Wednesday, June 5, 2013

Quotation Of The Day: Lewis Versus Rand Edition

If there ever was any doubt, although none should have existed, C.S. Lewis was a first-rate thinker; Ayn Rand was not. From this Mark Kleiman post:
In general, Rand deserves her followers, while Lewis emphatically does not deserve his. (I can just imagine Lewis’s reaction had he lived to see Ollie North (!) living in a mansion called “Narnia.”) Lewis was a superb writer of persuasive prose (I’d put him in the Orwell class) and, on average, a far clearer and more original thinker than Rand, whose “philosophy” is mostly Nietzsche-and-water. You don’t have to be a Christian to admire the brilliance of Screwtape, or its insight into some aspects of moral psychology and of bureaucratic life.

Tuesday, June 4, 2013

The Best Written Television Series Of All Time?

The Writers Guild of America has published a list of the 101 best television series. Writing for the Guild, Paul Brownfield praises character development:
Then, as now, it comes down to character—from Lucy Ricardo and Archie Bunker to Andy Griffith and Andy Sipowicz. There are kinships across generations—from The Honeymooners to Roseanne, say, or from The Twilight Zone to Lost. Regardless of the year, or genre, what emerges is a common dynamic between show and audience, the kind of lasting intimacy that writers telling episodic stories are uniquely able to achieve.
As a teacher, I agree with Brownfield's sentiments, but I'm not sure the programs were listed in order of the best character development. That quibble doesn't really matter. Lists like these aren't about the best series or the best characters. These lists exist for a single purpose: people like me get to argue about slights and irrational high ranks.

The Top Ten contains no real surprises.

  1. The Sopranos
  2. Seinfeld
  3. The Twilight Zone
  4. All in the Family
  5. M*A*S*H
  6. The Mary Tyler Moore Show
  7. Mad Men
  8. Cheers
  9. The Wire
  10. The West Wing
I might want The Wire to be a little higher on the list, but that's a quibble. Some purists might want I Love Lucy in the top 10; it came in at 12. Those same folks might be apoplectic that Lucy lost out to The Simpsons at 11.

Let's go to my biggest complaints. Friday Night Lights was ranked 22; House was ranked 74. I'd switch those. I loved Buffy the Vampire Slayer, but 49 is pretty high. I'd put it somewhere in the 70s.  I also thought Friends and The Larry Sanders should have been in the bottom half not the top 25. Deadwood came in at 32. I would not have put it on the list at all. Twin Peaks came in at 35 but should have made the top 20.

The best part of the list is confirmation of one of my long held biases, so no one should argue about this placement. It's obvious and unarguable. The original Star Trek is superior to Star Trek: The Next Generation. Kirk, Spock, Scotty, and Uhura were simply better characters than Picard, Riker, Troi, and Data. Star Trek came 33; TNG came was ranked 79.

Quotations Of The Day: Justice Scalia's Dissent In Maryland v King

From Justice Scalia's Maryland v King dissent:
So, to review: DNA testing does not even begin until after arraignment and bail decisions are already made. The samples sit in storage for months, and take weeks to test. When they are tested, they are checked against the Unsolved Crimes Collection—rather than the Convict and Arrestee Collection, which could be used to identify them.The Act forbids the Court’s purpose (identification), but prescribes as its purpose what our suspicionless-search cases forbid (“official investigation into a crime”). Against all of that, it is safe to say that if the Court’s identification theory is not wrong, there is no such thing as error. . .  
The Court disguises the vast (and scary) scope of its holding by promising a limitation it cannot deliver. The Court repeatedly says that DNA testing, and entry into a national DNA registry, will not befall thee and me, dear reader, but only those arrested for “serious offense[s].” Ante, at 28; see also ante, at 1, 9, 14, 17, 22, 23, 24 (repeatedly limiting the analysis to “serious offenses”). I cannot imagine what principle could possibly justify this limitation, and the Court does not attempt to suggest any. If one believes that DNA will “identify” someone arrested for assault, he must believe that it will “identify” someone arrested for a traffic offense. This Court does not base its judgments on senseless distinctions. At the end of the day, logic will out. When there comes before us the taking of DNA from an arrestee for a traffic violation, the Court will predictably (and quite rightly) say, “We can find no significant difference between this case and King.” Make no mistake about it: As an entirely predictable consequence of today’s decision, your DNA can be taken and entered into a national DNA database if you are ever arrested, rightly or wrongly, and for whatever reason. . . .
Today’s judgment will, to be sure, have the beneficial effect of solving more crimes; then again, so would the taking of DNA samples from anyone who flies on an airplane (surely the Transportation Security Administration needs to know the “identity” of the flying public), applies for a driver’s license, or attends a public school. Perhaps the construction of such a genetic panopticon is wise. But I doubt that the proud men who wrote the charter of our liberties would have been so eager to open their mouths for royal inspection.
I therefore dissent, and hope that today’s incursion upon the Fourth Amendment, like an earlier one, will some day be repudiated. [Emphasis Mine]
Suffice it to say, this decision needs to be overturned as quickly as possible. I still marvel at the fact that people scream bloody murder at any perceived abridgment of Second Amendment protections but are silent at real abridgments of Fourth Amendment rights.

