Thursday, July 7, 2011

Of Facts and Arguments

I've posted about Chris Mooney's research on ideological blinders before.  Today's New York Times "The Stone" column by Gary Gutting, a professor of philosophy at the University of Notre Dame, serves as useful reminder that facts alone do not create a successful argument.

Professor Gutting sums up current political debate quite well:  On side "put[s] forward a barrage of indisputable facts that show, with a very high probability, that [their] view is correct. But [the other side] construct[s] an equally impressive argument refuting [that] view."

Both sides have strong arguments for two reasons according to Gutting.  First,
Even a strong argument from purely factual premises is open to refutation unless we are assured that it has taken account of all relevant facts. Realistically, of course, we can never be sure that we have taken account of all relevant facts, especially with an issue as complex as a national budget.
Professor Gutting could have added education, Medicare, Social Security, nation building, war, and a host of other political dilemmas to the list. 

Second, Gutting points out that even if one succeeded in getting all of the relevant facts, one would "try to reinterpret the facts in light of fundamental convictions."

The whole article is worth reading, but Gutting makes two key statements worth remembering in any debate.  First,
Ignoring relevant facts can give us false confidence in the strength of our positions in political debates.
Second,
Each of us may conclude that the other is irrational or ignorant.  But we should beware of the sense of the inviolability of our own positions when what we really need is a serious effort to argue from all the relevant facts.
I will be bold enough to add two more suggestions to the Gutting's conclusions.  Know the ideological blinders of your sources and try to find out what facts they are ignoring.

Update: My Fellow Teachers Do Something Stupid

The National Education Association (NEA) endorsed President Obama and thus squandered whatever political influence it might have. Less than a week after that announcement, the President had a Twitter Town Hall and was posed with the following question.
MR. DORSEY:  So 10 percent of our questions now are about education, and this one was surfaced from our curator in California by Marcia:  “Public education here in California is falling apart, not graduating enough skilled workers or smart citizens.  Privatization looming?”
Given that Obama has just received NEA's endorsement, one would expect a ringing defense of public education.  Instead, President Obama offered the following:
THE PRESIDENT:  Look, when America was making a transition from an agricultural society to an industrial society, we as a country made a decision that we were going to have public high schools that would upgrade the skills of young people as they were leaving the farms and start participating in a more complex industrial economy.  When my grandfather’s generation came back from World War II, we made a decision that we were going to have a GI Bill that would send these young people to college because we figured that would help advance our economy.

Every time we’ve made a public investment in education, it has paid off many times over.  For us now to give short shrift to education when the world is more complex than ever, and it’s a knowledge-based society and companies locate based on whether they’ve got skilled workforces or not, that makes no sense.

     And so we’ve got to get our priorities straight here.  It is important for us to have a healthy business climate, to try to keep taxes low, to make sure that we’re not spending on things that don’t work.  It’s important that we get a good bang for the buck in education.  And so my administration has pushed more reform more vigorously across the country through things like Race to the Top than most previous administrations have been able to accomplish.  So we don’t just need more money; we need more reform.

     But we do have to pay for good teachers.  Young, talented people aren’t going to go into teaching if they’re getting paid a poverty wage.  We do have to make sure that buildings aren’t crumbling.  It's pretty hard for kids to concentrate if there are leaks and it’s cold and there are rats running around in their schools.  And that’s true in a lot of schools around the country.

We do have to make sure that there are computers in a computer age inside classrooms, and that they work and that there’s Internets that are actually -- there are Internet connections that actually function.

And I think that those states that are going to do well and those countries that do well are the ones that are going to continue to be committed to making education a priority.
I appreciate history lessons, but the list of public education successes should be followed by "I will do everything in my power to support public education."  Instead the declaration was followed by a paragraph that could have been written by the Cato Institute.  OK, Cato would not have endorsed Race to the Top, so I probably would prefer the Cato response to Obama's. 

I'm glad the NEA endorsement produced such positive results so quickly.

If NEA and Obama won't stand up for public education, I'll offer the following as a step by by step explanation of why public education needs to be preserved.

First, I agree with the statement attributed to Thomas Jefferson: "If we're going to have a successful democratic society, we have to have a well educated and healthy citizenry."

