When the teacher who writes posted about correcting and moiling, I commented that correcting stacks of papers is "emulating Sisyphus." I spent part of today pushing the correcting rock up the hill only to have it roll down on me several times.
While correcting, I came to the conclusion that blogging makes me a hypocrite. Maybe other teachers think their posts through, but all of the posts here are first drafts. Because most posts are dashed off quickly, they contain errors that teachers mark on students' papers. Thank God for cognitive dissonance and the ability to rationalize.
Mythology teachers, however, know that seeing faults in others but not in one's self leads to tragic errors such as those that befell Prometheus or Oedipus. I'm willing to take that risk today because baseball is back. The myths show that Oedipus will eventually be seen as blessing not a curse, and Prometheus will eventually shed his chains and leave the mountain. Baseball means he world is renewed until the World Series in late October and early November.
The previous paragraph may a rationalization, but it's a damn good one. I'm off to watch some baseball.
Monday, April 5, 2010
Sunday, April 4, 2010
Epic Sadness
I had hoped that the Clash of Titans remake would do two small thinks. First, it would take myths and heroism seriously. Second, it would be a good movie. According to Rotten Tomatoes, I'm going to be disappointed. I haven't seen it, but these reviews mean that I'll wait until it's on HBO. I suppose I shouldn't be surprised; after all, the publicity emphasized one of the most stupid movie lines of all time, "Release the Kracken."
Saturday, April 3, 2010
Some Bricolage on School Reform
At his blog Larry Cuban on School Reform and Practice, Larry Cuban discuss Americans love for change and how that relationship affects education. (I think that Cuban can put his name on his blog because he no longer teaches, but that's a post for a different time. He can also put his name on his blog because he has more letters after his name that I do.)
Cuban makes two astute observations about how Americans view change and schools. First, Americans think change is good. More importantly, change and improvement have become synonyms.
Education seems to face a deeper problem than Secretary of Education Duncan who wants change that goes beyond tinkering or a public confused about the difference between change and reform. Joshua Hammand's and James Morrison's The Stuff Americans Are Made of: The Seven Cultural Forces That Define Americans, A New Framework for Quality. Productivity and Profitability indicates that teachers may increasingly be labeled obstructionists. Hammond and Morrison claim that the seven forces are
Schools can't compete with McDonald's or Walmart when it comes to offering choice or being big. Further, the idea that 100% of students should be proficient in reading and math can be spun as an impossible dream that schools should attempt to achieve. It's a small step from trying an impossible dream to firing people who can't make the impossible happen. In addition, educators concentrate on each student's present circumstances, but the main focus is always the student's future. Finally, no institution supported by local property taxes and politicians' whims can expect to keep up with all that's new.
Lest I appear too negative, Hammond and Morrison also offer hope. For example, standardized tests make improvisation impossible. These tests also demonstrably limit the choices in each school's curriculum. However, education leaders at the national, state, and local level need to use the paradigms that these researchers have identified to teachers' and students' advantage. I'll try to use a few future posts to offer the views of a teacher and blogger from South Dakota about how that little impossible dream can happen.
Cuban makes two astute observations about how Americans view change and schools. First, Americans think change is good. More importantly, change and improvement have become synonyms.
To put it bluntly: Americans believe that change is good. We need look no further than commonplace patterns that pervade our daily lives. Car models change every year. Elections move public officials in and out of office every few years. And Americans love to move from where they were reared to other places. Change, then, is common; it is no big deal.
Not only is change seen as worthwhile, many Americans also confuse change with improvement. They are different concepts. When a married couple divorces, one spouse sees it as joyful emancipation and the other as a tragedy. The divorce qualifies as a change but each spouse views it dramatically different. Change is not necessarily improvement; improvement is in the head of the beholder. [Larry Cuban 4/3/10]Cuban illustrates that this confusion detrimentally affects education; ". . . teachers are blamed for being opposed to reform when their fellow Americans see it as a prized 'good,' one that automatically leads to improvement" [Larry Cuban 4/3/10]. He then goes on to parse the differences between "incremental change" and "fundamental change."
Education seems to face a deeper problem than Secretary of Education Duncan who wants change that goes beyond tinkering or a public confused about the difference between change and reform. Joshua Hammand's and James Morrison's The Stuff Americans Are Made of: The Seven Cultural Forces That Define Americans, A New Framework for Quality. Productivity and Profitability indicates that teachers may increasingly be labeled obstructionists. Hammond and Morrison claim that the seven forces are
- Americans demand choices
- Americans believe impossible dreams are possible. (Insert your own windmill joke here.)
- Americas love both big and more.
- Americans want everything NOW!!!
- Americans are willing to forgive mistakes and move on.
- Americans like to improvise.
- Americans love the NEW!!!
