Last Night, HBO premiered Treme, a new series set in New Orleans after Katrina. The series is produced by the same people who produced The Wire, one of the best television series ever. It also features some of the same stars including Wendell Pierce.
This new series may not reach the level of The Wire, but I started wonder if students and teachers twenty or thirty years from now will have "must have viewed" lists like we have "must have read lists." I don't believe books are going extinct, but their impact on culture may not be as great as it was for previous generations. So, will everyone look at Tony Soprano or Greg House as the epitome of contemporary tragic heroes? Will Mad Men be the example that one uses for verisimilitude or Saving Grace the standard for internal conflict? And finally in the spirit of asking too many weird questions, what would the canon contain? Everyone agrees that people read a Shakespeare play or three along with Eliot's, Frost's, and Whitman's poetry for example; what are the ten films or TV programs that would go on the list? (My apologies for only including the dead white males on the literature list.)
Monday, April 12, 2010
Sunday, April 11, 2010
Examining The Checklist Manifesto: How To Get Things Right (Part 1)
I first became aware of Atul Gawande's The Checklist Manifesto from C-SPAN's Book TV. One Washington Journal interview is here. Of course you can watch an entire speech on YouTube.
His thesis is simple. Simple, well written, checklists save lives in the operating room. It doesn't matter if the hospital is in the US or India or Jordan; when the surgical team used checklists, the number of infections and other complications dramatically decreased.
I intend to post more later, but three or four things stood out from this book. First, Van Halen's demand from a bowl of M&M's with all of the brown candy removed was really a checklist. Gawande quotes David Lee Roth who claims, "When I would walk backstage, if I saw a brown M&M in that bowl, well, we'd line-check the entire production. Guaranteed you're going to arrive at a technical error . . .Guaranteed you'd run into a problem" (80). Today is Sunday, so I guess it's fair to say that Van Halen believed the scriptural injunction that those who are faithful in the small things will also be faithful in the large things.
Second, Gawande reports that pay for performance programs for surgeons have had modest results. In fact, he concludes that "incentive programs have thus far been expensive, incremental, and of limited benefit" (91). Merit pay advocates probably will just skip that page.
Third, Gawande reminds readers that "ticking boxes is not the ultimate goal here. Embracing a culture of teamwork is" (160). In short, one should have a goal and use things like checklists, computers,or homework assignments as a tool to achieve that goal.
Most importantly, Gawande reminds readers that failures must be studied. He writes, "[w]e don't study routine failures in teaching, in law, in government programs, in the financial industry, or elsewhere. We don't look for patters of our recurrent mistakes and devise and refine potential solutions for them" (185).
It seems The Checklist Manifesto has some implications for education. Teachers, students, and administrators all seem to repeat preventable errors. If checklists can save lives in the operating room, perhaps they can help in the classroom.
His thesis is simple. Simple, well written, checklists save lives in the operating room. It doesn't matter if the hospital is in the US or India or Jordan; when the surgical team used checklists, the number of infections and other complications dramatically decreased.
I intend to post more later, but three or four things stood out from this book. First, Van Halen's demand from a bowl of M&M's with all of the brown candy removed was really a checklist. Gawande quotes David Lee Roth who claims, "When I would walk backstage, if I saw a brown M&M in that bowl, well, we'd line-check the entire production. Guaranteed you're going to arrive at a technical error . . .Guaranteed you'd run into a problem" (80). Today is Sunday, so I guess it's fair to say that Van Halen believed the scriptural injunction that those who are faithful in the small things will also be faithful in the large things.
Second, Gawande reports that pay for performance programs for surgeons have had modest results. In fact, he concludes that "incentive programs have thus far been expensive, incremental, and of limited benefit" (91). Merit pay advocates probably will just skip that page.
Third, Gawande reminds readers that "ticking boxes is not the ultimate goal here. Embracing a culture of teamwork is" (160). In short, one should have a goal and use things like checklists, computers,or homework assignments as a tool to achieve that goal.
Most importantly, Gawande reminds readers that failures must be studied. He writes, "[w]e don't study routine failures in teaching, in law, in government programs, in the financial industry, or elsewhere. We don't look for patters of our recurrent mistakes and devise and refine potential solutions for them" (185).
It seems The Checklist Manifesto has some implications for education. Teachers, students, and administrators all seem to repeat preventable errors. If checklists can save lives in the operating room, perhaps they can help in the classroom.