Second, as the astute Cory Heidelberger points out, Americans are "the first great nationality based on rational choice rather than blood."  Mr. Heidelberger could have added that Americans are not united by religion, language, crown, or geographic features.

Third, nations need both principles and institutions to unify the people.  (I don't have a source for this one, but I'll be happy to debate it with anyone who wishes.)

Fourth, absent a national religion or monarchy, I submit the the most logical unifying institution is the public school.

Private schools will produce the same unifying results as Coke, Pepsi, 7-Up, and Dr. Pepper.  Have you ever tried offering a Pepsi to a Coke drinker?  Perhaps I'm exaggerating a bit; they might unify as well as McDonalds, Wendy's, Taco Johns, and Burger King.

If President Obama can't or won't enunciate the essential need for public education, and apparently he will not, NEA had no reason to endorse him

Wednesday, July 6, 2011

Some Minor Musings About Commuincation, Education, and High School Debate

The Web may never replace the physical classroom, but like public schools it gives away what many businesses pay experts thousands of dollars to tell them.  Today's prime example is Joe Carter's column "Lessons of an Influence Seeker" at First Things.  Carter's observations about influence apply to nearly any effort to communicate.

First, Carter advises that one should "[k]now your 'great objects.'"  The key communication takeaway here is "[u]nless you can clarify to yourself what you want to affect, you can't make it clear to anyone else."  The most difficult task to teach students writing a paper or debaters constructing a case is developing a clear thesis.  Once students can make an idea clear to themselves, they usually can communicate it to teachers or debate judges.

Next, Carter asserts "[m]edia coverage is not the same as influence."  Most students or bloggers for that matter don't have to worry about "media coverage."  All of us, however, do need to remember that popularity, "media coverage," does not mean one is communicating effectively, having "influence."  Carter elaborates from his personal experience: "When the readers and listeners folded the newspaper, closed the magazine, and turned off the radio they completely forgot about my message."  He concludes, "Regularity and rapport—the two keys to influencing hearts and minds—cannot be squeezed into an occasional sound bite."

For debaters, the message is clear.  Leave good points on the flow so the judge has something to remember.  Further, saying "cross apply the Mead in '98 card because the warrants are sweet" is a sound bite that may not be enough to influence a judge to vote for you.  Students turning in an AP essay need to remember that one good line doesn't necessarily earn the paper an "A."

The last two points from Carter's column that apply to the classroom and the debate round need little elaboration:  "Keep your pride in check" and "Think Long Term."

The biggest takeaway from Carter's post is "[f]ind the right balance for your message and your audience."  It probably should be turned into a poster and taped to the wall of every debate room in the country.

Finally, I think I need to read these paragraphs once a week.
Lesson #4: If you want to have a bigger influence, start by thinking smaller—So you’re not a teacher, a pastor, or a professional writer. You don’t have a forum to spread the message of your great objects. How do you get started? Here’s what you do: (1) start a blog, (2) write at least five days a week, (3) build an audience of 150 readers.

As Malcolm Gladwell argues in his book The Tipping Point, the maximum number of individuals with whom we can have a genuinely social relationship is about 150. In blogging terms, this means that when your readership grows, your ability to have a truly influential connection with them decreases significantly. This is not to say that you should attempt to limit your readership to 150 readers. But if you want to maximize your personal influence, focus on establishing strong bonds and deep interaction with a core group.

Consider what might happen if each of these 150 readers read and thought about what you wrote on your blog for five minutes every day. Five minutes may seem insignificant, but it can have an exponential effect. With only five minutes every day, five days a week, you will have the reader’s attention for almost an entire day—22 hours—every year. That’s an astounding opportunity for influence.

The question then becomes how you’ll use this opportunity. Your audience is giving you two of their most precious possessions—their time and their attention. What are you doing with this gift?

Some—even perhaps most—of your time should be spent building rapport with your audience. If all you ever write about is related to your great objects, it will be a challenge to hold their attention. But if you rarely—or never—mention your core message, then you have squandered your opportunity. Find the right balance for your message and your audience.

