoming, North Dakota, Nebraska, Iowa,and Minnesota coordinate an invasion.
As a South Dakotan used to my state getting its fair share or more of the federal government's security largess, I was, therefore, greatly troubled to learn that South Dakota is one of a handful of states that has not received a Mine Resistant Ambush Protected armored vehicle. This handy chart from the New York Times shows that all of our neighbors have at least one such vehicle.
![]() |
| NYT chart. Click to enlarge |
On a slightly more serious note, the article also points out that the sheriff's department North Dakota's Walsh County has 40 silencers that they apparently were unaware of. One wonders what military equipment South Dakota's law enforcement agencies possess wittingly or unwittingly
Its worth questioning whether most police departments need military equipment. The equipment does seem to give rise to responses that are much more muscular than necessary:
The equipment has been added to the armories of police departments that already look and act like military units. Police SWAT teams are now deployed tens of thousands of times each year, increasingly for routine jobs. Masked, heavily armed police officers in Louisiana raided a nightclub in 2006 as part of a liquor inspection. In Florida in 2010, officers in SWAT gear and with guns drawn carried out raids on barbershops that mostly led only to charges of “barbering without a license.
Taken in that light, lack of an MRAP is probably a positive for South Dakotans' safety unless Montana,Wyoming, North Dakota, Nebraska, Iowa,and Minnesota coordinate an invasion.
Sunday, June 8, 2014
Tweet Of The Day: Political Parties Frequently Mirror Images Of Each Other Edition
2006: Democrats: Signing statements bad! GOP: No big deal!
2014: GOP: Signing statements bad! Dems: No big deal!
http://t.co/2evH8vdzaY
— Charlie Savage (@charlie_savage) June 7, 2014
Labels:
A Pox on Both Your Houses,
Tweets
I Am Going To Vote For Terry Winter
The preposition in the post's title is important. It's been a long time since I voted for someone.
In November, I will mark a box that indicates I chose Rick Weiland, Larry Pressler, or Gordon Howie to be South Dakota's next United States Senator. Whichever candidate I select, my vote likely will not be for him, It will be against Mike Rounds who created budgets that allowed his successor to decimate education funding in South Dakota and who will likely support every effort to increase the scope of the national security state.
I will also mark a box indicating support for Susan Wismer or Mike Myers. That vote will certainly be a vote against Dennis Daugaard, a smiling Machiavellian who will pursue policies that guarantee "the least of these" continue to get less.
To her credit, Kristi Noem has taken to issuing press releases on the evils of human trafficking, but her vapid mouthing of red meat talking points will leave me not choice but to vote against her by checking the box next to Corinna Robinson's name. (I confess that I fear Robinson, whom I once had high hopes for as a candidate, will prove herself to be so ineffectual on the campaign trail that I may not vote for either one.)
When I mark the box next to Terry Winter's name, I will be voting for Terry Winter for District 18 Representative for the South Dakota House of Representatives. This vote will not be against incumbent Mike Stevens or Jean Hunhoff who is seeking this state house seat while Bernie Hunhoff runs for the state senate.
Terry will bring an understanding of what all of the polices imposed by Pierre have done to the average classroom teacher. Most importantly, he will fight for those Rounds, Duagaard, and the rest of the state's power structure have ignored. He will bring a sharp intellect and well honed wit to floor debates. Terry will speak truth to power with the wisdom of and, if one can trust Hollywood, the physical features and voice of an Old Testament prophet.
I have few illusions. Mike Stevens will have a campaign that's better funded than Terry's, and Stevens has conservative bona fides that ensure him a large base. Jean Hunhoff is part of a family dynasty; she too will have more than enough financial support; further, any vulnerabilities she may have lie to her right flank, political ground Winter does not occupy. For all I know, this endorsement may cost him a vote or two, although by November, most will have forgotten the post.
I am a realist and know that, if elected, Terry will cast votes I disagree with. Thankfully, he marches in lockstep with no one. It will be refreshing to vote enthusiastically for someone rather than against the status quo. Besides,anyone who can make less cynical about the political process, deserves to be elected.