Labels:
Classroom Tools?,
Merit Pay,
The Checklist Manifesto
Saturday, April 10, 2010
Two YouTube Videos Every Speech and Debate Teacher Needs
A Useful Warning about Mistakes Inherent in Visual Aid Speeches
A Reminder about What Every Persuasive Speech Needs
A Reminder about What Every Persuasive Speech Needs
Labels:
Argument,
PowerPoint,
Teaching Tools,
YouTube Vids
Friday, April 9, 2010
What's This Book Going to Cost Me?
Daniel Pink's book Drive has gotten great reviews.I haven't read it; I plan to this summer. I really hesitate to comment on a book that I haven't read, but the reviews for this book scare me. The reviews all contain descriptions and quotations similar to those Laura Vanderkam has in her recent review. She writes,
Callings are wonderful. In Greek mythology, Prometheus had a calling to bring humanity fire. Clergy, missionaries, and doctors have callings to preach the gospel and help the poor and suffering. Police and firefighters have callings to protect the public. Most teachers claim they don't work for the money; in short, they claim to have a calling to teach.
In an ideal world, Pink may be right and his ideas may make workers' lives better and improve employer/employee relationships. In South Dakota, however, private employers and school boards are more likely to use Pink's ideas to put negotiations for higher pay in the same category as requests for "free coffee and in-office massages." In other words, higher salaries are frivolous and a teacher's calling will be "so compelling that [the teacher] should be happy to build the teacher's "entire self around it." Of course anything that rewarding should be done for the joy of doing it; therefore, no salary is really needed.
That's my fear; I may be wrong, but I doubt it.
. . . Pink offers a different prescription. The best motivation, he suggests, is intrinsic, that is, when people want to do the work because they find the work itself fulfilling. That doesn’t mean such workers don’t want to be paid well. They do, of course, and they also like free coffee and in-office massages as much as anyone else. But leaders who understand this higher level of motivation compensate people in a way that “takes the issue of money off the table, so they can focus on the work itself.” They pay their employees well for their industry, but equally important, people aren’t pitted against one another through compensation schemes that pay some people way more than others for the same work. These leaders create an environment where people want to do their best. This involves giving people lots of autonomy over their time, their tasks, their techniques, and their teams; providing them an opportunity to work toward mastery of their professional craft; and imbuing their work with a sense of purpose. [emphasis added] (What Drives Us by Laura Vanderkam, City Journal 5 March 2010)Based on this review, Pink believes that people ought to have a calling rather than a job. Michael Lewis explains the difference,
The distinction is artificial but worth drawing. A job will never satisfy you all by itself, but it will afford you security and the chance to pursue an exciting and fulfilling life outside of your work. A calling is an activity you find so compelling that you wind up organizing your entire self around it -- often to the detriment of your life outside of it. There’s no shame in either. Each has costs and benefits. There is no reason to make a fetish of your career. There are activities other than work in which to find meaning and pleasure and even a sense of self-importance -- you just need to learn how to look.(Lewis, Bloomberg 10 December 2008)In South Dakota, however, callings have consequences, as The Madville Times points out South Dakota pays the lowest wages per job of any state in the nation. The Times points out "[i]n 2008, the per-job average here was $40,726. The next lowest state, Montana, posts $1462 more per job. The national average per job is $56,116. According to the Times commentators, the story is much more bleak; salaries in South Dakota are only about $33,000 whereas the national average is $42,270 (The Madville Times 6 April 2010).
Callings are wonderful. In Greek mythology, Prometheus had a calling to bring humanity fire. Clergy, missionaries, and doctors have callings to preach the gospel and help the poor and suffering. Police and firefighters have callings to protect the public. Most teachers claim they don't work for the money; in short, they claim to have a calling to teach.
In an ideal world, Pink may be right and his ideas may make workers' lives better and improve employer/employee relationships. In South Dakota, however, private employers and school boards are more likely to use Pink's ideas to put negotiations for higher pay in the same category as requests for "free coffee and in-office massages." In other words, higher salaries are frivolous and a teacher's calling will be "so compelling that [the teacher] should be happy to build the teacher's "entire self around it." Of course anything that rewarding should be done for the joy of doing it; therefore, no salary is really needed.
That's my fear; I may be wrong, but I doubt it.
Labels:
Daniel Pink,
Ideas and Consequences,
Teacher Pay
Thursday, April 8, 2010
Some Random Theses Nailed to a Random Bush on the Plains (part 1)
Martin Luther had 95 theses that he nailed to the Wittenberg Church door. I suppose I should clarify that it was the Castle Church in Wittenberg in case any random Lutherans want to pick nits.