It Can't Be Good If It Makes The Tea Party Squeamish

Apparently, the Confederacy will not be endorsing Michele Bachmann.  It will instead run its own slate of candidates.  The Daily Beast reports on the rising number of white supremacists including former Ku Klux Klan leader David  Duke who are running for public office.  According to Don Black who is one of those candidates,
“Many of our people are involved in the Tea Party . . . .But much of their leadership is skittish when it comes to talking about racial realities. The Tea Party is a healthy movement but many are too conditioned to run like scared rabbits when called racists.”
It's good to know that Tea Party leaders have qualms about racism.  It's a little less comforting that one of the major new white supremacist candidates lives in neighboring Montana.  The article covers Montana's John Abarr.
“White people need to wake up to the fact that we’re becoming a minority in our country,” says John Abarr, a 41-year-old former organizer for the Knights of the Ku Klux Klan, has filed to begin raising money for Montana’s lone U.S. House seat.  He’s not worried that the Republican Party isn’t backing him: “I don’t think public opinion is all that much against us. Montanans are independent thinkers.” His key platform? Abolish the Fed, raise the military age to 21 to stop what he calls the “barbaric” practice of sending teenagers to war, end the death penalty, legalize marijuana (he doesn’t smoke or drink himself), establish a 5 percent flat tax, and help whites by fighting entitlements (like affirmative action and immigration) that he says favor minorities. He describes the Klan as a Christian, white civil-rights organization, and glosses over the brutality that has earned the group its bad name. “I can’t agree with lynching anybody for any reason, but that was a different time in our history.” He adds: “We already have a black president, and I’m not sure when we’ll have a white president elected again.”
Abarr's candidacy prompts a couple of questions.  How long will it be before a white supremacist seeks public office in South Dakota?  How will South Dakota Tea Partiers deal with that candidacy?

Tuesday, July 5, 2011

Plains Pops: Money And Religion Edition

The Week calls executive salaries "enraging" and reveals the biggest disconnects between the rich and the rest of us.
$10.8 million
Median pay in 2010 for top executives at 200 large companies, according to an Equilar report commissioned by The New York Times. "Total C.E.O. pay hasn't quite returned to its heady, pre-recession levels — but it certainly seems headed there," says Prandyna Joshi in The New York Times.

$752
Average weekly income of the average American worker in late 2010, just a 0.5 percent raise over the previous year. "It's not as if most workers are getting fat raises," says Joshi. After inflation, they're actually making less.

29.2
Percentage increase in profits for American businesses in the fourth quarter of 2010, "the fastest growth in more than 60 years"

2
Percentage increase, since the recovery began, in the amount businesses are spending on employees, according to the Commerce Report

26
Percentage increase in the amount they're spending on equipment and software. "The economy is producing as much as it was before the downturn, but with seven million fewer jobs," says Catherine Rampell in The New York Times.
Writing an opinion piece for CNN, Kenneth Davis, author of Don't Know Much About History, opines that original intent properly understood implies that United States was not founded as a Christian nation.  Several take away paragraphs.  First, the founders were probably not evangelicals.
No one can argue, as "Christian Nation" proponents correctly state, that the Founding Fathers were not Christian, although some notably doubted Christ's divinity.

More precisely, the founders were, with very few exceptions, mainstream Protestants. Many of them were Episcopalians, the American offshoot of the official Church of England. The status of America's Catholics, both legally and socially, in the colonies and early Republic, was clearly second-class. Other Christian sects, including Baptists, Quakers and Mormons, faced official resistance, discrimination and worse for decades.
Davis then goes on to give the following facts to bolster his claims that the United States founders saw the nation as a secular state.
Beyond that, the first House of Representatives, while debating the First Amendment, specifically rejected a Senate proposal calling for the establishment of Christianity as an official religion. As Lambert concludes, "There would be no Church of the United States. Nor would America represent itself as a Christian Republic."

The actions of the first presidents, founders of the first rank, confirmed this "original intent:"

-- In 1790, President George Washington wrote to America's first synagogue, in Rhode Island, that "all possess alike liberty of conscience" and that "toleration" was an "inherent national gift," not the government's to dole out or take away

-- In 1797, with President John Adams in office, the Senate unanimously approved one of America's earliest foreign treaties, which emphatically stated (Article 11): "As the government of the United States of America is not in any sense founded on the Christian Religion, -- as it has in itself no character of enmity against the laws, religion or tranquility of Musselmen (Muslims) ..."