Schools can't compete with McDonald's or Walmart when it comes to offering choice or being big. Further, the idea that 100% of students should be proficient in reading and math can be spun as an impossible dream that schools should attempt to achieve. It's a small step from trying an impossible dream to firing people who can't make the impossible happen. In addition, educators concentrate on each student's present circumstances, but the main focus is always the student's future. Finally, no institution supported by local property taxes and politicians' whims can expect to keep up with all that's new.
Lest I appear too negative, Hammond and Morrison also offer hope. For example, standardized tests make improvisation impossible. These tests also demonstrably limit the choices in each school's curriculum. However, education leaders at the national, state, and local level need to use the paradigms that these researchers have identified to teachers' and students' advantage. I'll try to use a few future posts to offer the views of a teacher and blogger from South Dakota about how that little impossible dream can happen.
Friday, April 2, 2010
Of Sticks, Hammers, and Carrots
The Answer Sheet blog points to a couple of items of concern.
First, it reprints an open letter from Jim Horn to President Obama and Secretary of Education Duncan about reauthorizing NCLB. The key quotation,
Teachers need to make it possible for their students to learn. They should know their material and how to communicate that knowledge. Although Socrates famously argued that he know nothing, he obviously know enough to ask great questions. Test scores won't show whether teachers help students learn, know their material, or promote asking great questions; test scores illustrate whether students can take tests. That's it.
Further, high school students need to take responsibility for their education. As a wise man once told me, "You can lead a horse to water, but you can't make him drink; you can send kids to school but you can't make them think." Tying test scores to continued employment or pay automatically allows students avoid thinking and learning. They get to put the responsibility on someone else. In fact, they can fail every test and every class, and it will be the teachers' fault.
The efforts to link teacher pay or job security to student results indicate a lack of reading skills. Proponents will probably admit to using a carrot and stick approach because the best teachers will get the "carrot" of higher salary while the poor teachers will get the "stick" or in this case the "hammer"of lower pay or unemployment.
A careful reading of the story, however, reveals that the boy never got results while using the stick to punish the donkey. The more he "hammered" the donkey with the stick, the less work the donkey accomplished. It was only after the stick became an extension of the boy's arm and was used to dangle the carrot in front of the donkey that the donkey began to pull the cart.
The people who love NCLB or who support the Floridan bill seem to assume that testing will produce students who are better prepared to work or attend college because teachers who have been doing absolutely nothing for the past fifty years will suddenly start teaching and thousands of new applicants will eagerly seek the benefits that come to teachers whose students pass NCLB mandated tests. They are wrong on both counts. A high school career that allows students to blame someone else for their failure to learn will produce graduates who need extra workplace training or remedial college classes. The proposed changes to NCLB and the Florida approach will make the teaching profession more desirable for only those people who enjoy being "hammered." In that case, future teachers will have to be drunks or masochists or both.
First, it reprints an open letter from Jim Horn to President Obama and Secretary of Education Duncan about reauthorizing NCLB. The key quotation,
Despite all the politicizing of the teaching profession, at heart teachers remain child advocates and cultivators of the next generation of citizens. Teachers want children to succeed and flourish, but it is not because they have been paid to do so. A student’s growth and well-being remain the teacher’s most ardent concerns, despite the fact that she is undervalued, demonized, ridiculed, mistrusted, and paid less than most other professions that require the same level of education and training.Second, a report on Florida's efforts to "hammer" teachers. The term "hammer" comes from one of the bill's authors. The legislation would tie teacher pay directly to student test scores. Districts could not take into account years of service or education. The key quotation,
If a child’s test scores are to be used to make decisions regarding a teacher’s most basic needs for adequate sustenance for her family and for a dollop of dignity from her principal, then you risk damaging the teacher-student relationship that goes as far back as Socrates.
This approach could easily spread beyond the borders of Florida. It’s everybody’s business.The Florida approach can easily find a home in South Dakota. The State currently offers few legal protections for teachers or any other workers. That fact won't stand in the way of people's perceptions that teachers are overpaid, lazy people who teach for the thrill of June, July, and August.
Teachers need to make it possible for their students to learn. They should know their material and how to communicate that knowledge. Although Socrates famously argued that he know nothing, he obviously know enough to ask great questions. Test scores won't show whether teachers help students learn, know their material, or promote asking great questions; test scores illustrate whether students can take tests. That's it.
Further, high school students need to take responsibility for their education. As a wise man once told me, "You can lead a horse to water, but you can't make him drink; you can send kids to school but you can't make them think." Tying test scores to continued employment or pay automatically allows students avoid thinking and learning. They get to put the responsibility on someone else. In fact, they can fail every test and every class, and it will be the teachers' fault.
