Thursday, January 3, 2013

Quotations Of The Day: Literary Allusion And Assault On Civil Liberties Edition

First Judge Colleen McMahon uses the two literary classics to describe her ruling that the Constitution doesn't allow the President to assassinate American citizens but that the Administration does not have to release internal memoranda that justify ordering assassinations:
“I can find no way around the thicket of laws and precedents that effectively allow the executive branch of our government to proclaim as perfectly lawful certain actions that seem on their face incompatible with our Constitution and laws while keeping the reasons for their conclusion a secret,” she wrote.
“The Alice-in-Wonderland nature of this pronouncement is not lost on me,” Judge McMahon wrote, adding that she was operating in a legal environment that amounted to “a veritable Catch-22.”
Conor Friedersdorf begins his analysis of McMahon's ruling with two more literary references:
Permitted to run CNN for a day, I'd amuse myself by arranging for a Crossfire-style debate between English professors who disagree intensely about how best to characterize President Obama's national security policies. "They're Orwellian," one would insist. "They're actually better described as Kafkaesque," the other would counter. They'd go back and forth, citing his transgressions against basic norms of justice and comparing them to plot points from dystopian novels. Poor Wolf Blitzer. He'd be horrified by a segment that afforded so little deference to a sitting president.

Implementing Common Core In South Dakota May Mean No Debate

Or at least no high school debate classes.

Currently South Dakota high school students must earn 4 language arts credits.  Those credits must include 1.5 writing credits, 1.5 literature credits. That literature requirement specifies that a student must take a semester of American Literature. The requirements also mandate a half credit of speech or debate and allow for a half credit language arts elective.

A new proposal that I'm told will be taken up this spring will operate under the principle that "each standard need not be a separate focus for instruction and assessment." In short, students many no longer be required to take American Literature along with speech or debate in order to earn a high school diploma.

Eliminating the speech or debate requirement is problematic and counter-intuitive on several levels.

First, the Common Core emphasizes non-fiction reading. Preparing debate cases requires that students read news articles, research students, white papers, and philosophical texts. No one sites Flannery O'Connor or Nathaniel Hawthorne in a policy debate round. Sometimes, I wish they would, but that's a topic for another day.

Second, debate requires students to evaluate sources and be aware of source bias. More importantly, speech and debate textbooks have units on propaganda techniques and recognizing logical fallacies. Given that fact checking has of necessity become a cottage industry. Politicians and pundits make a career by using facts to prove points that those facts were not intended to prove. TV advertisements use every logical fallacy imaginable to get consumers to buy products the consumer probably doesn't need. In short, recognizing logical fallacies and propaganda seems a necessary 21st Century life skill

Senator Russel Olson wants colleges and universities to teach students to be primarily good workers not necessarily good thinkers. If Olson's bill passes, high school speech and debate classes may be one of the few chances students get to question presumptions and construct arguments.

Of course, it's possible that Olson and those behind the proposal that will eliminate the debate requirement don't want citizens to think but just do what they're told. If that's the case, then South Dakota needs more not fewer debate classes.

Wednesday, January 2, 2013

2013 Resolutions Part 2

I found these three posts about resolutions interesting and thought I would share them.

This Ken Santema Libertarian reminder is thought provoking.

Although not resolution specific, this longer post about the Jerry Seinfeld productivity method that consists of not breaking the chain seems helpful for disorganized folk with short attention spans when it comes to doing mundane tasks. I am one of those people.

Finally, this list of low-key resolutions has two that I really need to follow:
1. Listen longer before responding.
2. Ask more questions.




Tuesday, January 1, 2013

New Year's Day Geek Post: All The Bruce Waynes Morphed Into One

From this IO9.com post:
Still debating on which Hollywood representation of Bruce Wayne was the very best? No need to anymore. Here is a shot of every single actor who has played the live action superhero morphed into one perfect Batman. It includes Adam West, Michael Keaton, Val Kilmer, George Clooney, and Christian Bale. This comes from Redditor morphinapg. Personally we would have left Kilmer's lips, but that is still one fine looking troubled millionaire.


I have to admit that I'd be much more interested to see a photo morphing all of the actresses who have played Catwoman: Julie Newmar, Lee Merriweather, Eartha Kitt, Michelle Pfeiffer, Halle Berry, and Anne Hathaway. The following YouTube video includes all of the actresses except Hathaway.



A Minor Musing About The Certainty Of A Middle Class Tax Increase

The Washington Post points out that Americans who depend on a paycheck will have a tax increase under the deal that Vice-President Joe Biden and Senator Mitch McConnell negotiated.
The deal negotiated by Vice President Biden and Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) addresses a separate tax — the income tax — and would prevent tax rates from increasing for all but the wealthiest Americans. But both sides have decided to leave the payroll tax out of the agreement.

Unlike income taxes, which rise along with a worker’s income, the payroll tax is a fixed percentage of an employee’s salary. Allowing the tax cut to expire increases taxes on salaries by 2 percent for every American worker. Up to $110,100 a year in salary is subject to the tax.
First, I have to admit that I'm ambivalent about about the payroll tax holiday lapsing. I don't like the idea that my paycheck is going to be decreased 2%, but I realize that payroll taxes affect social security benefits.

The thing that really bugs me about the end of the payroll tax holiday is that Mitt Romney and others of his ilk can smile their plastic smiles and chuckle woodenly that the 47% got what was coming to them, more taxes. Meanwhile, Romney et al. will be setting up another tax shelter in the Caymans.

Monday, December 31, 2012

Why Common Core Standards Concern Me: A Weather Analogy

For those who skipped the post's title, what follows is an analogy.

The Common Core emphasizes non-fiction, so students should be able to read nonfiction like the following tidbits from the Weather Channel.


The Core's strongest advocates might want students to understand classic literary references to weather or seasons like the following song. They'd probably love this Sinatra version has the benefit of a spelling lesson, but they might bemoan the fact that it's too romantic.


The Core's proponents seemingly don't understand that facts, classics and spelling lessons may not make the point as well as a simple regional story told well. What follows may be hyperbolic, but it combines the realism of a weather report with the literary elements of the more popular song. If it were literature being taught in an English class, it's the type of work that the Core would force teachers to cut so that the teacher could have students read the weather report.


Quotation Of The Day: Republican Party Devoid Of Soul

From former Republican presidential candidate John Huntsman in this Daily Telegraph interview:
"The party right now is a holding company that's devoid of a soul and it will be filled up with ideas over time and leaders will take their proper place,"