Monday, June 3, 2013

An Open Memo To Common Core Opponents

To: Common Core Opponents
From: The Displaced Plainsman
Subject: Anonymous Letters
Date: June 3, 2013

I too have serious misgivings about the Common Core and what its implementation might mean. Some of you are making it much harder for rest of us to be taken seriously.

Let me give you an example. Today, while I was sitting in a workshop that I'm taking so that I can keep my teacher certification, the professor told us that she and her husband, who is also an educator, had received a letter filled with cut and paste anti-Core rants. The letter also contained links to anti-Core sites.

As a teacher, I'm supposed to provide some positive feedback. In this case, those who sent this letter should be commended for not using letters physically cut from assorted newspapers and magazines. It's always good to avoid having one's anonymous letter resemble a kidnapper's ransom note.

Now for the negative but helpful criticism. I will to start gently as I can. HOW CAN YOU BE SO STUPID AND STILL BREATHE?

Tactics like this marginalize people who have practical reasons for opposing the Core. Any criticism is now waved off as the rantings of lunatics who fear black helicopters and believe the Core is going to usher in the mark of the Beast.

Perhaps you have been indoctrinated by Nike and its "Just Do It" campaign. Nike made a lot of money from that campaign, but sometimes it not enough to just do something. How one does something is frequently as important as what one does. In this case opposing the Core may well be the right thing to do. How you're doing it, however, is so wrong that it's actually hurting your cause.


Sunday, June 2, 2013

National Republican Senatorial Committee Weighs In On South Dakota Senate Race

From Politico, Senator Jerry Moran (R-Kansas) has weighed in on the South Dakota Republican efforts to win the United States Senate seat currently held by Tim Johnson:
Sen. Jerry Moran (R-Kan.), the chair of the NRSC, all but endorsed the GOP establishment favorites running for open Senate seats next year in West Virginia and South Dakota.
In an interview Sunday on C-SPAN’s “Newsmakers,” Moran said he had “great confidence and faith” in Rep. Shelley Moore Capito (R-W. Va.) and former South Dakota Gov. Mike Rounds, the Republican front-runners to capture seats held by a pair of retiring Democrats.
“She seems to be clearly on her way to being nominated as the Republican candidate in West Virginia,” the campaign committee chairman said of Capito, calling her “a great House member.” Moran was nearly as effusive in praising Rounds, describing the former two-term governor as an “outstanding candidate.”
Capito and Rounds have drawn criticism from conservatives, including the Club for Growth, for their fiscal records but have not yet been met with daunting primary challengers. Moran’s comments suggest Senate Republicans would prefer to keep it that way.
It will be interesting to see how the Republican right wing deals with this pseudo endorsement. I'm guessing loudly and unhappily. 

Scripture And Song Of The Week: Gospel Of John 9 Edition

KJV
1 And as Jesus passed by, he saw a man which was blind from his birth.
2 And his disciples asked him, saying, Master, who did sin, this man, or his parents, that he was born blind?
3 Jesus answered, Neither hath this man sinned, nor his parents: but that the works of God should be made manifest in him.
4 I must work the works of him that sent me, while it is day: the night cometh, when no man can work.
5 As long as I am in the world, I am the light of the world.
6 When he had thus spoken, he spat on the ground, and made clay of the spittle, and he anointed the eyes of the blind man with the clay,
7 And said unto him, Go, wash in the pool of Siloam, (which is by interpretation, Sent.) He went his way therefore, and washed, and came seeing.

Saturday, June 1, 2013

Racists Protest Cheerios Ad

I love Cheerios, so I never pay much attention to their ads. I'm going to buy the cereal anyway. Apparently others watch the ads more carefully than I do. I wonder if those who protested this Cheerios ad have full possession of the reasoning skills God gave them.



According to the New York Daily News, they may not:
An innocent ad for heart-healthy Cheerios has sparked an onslaught of disturbing racist backlash on the Internet.
The cereal brand was forced to pull comments from its YouTube page after a cereal commercial featuring an interracial family reportedly prompted a string of messages about Nazis, racial genocide and viewers so disgusted they “want to vomit.”
Adweek adds some perspective:
It's another one of those things that shouldn't be a story but is—an ad from a major U.S. brand featuring an interracial couple and their daughter. You'd think this new Cheerios ad from Saatchi & Saatchi in New York might go largely unnoticed, given the plethora of interracial couples on TV shows these days. (NBC's Parenthood is a notable example, though far from the only one.) But it's not going unnoticed—it hit Reddit's front page, a place largely reserved for life's great oddities, and the YouTube view count is rising fast. The problem is that TV ads have always lagged TV programming in this regard, as so many brands are clearly scared of being perceived as making a political statement with the casting of their commercials. Thus, the Cheerios ad, despite its characters being representative of tens of thousands of actual couples in America, sticks out like a sore thumb. And then you have the YouTube comments section, which predictably has devolved into an endless flame war, with references to Nazis, "troglodytes" and "racial genocide." At what point will an ad like this just seem normal?
When I got the link to put the YouTube clip in this post, I noticed that 1153 people disliked the ad. I wonder was Brad Ford one of them?

Update: Someone using the pseudonym Herman V stopped by to tell me and the world that nothing good comes from putting blacks and whites together. I was going to let the comment stand, but it also included a link I didn't trust, so I removed it. Suffice it to say, Herman and I disagree about his statements.