The efforts to link teacher pay or job security to student results indicate a lack of reading skills. Proponents will probably admit to using a carrot and stick approach because the best teachers will get the "carrot" of higher salary while the poor teachers will get the "stick" or in this case the "hammer"of lower pay or unemployment.
A careful reading of the story, however, reveals that the boy never got results while using the stick to punish the donkey. The more he "hammered" the donkey with the stick, the less work the donkey accomplished. It was only after the stick became an extension of the boy's arm and was used to dangle the carrot in front of the donkey that the donkey began to pull the cart.
The people who love NCLB or who support the Floridan bill seem to assume that testing will produce students who are better prepared to work or attend college because teachers who have been doing absolutely nothing for the past fifty years will suddenly start teaching and thousands of new applicants will eagerly seek the benefits that come to teachers whose students pass NCLB mandated tests. They are wrong on both counts. A high school career that allows students to blame someone else for their failure to learn will produce graduates who need extra workplace training or remedial college classes. The proposed changes to NCLB and the Florida approach will make the teaching profession more desirable for only those people who enjoy being "hammered." In that case, future teachers will have to be drunks or masochists or both.
Thursday, April 1, 2010
Grammar Help
This Twitter site and this webiste from the Wichita Eagle help people deal with grammatical conundrums. So far my favorite has been noted by the Bookslut Blog.
"Affect" is usually a verb. "Effect" is usually a noun. Kryptonite affects Superman; its effects are debilitating.Grammar and superheroes, what could be better?
Labels:
Grammar,
Grammar Monkeys,
Superheroes
A Post in Which I Flatter Myself and Add Another Life Goal
This post at "Musings From A Not So Master Teacher" got me doing some introspection. John Spenser posits that some teachers don't fit the basic teacher stereotype. He calls these teachers "indie teachers" and lists 5 criteria for identifying these creatures. I've broken his original 5 criteria into a longer list that include his specific examples and then indicated whether I fit the criterion or example.
"Prefers indie, or at least non-mainstream music." My favorite albums are Warren Zevon's The Wind, Sam Phillips's Martinis and Bikinis, and Johnny Cash's The Man Comes Around. I think I qualify under this criterion.
"Doesn't blush at a self-published book." I miss here. I'm not saying I wouldn't self publish, but I would not like it.
"Tends to vote independent and uses strange labels (I'm a left-leaning libertarian, I'm a green moderate) in the process." I think being a fine and profane gentleman fits. I've never voted a straight ticket, so I probably meet this one.
"This teacher is skeptical, but not necessarily cynical, toward social institutions like schools, government, corporations." I think that government should be big enough to keep corporations in check. Lately, that's pretty big. Schools have a purpose, but they ain't Jesus. I think I meet this criterion.
"[T]his type of teacher doesn't "love" public school so much as loves the learning process." All I can say is "Preach it, Brother."
"Tends to share and sees horizontal collaboration as more valuable than being forced to use an "expert" resource." I steal good ideas whenever I can from whomever I can. I also tend to look at the idea or tool or philosophy behind the concept rather than the purveyor's title or credentials. I'm pretty sure that I meet this criterion.
"In other words, this type of teacher likes to share links, share resources, share ideas, share content." I'm a bit of a hoarder of ideas. I willing to talk about ideas all day. I'd say I meet only half of this one..
"You'll see a Creative Commons license on blog posts, for example." I haven't done this, but I would like to. Still, I honestly can't give myself credit for meeting this one.
"Develops resources rather than using school-imposed curriculum," I use my own materials exclusively for one of the classes I teach; I play nice and use some of the "official" materials for classes that several of us have to teach. I think I fit this criterion.
". . . doesn't depend on schools to fix discipline issues, etc." Defenestration is the most beautiful word I know, especially because many of the young ones in my class believe I may actually defenestrate one of them before I retire. I fit this description pretty well.
"Tends to be open to new ideas, supportive of paradox and contemplative." According to the Keirsey Bates test I'm an INTP, so I'm pretty sure I meet this criterion.
"At it's worst, this can look like chincy, cheap idealism. At it's best, it becomes innovation." I don't know if I'm innovative, so I'll take a half point here because I know that I have an idealistic streak at times.
"It's no wonder that you see so many indie teachers quoting Seth Godin's Linchpin." I don't have the book, but I'll probably read it now. I do, however, have a Seth Godin action figure.
If my math is correct, I meet 10 out of the 13. Given that the list contains some pretty specific examples, that's not to bad. I'd like to add one more criterion that one must have to be "an indie teacher." One must realize that teaching is probably a craft. A few might be be able to make it an art. No matter how much the politicians claim otherwise, it will never be a science.
Education needs more innovative, skeptical, contemplative, independent individuals. If I don't meet the criteria for being an indie teacher, I should. I guess I'll add meeting these criteria to the life goals in the post that precedes this one. I'll add another smaller goal. No more introspective posts for at least a week.
