Monday, September 17, 2012

Quotations Of The Day: The Hollowness Of The Common Core Edition

From this Marion Brady post on The Answer Sheet:

First, a bit of common sense that the Core ignores:
Knowledge grows as we connect bits of it — as we discover relationships between, say, street width and sense of community, between birth order and certain personality traits, between capital investment decisions and political stability.

Compartmentalizing knowledge gets directly in the way of the basic process that makes kids (and the rest of us) smarter.
Then, of course there are a few other secrets that reformers and Core advocates try to ignore:
The standards have been swallowed by just about everybody, and as soon as they’ve been digested, Pearson, McGraw-Hill, Educational Testing Service, and other manufacturers of standardized tests will be ready with contracts in hand for computerized tests in numbers sufficient to crash web servers.

The tests, of course, will build in a failure rate set by some faceless decision-maker — an easily operated spigot for meeting stockholder expectations. Open it — boost the failure rate — and up go sales of tests, test prep tools, instructional materials. And, of course, profits.

Even if I’m wrong about the eight other problems with the Common Core Standards (and I’m not), I don’t see any wiggle room on this one. If I’m right, the current reform effort’s centralizing of control of education, its micromanaging of classrooms by non-educators, its blocking of all innovation not tied to the core, and its reliance on destructive, simplistic tests that fail to take account of the fundamental nature of knowledge, and of human complexity and variability, will, in Senge’s words, exact an “enormous price."

That price will be the inability of our children and our children’s children to cope with a future shaping up to be more challenging than anything humans have thus far faced.

A Brief Musical Interlude For Those Of Us Who Don't Like Mondays


Sunday, September 16, 2012

An Important Reminder About Voters And Politics

Tod Kelly attended the recently conlcuded Value Voters Summit and comes away asserting "the attendees I was fortunate enough to meet – . . . were, to a man and woman, incredibly salt-0f-the-Earth nice people."

He goes on to make eleven brief observations about the people who spoke to these attendees. My favorites:
So, in no particular order, here are the top ten things I learned from the Values Voter Summit Main Stage speakers:
1. By the tally I kept, the number of times I heard Main Floor Speakers not named Paul Ryan mention Barack Obama: 157. Number of times I heard Main Floor Speakers not named Paul Ryan mention Mitt Romney: 5. . . .
3. The Obama administration has begun secretly plotting with the Organization for Islamic Cooperation. They have begun to “brainwash” FBI and other security agents to be receptive to the messages of Islam, so that Sharia law speech laws can be enforced unchallenged after Obama’s reelection. (Michelle Bachmann, US Rep-MN). . .
7. The Obama administration is planning to make illegal all churches and synagogues, and put in jail any Americans that attend them. This will happen this January, “March at the latest.” (Kamal Saleem, Debunked Ex-Terrorist Impersonator). . . .
8. Arizona Governor Jan Brewer was apparently told early on that politicians smile big all the time. So now when she talks about terrible tragedies like the brutal the murder of Robert Krentz or Chris Stevens, she does so with a beaming, 100 megawatt smile that looks like she’s about to break out in the giggles. It comes off looking very creepy. Seriously, her people need to sit her down and talk to her about this. . . .
9. When Rand Paul opened the conference, he talked about the sanctity of human life, in regard to human fetuses, to thunderous, leap-out-of-your-chair applause. He continued to underline this philosophy by pivoting to the subject of war, where he said, “Truly great leaders are reluctant to go to war.” The crowd got pretty quiet on him after that. . . .
And this ones not really about a speaker, so I’ll throw it in as a bonus fun fact:
11. Friday morning before Paul Ryan came out, they showed a video presentation honoring the Heritage Foundation. The video ended with stills of famous conservatives that had worked with the foundation, and each got a different level of applause by the audience, based on how popular the pictured conservative was. Not surprisingly, the picture of Paul Ryan got the loudest. The next biggest cheers went to a picture of Limbaugh, followed by one of Hannity, and right behind him was George W. Bush. One of the pictures that got the least, shockingly, was the picture of Reagan, who got what might be called a polite, golf-clap smattering. This may have been the most surprising moment of the conference for me.
The fact that Rush Limbaugh and Sean Hannity can earn bigger applause than Ronald Reagan says a lot about the state of America's alleged conservatives. None of what is says should be considered good. The fact that a call to be "reluctant to go to war" quieted a crowd of "salt-of-the-Earth-nice people" should frighten us all.






A USB Typewriter? Yes, Please!



HT: Kasia Cieplak-Mayr von Baldegg writing in the The Atlantic

Quotations Of The Day: Something's Rotten In The State Of South Dakota Edition

From Stan Adelstein, a South Dakota State Senator, in this comment on the Madville Times:
Somehow South Dakota is losing something - call it honesty and transparency - call [it people's] rights before someone's big dollar interest!
He also writes:
But, but what is going on? . . .  I never saw anything like this in the Rounds or Janklow administrations -- and I was kind of in the know. My only embarrassment is, that at my age and with my business experiences I should have known what some people were trying to do.
Everyone who goes through high school has probably heard the Lord Acton statement “Power tends to corrupt and absolute power corrupt absolutely." It's become a cliche, but South Dakota voters should never doubt that Acton is correct. When one party has absolute power in a state, that power will continue to corrupt.






Scripture And Song Of The Week: Job Edition

Job 38
NIV
 4 “Where were you when I laid the earth’s foundation?
    Tell me, if you understand.
5 Who marked off its dimensions? Surely you know!
    Who stretched a measuring line across it?
6 On what were its footings set,
    or who laid its cornerstone—
7 while the morning stars sang together
    and all the angels[a] shouted for joy?

8 “Who shut up the sea behind doors
    when it burst forth from the womb,
9 when I made the clouds its garment
    and wrapped it in thick darkness,
10 when I fixed limits for it
    and set its doors and bars in place,
11 when I said, ‘This far you may come and no farther;
    here is where your proud waves halt’?

Saturday, September 15, 2012

A Saturday Night Song

I am finding this a perfect Saturday night song; I must be getting old.