In November, I will mark a box that indicates I chose Rick Weiland, Larry Pressler, or Gordon Howie to be South Dakota's next United States Senator. Whichever candidate I select, my vote likely will not be for him, It will be against Mike Rounds who created budgets that allowed his successor to decimate education funding in South Dakota and who will likely support every effort to increase the scope of the national security state.
I will also mark a box indicating support for Susan Wismer or Mike Myers. That vote will certainly be a vote against Dennis Daugaard, a smiling Machiavellian who will pursue policies that guarantee "the least of these" continue to get less.
To her credit, Kristi Noem has taken to issuing press releases on the evils of human trafficking, but her vapid mouthing of red meat talking points will leave me not choice but to vote against her by checking the box next to Corinna Robinson's name. (I confess that I fear Robinson, whom I once had high hopes for as a candidate, will prove herself to be so ineffectual on the campaign trail that I may not vote for either one.)
When I mark the box next to Terry Winter's name, I will be voting for Terry Winter for District 18 Representative for the South Dakota House of Representatives. This vote will not be against incumbent Mike Stevens or Jean Hunhoff who is seeking this state house seat while Bernie Hunhoff runs for the state senate.
Terry will bring an understanding of what all of the polices imposed by Pierre have done to the average classroom teacher. Most importantly, he will fight for those Rounds, Duagaard, and the rest of the state's power structure have ignored. He will bring a sharp intellect and well honed wit to floor debates. Terry will speak truth to power with the wisdom of and, if one can trust Hollywood, the physical features and voice of an Old Testament prophet.
I have few illusions. Mike Stevens will have a campaign that's better funded than Terry's, and Stevens has conservative bona fides that ensure him a large base. Jean Hunhoff is part of a family dynasty; she too will have more than enough financial support; further, any vulnerabilities she may have lie to her right flank, political ground Winter does not occupy. For all I know, this endorsement may cost him a vote or two, although by November, most will have forgotten the post.
I am a realist and know that, if elected, Terry will cast votes I disagree with. Thankfully, he marches in lockstep with no one. It will be refreshing to vote enthusiastically for someone rather than against the status quo. Besides,anyone who can make less cynical about the political process, deserves to be elected.
Labels:
Endorsement,
Local Politics
Scripture And Song For The Week: Ecclesiastes 7 Edition
Ecclesiastes 7
NIV
NIV
29 This only have I found: God created mankind upright, but they have gone in search of many schemes.”
Labels:
Scripture And Song For The Week
Saturday, June 7, 2014
South Dakota YouTube Channels?
I believe this post constitutes a bleg. I recently discovered that regular Madville Times commenter Stan Gibilisco has a rather extensive YouTube channel. Does anyone know of any other South Dakota YouTubers who produce content independentof the South Dakota blogosphere? Please let me know in the comments.
Labels:
YouTube Vids
Developing South Dakota's Democratic And Independent Candidates' Personas: Marvel Universe Edition
It's Saturday morning. The primary season made some folks testy and gave others a headache. There's going to be a long, hot, humid summer before Labor Day and then we will be bombarded by too many bad commercials and too much noisy campaigning between Labor Day and election day. It's time for a little levity.
The South .Dakota Republican candidates are prohibitive favorites in each of the statewide races that have been determined by primary: governor, United States Senate, and United States House of Representatives. It, therefore, behooves fans of both politics and comics to look at what Marvel Comics personas the Loyal Opposition, a motley but plucky collective who will be opposing the Republican nominees, should adopt.
In the United States Senate race, the Republicans have nominated Mike Rounds who seems protected by Teflon and Kevlar. He will be opposed by Democrat Rick Weiland and Independents Larry Pressler and Gordon Howie.
Having visited every town in South Dakota, loyal opponent Rick Weiland has showed he has plenty of endurance, one of 'Wolverine's powers. All Weiland needs to do is add adamantium claws and mean streak to cut through both Teflon and Kevlar.