I'm fairly certain that his counter-cultural ideas were developed over time. In other words, he didn't just sit down on a Halloween night and think up 95 ideas. I'm also fairly certain that he borrowed and adapted a few of them. I hope the Plains Lutherans don't declare me a blasphemer for using their founder's concept. I really don't want to be force fed lutefisk for the next 7 years. I don't know if I'll every get to 95 total theses, but ever so often, I'll post one or two and see what happens.
Thesis the first: Self-Esteem is overrated and perhaps destructive. From a an article entitled "Theodore Dalrymple on Self-Esteem and Self Respect,"
I'm fairly certain that his counter-cultural ideas were developed over time. In other words, he didn't just sit down on a Halloween night and think up 95 ideas. I'm also fairly certain that he borrowed and adapted a few of them. I hope the Plains Lutherans don't declare me a blasphemer for using their founder's concept. I really don't want to be force fed lutefisk for the next 7 years. I don't know if I'll every get to 95 total theses, but ever so often, I'll post one or two and see what happens.
Thesis the first: Self-Esteem is overrated and perhaps destructive. From a an article entitled "Theodore Dalrymple on Self-Esteem and Self Respect,"
In short, self-esteem is but a division of self-importance, which is seldom an attractive quality. That person is best who never thinks of his own importance: to think about it, even, is to be lost to morality.
Self-respect is another quality entirely. Where self-esteem is entirely egotistical, requiring that the world should pay court to oneself whatever oneself happens to be like or do, and demands nothing of the person who wants it, self-respect is a social virtue, a discipline, that requires an awareness of and sensitivity to the feelings of others. It requires an ability and willingness to put oneself in someone else's place; it requires dignity and fortitude, and not always taking the line of least resistance. [In Character, 3/28/10]Thesis the Second: Walter Mosley's Blonde Faith is an excellent book, but it can't be considered a classic because of lines like "realizing in few seconds I'd be dead" followed closely by "I think I smiled, and then the world went black." The first person narrator can't die. He's the one telling the story. Dead people don't tell stories, and they certainly can't tell you how they died after they're dead. In the case the problem is exacerbated by Mosely's great sense of history and place. He reminds readers that the 1960s were filled with racial tension. Blonde Faith's verisimilitude should make it a classic, but Easy Rawlins's narration of his own death means the book doesn't make the canon..
Labels:
Some Random Theses
Wednesday, April 7, 2010
A Modest Testing Proposal (Yes I Know It's A Cliche)
I was one of the staff members selected to help administer the South Dakota state-mandated DSTP test today. South Dakota requires all who administer this test to swear oaths to several major deities not to reveal any details of the test or use the term evolution. We can't even say that the test has evolved from earlier versions. Those oaths are sanctified by burnt offerings of mammals, fowl, fish, reptiles, and amphibians.
While watching the young minds deal with the conundrums that the state allegedly paid some publisher a million dollars to create, I had an epiphany: opposing the test is really counter productive.
South Dakota should expand the test. Every person who currently supports the NCLB and its mandated tests would probably leap at the chance to take them. South Dakota Public TV could even broadcast the test taking and announce the results. It could be a local version of Are You Smarter Than A 5th Grader? The show could be called Are You Smarter Than Next Year's Senior?
This plan should be a win-win situation. South Dakota Public TV might get some extra revenue from this wonderful program. Those who think that testing will force teachers to finally do their job and teach will get to show how great tests are by taking them and proving that those tests illustrate practical knowledge that everyone needs to succeed in business without really trying.
While watching the young minds deal with the conundrums that the state allegedly paid some publisher a million dollars to create, I had an epiphany: opposing the test is really counter productive.
South Dakota should expand the test. Every person who currently supports the NCLB and its mandated tests would probably leap at the chance to take them. South Dakota Public TV could even broadcast the test taking and announce the results. It could be a local version of Are You Smarter Than A 5th Grader? The show could be called Are You Smarter Than Next Year's Senior?
This plan should be a win-win situation. South Dakota Public TV might get some extra revenue from this wonderful program. Those who think that testing will force teachers to finally do their job and teach will get to show how great tests are by taking them and proving that those tests illustrate practical knowledge that everyone needs to succeed in business without really trying.
Labels:
Testing
Tuesday, April 6, 2010
Reform and Philosphy
The wonderfully titled blog "It's Not All Flowers and Sausages" has a great post about how policy makers discount teachers' opinions. Mrs. Mimi, the alliterative pseudonym chosen by the blogger, uses an EdWeek article as a genesis to make several wonderfully provocative points.
