Friday, May 4, 2012

Am I My Wealthy Bothers' Keeper?

In an April 30 Slate interview Malcolm Gladwell argues that college football should be banned.  When asked about the National Football League, Gladwell responds,
As long as the risks are explicit, the players warned, and those injured properly compensated, then I'm not sure we can stop people from playing. A better question is whether it is ethical to WATCH football. That's a harder question.
Since then, Junior Seau committed suicide, shooting himself in the chest in an apparent effort to preserve his brain to be tested for concussion related damage.


Ta-Nehisi Coates, a senior editor for The Atlantic, believes that Seau's death makes the answer obvious.
I'm not so sure that it's hard at all. The answer, at least for those displeased with pro football's response, seems pretty clear. Doing the damn thing is the hard part.
I now know that I have to go. I have known it for a while now. But I have yet to walk away. For me, the hardest portion is living apart--destroying something that binds me to friends and family. With people whom I would not pass another words, I can debate the greatest running back of all time. It's like losing a language.
Coates and Gladwell hit on two important points.  The National Football League dominates America's sports calendar.  It entertains and provides metaphors that organize businesses and individual's social lives.  The League's coaches and star players are some of the most requested speakers.  Any book that bears their names becomes an automatic best-seller.


The men who play professionally chose to do so  and are handsomely rewarded for their efforts.  It is, however, becoming more obvious that playing the game professionally kills many.  The deaths are premature and painful.  In the case of Seau and Dave Duerson, they seemed to become different people prior to their suicides

I spend a huge portion of my Sundays from September through February watching the National Football League. Like Coates, I use it as a language to communicate.  It's a useful one with many students.

Coates and Gladwell are making me wonder if I need to change that habit and find other ways to communicate.  I haven't thought about this as long as Coates, and I haven't made the decisions that he has, but I have difficulty ethically justifying being entertained by people who end their lives prematurely to provide that entertainment.

Wednesday, May 2, 2012

You Shall Know The Truth And The Truth Shall Set You Free

Offered without comment because it's so fantastic.

And So It Starts....The Red Herring Slippery Slope Defense Of HB 1234

Bob Mercer issues a talking point that one will hear the Governor's supporters use to defend HB 1234: The Unions Will Come!!! The Unions Will Come!!! The Unions Will Come!!! Oh! The Horror!!! The Unions Will Come !!!!

The story will go something like this. HB 1234 is our sainted Governor's response to a uniquely South Dakota problem. (The fact that Republican governors Jindal, Walker, Christie et al. have proposed similar anti-teacher legislation will be conveniently ignored.)

This effort to save South Dakota schools from teachers is now going to be confounded by evil, vile out of state agitators who advocate terrible ideas like workers should be paid well. These heinous enemies of all that is right and good may even believe in evolution.

In this narrative, South Dakota teachers will be either the vanguard of a 5th column or witless dupes led astray by out of state agitators, the serpents in the South Dakota Eden. Focus group polling is likely taking place now to determine how to frame teachers in this debate.

Once the antagonists have been defined, the slippery slope will take shape. Unions will arrive in South Dakota; teachers will demand and receive more money; when teachers get paid more, other workers will demand hirer pay. When teachers get paid more, taxes will rise. When other workers get paid more, businesses will be less profitable. When taxes rise and businesses become less profitable, every business except McDonalds, which pays only minimum wage, will leave the state. When McDonalds is the only business left in a state, the citizens lives become nasty, brutish, and short.

The choice will be clear: either support "all of the . . . changes in the 65-section bill" or live in a state that allows outside agitators to provide "support for anti-1234 candidates for the Legislature and to campaign against the Republican incumbents who voted to pass 1234."

Governor Daugaard is likely negotiating right now to hire the person who created ads like this one for Direct TV to write ads for the save HB 1234 campaign.

Quotation Of The Day: Stephen King On Being Rich Edition

Although I haven't read much of King's fiction, I heartily recommend On Writing.  I'm going to have to buy a few King books after reading this:
Here’s another crock of fresh bullshit delivered by the right wing of the Republican Party (which has become, so far as I can see, the only wing of the Republican Party): the richer rich people get, the more jobs they create. Really? I have a total payroll of about 60 people, most of them working for the two radio stations I own in Bangor, Maine. If I hit the movie jackpot—as I have, from time to time—and own a piece of a film that grosses $200 million, what am I going to do with it? Buy another radio station? I don’t think so, since I’m losing my shirt on the ones I own already. But suppose I did, and hired on an additional dozen folks. Good for them. Whoopee-ding for the rest of the economy.
At the risk of repeating myself, here’s what rich folks do when they get richer:they invest. A lot of those investments are overseas, thanks to the anti-American business policies of the last four administrations. Don’t think so? Check the tag on that T-shirt or gimme cap you’re wearing. If it says MADE IN AMERICA, I’ll … well, I won’t say I’ll eat your shorts, because some of that stuff ismade here, but not much of it. And what does get made here doesn’t get made by America’s small cadre of pluted bloatocrats; it’s made, for the most part, in barely-gittin’-by factories in the Deep South, where the only unions people believe in are those solemnized at the altar of the local church (as long as they’re from different sexes, that is).

Tuesday, May 1, 2012

Quotation Of The Day: Why Teachers Are Angry Edition

From this Dana Goldstein article in The Nation
It is difficult to generalize about the opinions of any group as large and diverse as public school teachers, of which there are about 3.2 million. But it can’t be good news that a survey of teachers released in March by MetLife found the lowest job satisfaction numbers since 1989, with just 44 percent of respondents describing themselves as “very satisfied” with their classroom careers, down from 59 percent in 2009 and 62 percent in 2008. According to MetLife, nearly a third of public school teachers are considering leaving their jobs. . . . .
But polling shows teachers are depressed by the increasing reliance on standardized tests to measure student learning—the “high stakes” testing regime that the standards and accountability movement has put in place across the country and that Race to the Top has reinforced in some states and districts. Teachers are also concerned that growing numbers of parents are not able to play an active role in their children’s education, and they are angry about the climate of austerity that has invaded the nation’s schools, with state and local budget cuts threatening key programs that help students learn and overcome the disadvantages of poverty.
I would add that it would be nice if politicians would invite a few more teachers to the table when policies are being determined.

I've Learned About Another Freedom

Hugh MacLeod who built an Internet cult following with his recommendations about how to be creative and his skill at doing interesting artwork on the back of business cards, has written a paean to blogging: Freedom Is Blogging in Your Underwear.  He has made made a few of his works free for bloggers to use as they see fit.

I decided to give myself a reminder that if I want to be a hipster blogger like this cat,



I really need to remember not to rise to every piece of political bait.