-- In 1802, Jefferson added his famous "wall of separation," implicit in the Constitution until he so described it (and cited in several Supreme Court decisions since).
Because these first two pops seem a bit disjointed, I'll try to tie money and religion together.  The Pope tweets, and Bloomberg reports that Twitter is worth $7 billion which is about $2 billion less than the National Football League which arguably functions as America's secular church.

The Little Guys Don't Stand A Chance: Quotation of the Day

Writing in Slate, Dahlia Lithwick offers a stinging indictment of the recent Supreme Court term.
Depending on how you count "big cases," the Supreme Court has just finished off either a great (according to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce) or spectacularly great (according to a new study by the Constitutional Accountability Center) term for big business. The measure of success here isn't just the win-loss record of the Chamber of Commerce, although that's certainly part of the story. Nor is it news that—in keeping with a recent trend—the court is systematically closing the courthouse doors to everyday litigants, though that's a tale that always bears retelling. The reason the Roberts Court has proven to be Christmas in July for big business is this: Slowly but surely, the Supreme Court is giving corporate America a handbook on how to engage in misconduct. In case after case, it seems big companies are being given the playbook on how to win even bigger the next time.
Lithwick concludes her column, "when you teach big business precisely how to screw over the little guy, and how to do it faster, cheaper, and without detection … well, that's not even an illusion of justice anymore. It's enabling."

My Fellow Teachers Do Something Stupid

The National Education Association voted to endorse Barack Obama for the 2012 election.  They also voted to direct
. . . . the NEA President to communicate aggressively, forcefully, and immediately to President Barack Obama and US Secretary of Education Arne Duncan that NEA is appalled with Secretary Duncan's practice of:. . . .
Blogger Teacher Ken tries to put the decision in historical perspective.
Let's provide some historical context for elections since 1988.

1988  Dukakis got 86%

1992 Clinton got 88%

1996 Clinton got 91%

2000 Gore got 86.5%

2004 Kerry got 86.5%

2008 Obama got 79.8%

2011, Obama got 72%.

Unlike Clinton, in his endorsement for reelection Obama dropped 7.8%, while Clinton went up 3%.

And Obama's percentage in 2008 was already the lowest in the past 5 elections.

This is far from "overwhelming" support by historical standards.
Those numbers according to Teacher Ken mean the vote was something other than overwhelming by historical standards.  Overwhelming or not, the endorsement is a stupid decision.

First, Obama's education record is dismal.  The Washington Post describes an individual teacher's frustrations that echo mine.  Teachers supported Obama to "stand strong for public schools and break from a federal education policy of 'testing, testing, testing.'"  However the results have been something different.
Three years later, all the standardized tests are still there. In some places, they are beginning to be used to fire teachers. Lately. . .  the solutions to all of public education’s troubles seem to boil down to a refrain: “Blame it on the teacher[s] who works [their] tail[s] off for 14 hours a day."
Further, education historian Diane Ravitch who tweets with the handle @DianeRavitch has tweeted the following:  "Obama education policy is worse than NCLB because of increased pressure for high-stakes testing, judging by teachers by scores." and "Suppose we might refer to the Bush-Obama education policy since NCLB and RTTT [Race to the Top] are so well aligned, bipartisan."

In short, President Obama has done nothing that teachers supported him to do and he may well have made matters worse.

Second, the vote to endorse and the vote to issue disapproval seems to indicate that Duncan is a wild card who is acting without Obama's approval.  The President appointed Secretary Duncan.  The President has shown a willingness to overrule his generals.  The New York Times reported,
Gen. David H. Petraeus, the top American commander in Afghanistan, said Thursday that President Obama’s new schedule for drawing down forces there was “more aggressive” than he had recommended and increased the risk that the military would not meet all its goals.
Teachers are now supposed to believe that the President can overrule a general but not a secretary of education. It's much more logical, Duncan is putting Obama's policies in place.

Third, NEA may have felt pressured to make the endorsement now so they hold the Representative Assembly every July.  The Chicago Tribune reports
Because the NEA's representative assembly, its primary policymaking arm, meets once a year, union leaders said they faced a dilemma of either being early or late in determining their political support. The group typically makes an endorsement in July preceding the presidential election.
The endorsement is the most important political tool that NEA has.  They have squandered it.

Given that Obama's policies are no better than President Bush's policies, all this early endorsement accomplishes is re-enforce the idea that teachers are lap dogs of the Democratic party.