The EdWeek article begins,
Let's get on with it anyway. In Democracy in America, Tocqueville writes, "I think that in no country in the civilized world is less attention paid to philosophy than in the United States. The Americans have no philosophical school of their own, and they care but little for all the schools into which Europe is divided, the very names of which are scarcely known to them."
What Tocqueville saw in the early 1830s still holds true today. It's for that reason that policy makers probably never read books like Moral Consciousness and Communicative Action or web articles like this one that enunciate the following principles that would allow teachers to become more active participants in school reform discussions.
Following these principles means that no constituency in the reform debate will get everything s/he desires, but no one will lose everything. Further, teachers would not just be survey numbers, they would actually be participants in the discussion. They could challenge the ridiculous suppositions that led to the current mess. More importantly, the powers that be could not say "Suck it up and shut up!!!" Teachers could not be coerced into accepting policies that make it possible to test but not teach.
Teachers lost everything under NCLB and seem set to keep losing under the new proposals. Using philosophy as tool to get to the table is a long shot, but the results of having real teachers at the table would probably produce workable effective reforms. At worst, it will get the same reception that teachers get when they offer suggestions now.
The EdWeek article begins,
Perhaps at no other time in the history of American education has there been more publicly available information about what teachers think about their profession, their students, and the conditions under which they work.
As advocates pore over the results of teacher surveys being conducted nationally, at the state level, and even at individual schools, observers are beginning to ask questions about how the information can be used to inform policies to improve teachers’ working conditions and promote teacher and leadership effectiveness.Mrs. Mimi brilliantly observes,
Just because we're saying it doesn't mean that the Powers That Be are listening, taking us seriously or think that we have anything intelligent to offer. I've worked at educational research organizations and more often than not, the concerns of Real Teachers are met by eye rolling. EYE ROLLING! By people who claim to care about education...Every teacher who has expressed a good idea to a principal, superintendent, or school board member has had the experience she describes. She later asserts,
In MY SCHOOL (Friends, one of the biggest arguments used to discredit our words is that they are too contextually bound...meaning, they are too tied to our actual schools rather than the system at largeFinally, Mrs. Mimi asks the million dollar question,
How about we say enough with the surveys? How about we actually invite a REAL TEACHER (or better yet a WHOLE BUNCH OF TEACHERS) to the table when these policies and decisions are actually being made?!?!?I think I have several answers to that question. Most of them will make me sound far too bitter to be taken seriously. Instead, I'll try to sound cerebral, even though that effort will ensure that I won't be taken seriously.
Let's get on with it anyway. In Democracy in America, Tocqueville writes, "I think that in no country in the civilized world is less attention paid to philosophy than in the United States. The Americans have no philosophical school of their own, and they care but little for all the schools into which Europe is divided, the very names of which are scarcely known to them."
What Tocqueville saw in the early 1830s still holds true today. It's for that reason that policy makers probably never read books like Moral Consciousness and Communicative Action or web articles like this one that enunciate the following principles that would allow teachers to become more active participants in school reform discussions.
1. Every subject with the competence to speak and act is allowed to take part in a discourse.If policymakers were to follow the principles listed above, teachers would be able to participate. The people whose jaws drop at the mention of teacher involvement might argue that mere classroom teachers are not competent to participate in important decisions. These are the same people, however, who argue that nothing is more important than the current cohort of students. If the latter is true, then it seems illogical to hire incompetent people to husband that resource.
2a. Everyone is allowed to question any assertion whatever.
2b. Everyone is allowed to introduce any assertion whatever into the discourse.
2c. Everyone is allowed to express his attitudes, desires, and needs.
3. No speaker may be prevented, by internal or external coercion, from exercising his rights as
laid down in (1) and (2).
Following these principles means that no constituency in the reform debate will get everything s/he desires, but no one will lose everything. Further, teachers would not just be survey numbers, they would actually be participants in the discussion. They could challenge the ridiculous suppositions that led to the current mess. More importantly, the powers that be could not say "Suck it up and shut up!!!" Teachers could not be coerced into accepting policies that make it possible to test but not teach.
Teachers lost everything under NCLB and seem set to keep losing under the new proposals. Using philosophy as tool to get to the table is a long shot, but the results of having real teachers at the table would probably produce workable effective reforms. At worst, it will get the same reception that teachers get when they offer suggestions now.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)