"Prefers indie, or at least non-mainstream music." My favorite albums are Warren Zevon's The Wind, Sam Phillips's Martinis and Bikinis, and Johnny Cash's The Man Comes Around. I think I qualify under this criterion.
"Doesn't blush at a self-published book." I miss here. I'm not saying I wouldn't self publish, but I would not like it.
"Tends to vote independent and uses strange labels (I'm a left-leaning libertarian, I'm a green moderate) in the process." I think being a fine and profane gentleman fits. I've never voted a straight ticket, so I probably meet this one.
"This teacher is skeptical, but not necessarily cynical, toward social institutions like schools, government, corporations." I think that government should be big enough to keep corporations in check. Lately, that's pretty big. Schools have a purpose, but they ain't Jesus. I think I meet this criterion.
"[T]his type of teacher doesn't "love" public school so much as loves the learning process." All I can say is "Preach it, Brother."
"Tends to share and sees horizontal collaboration as more valuable than being forced to use an "expert" resource." I steal good ideas whenever I can from whomever I can. I also tend to look at the idea or tool or philosophy behind the concept rather than the purveyor's title or credentials. I'm pretty sure that I meet this criterion.
"In other words, this type of teacher likes to share links, share resources, share ideas, share content." I'm a bit of a hoarder of ideas. I willing to talk about ideas all day. I'd say I meet only half of this one..
"You'll see a Creative Commons license on blog posts, for example." I haven't done this, but I would like to. Still, I honestly can't give myself credit for meeting this one.
"Develops resources rather than using school-imposed curriculum," I use my own materials exclusively for one of the classes I teach; I play nice and use some of the "official" materials for classes that several of us have to teach. I think I fit this criterion.
". . . doesn't depend on schools to fix discipline issues, etc." Defenestration is the most beautiful word I know, especially because many of the young ones in my class believe I may actually defenestrate one of them before I retire. I fit this description pretty well.
"Tends to be open to new ideas, supportive of paradox and contemplative." According to the Keirsey Bates test I'm an INTP, so I'm pretty sure I meet this criterion.
"At it's worst, this can look like chincy, cheap idealism. At it's best, it becomes innovation." I don't know if I'm innovative, so I'll take a half point here because I know that I have an idealistic streak at times.
"It's no wonder that you see so many indie teachers quoting Seth Godin's Linchpin." I don't have the book, but I'll probably read it now. I do, however, have a Seth Godin action figure.
If my math is correct, I meet 10 out of the 13. Given that the list contains some pretty specific examples, that's not to bad. I'd like to add one more criterion that one must have to be "an indie teacher." One must realize that teaching is probably a craft. A few might be be able to make it an art. No matter how much the politicians claim otherwise, it will never be a science.
Education needs more innovative, skeptical, contemplative, independent individuals. If I don't meet the criteria for being an indie teacher, I should. I guess I'll add meeting these criteria to the life goals in the post that precedes this one. I'll add another smaller goal. No more introspective posts for at least a week.
Labels:
Indie Teachers,
Life Goals
A Few Comments about Goals
A year ago, I wrote a post about my desire to become "a fine and profane rural gentleman." I am doing quite well on the "profane" part; I need to keep working on the "fine" elements.
I now have a second life goal. In Blonde Faith, Walter Mosley has his protagonist Easy Rawlins describe himself and his friend as people who "were well read and willing to talk about ideas." I like this idea so much that I may be willing to avoid being profane while talking about certain ideas.
Let me be clear that I've always had the latter goal, but Mosley phrases it more pointedly than I can. As to the former, being an walking contradiction suits me.
One thing that scares me is that I'm running out of time to reach these goals and the those that other people haven't phrased so well for me. I'm on the wrong side of 50. Donald Miller describes my situation with a great metaphor.
I now have a second life goal. In Blonde Faith, Walter Mosley has his protagonist Easy Rawlins describe himself and his friend as people who "were well read and willing to talk about ideas." I like this idea so much that I may be willing to avoid being profane while talking about certain ideas.
Let me be clear that I've always had the latter goal, but Mosley phrases it more pointedly than I can. As to the former, being an walking contradiction suits me.
One thing that scares me is that I'm running out of time to reach these goals and the those that other people haven't phrased so well for me. I'm on the wrong side of 50. Donald Miller describes my situation with a great metaphor.
"Soon you will be at that part of the book where you are holding the bulk of the pages in your left hand, and only a thin wisp of the story in your right" (Donald Miller, Through Painted Deserts: Life, God, and Beauty on the Open Road, xii)I think I'll go read now, so I have some good ideas to speak about, profanely or otherwise.
Labels:
Life Goals
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)