Gordon Howie wants to bring true conservative thunder to the race. Quite frankly, the best fit for anyone trying to bring that thunder is Thor, the Norse god of thunder. Taking on the persona of a pagan god might also allow Howie to show that he's willing to be inclusive of those beyond his conservative Christian base.
Former Senator Larry Pressler has been out of the public view since he left office in January of 1997. Captain America was on ice from the end of World War II until the Avengers revived him in the early 1960s. Captain America uses his age to bring to the fore good old-fashioned American virtues; Pressler has video of his ability to avoid the vice of greed. Rounds association with EB 5 program and its assorted irregularities may make him vulnerable on that front. More importantly Pressler has political history that is being mined for for weak spots. Cap's shield may come in handy if Rounds decides to run a a few attack ads.
In the gubernatorial race, incumbent Dennis Daugaard will face loyal opponents Democrat Susan Wismer and Independent Mike Myers.
Conventional wisdom has it that Wismer needs to bring a little lightning to her campaign. No female superhero can do that job better than Storm.
Myers is the longest of long shots who needs to dramatically alter all known laws of probability. Fortunately, the Marvel Universe has a relatively unknown character with the proper name and probability altering powers, Longshot.
Finally Corinna Robinson needs to demonstrate strength and intellect to defeat incumbent Republican Congresswoman Kristi Noem. Although the individual titles have been played for laughs, She-Hulk's appearance is assorted team books demonstrate the character has the necessary power, intellect, and wit that Robinson will need to dispatch Noem.
There you have, The Loyal Opposition. The name doesn't have the ring of The Avengers, but should Democrats and Independents adopt these personas, the races might be a little closer and a little more interesting.
The South .Dakota Republican candidates are prohibitive favorites in each of the statewide races that have been determined by primary: governor, United States Senate, and United States House of Representatives. It, therefore, behooves fans of both politics and comics to look at what Marvel Comics personas the Loyal Opposition, a motley but plucky collective who will be opposing the Republican nominees, should adopt.
In the United States Senate race, the Republicans have nominated Mike Rounds who seems protected by Teflon and Kevlar. He will be opposed by Democrat Rick Weiland and Independents Larry Pressler and Gordon Howie.
Having visited every town in South Dakota, loyal opponent Rick Weiland has showed he has plenty of endurance, one of 'Wolverine's powers. All Weiland needs to do is add adamantium claws and mean streak to cut through both Teflon and Kevlar.
Gordon Howie wants to bring true conservative thunder to the race. Quite frankly, the best fit for anyone trying to bring that thunder is Thor, the Norse god of thunder. Taking on the persona of a pagan god might also allow Howie to show that he's willing to be inclusive of those beyond his conservative Christian base.
Former Senator Larry Pressler has been out of the public view since he left office in January of 1997. Captain America was on ice from the end of World War II until the Avengers revived him in the early 1960s. Captain America uses his age to bring to the fore good old-fashioned American virtues; Pressler has video of his ability to avoid the vice of greed. Rounds association with EB 5 program and its assorted irregularities may make him vulnerable on that front. More importantly Pressler has political history that is being mined for for weak spots. Cap's shield may come in handy if Rounds decides to run a a few attack ads.
In the gubernatorial race, incumbent Dennis Daugaard will face loyal opponents Democrat Susan Wismer and Independent Mike Myers.
Conventional wisdom has it that Wismer needs to bring a little lightning to her campaign. No female superhero can do that job better than Storm.
Myers is the longest of long shots who needs to dramatically alter all known laws of probability. Fortunately, the Marvel Universe has a relatively unknown character with the proper name and probability altering powers, Longshot.
Finally Corinna Robinson needs to demonstrate strength and intellect to defeat incumbent Republican Congresswoman Kristi Noem. Although the individual titles have been played for laughs, She-Hulk's appearance is assorted team books demonstrate the character has the necessary power, intellect, and wit that Robinson will need to dispatch Noem.
There you have, The Loyal Opposition. The name doesn't have the ring of The Avengers, but should Democrats and Independents adopt these personas, the races might be a little closer and a little more interesting.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


_from_Avengers_21_Infinity.jpg)



