Showing posts with label Machiavelli. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Machiavelli. Show all posts

Friday, July 6, 2012

Denny And The Prince*

Yesterday, the ever concise Bob Mercer analyzed Governor Daugaard's claim to have created "a culture of fiscal restraint."
Those seven words began the latest weekly column issued from Gov. Dennis Daugaard, in which he talks about state agencies returning $13 million of unspent funds from their 2012 budgets, which closed June 30. He also talked about tax revenues and other general collections being up 7.3 percent through the first 11 months of the 2012 fiscal year. Those seven words are fascinating as a political statement, because they reflect directly upon the previous management under the Rounds administration, in which Daugaard was lieutenant governor. The full sentence says, “Under a new culture of fiscal restraint, our state agencies are not spending every dollar they were allocated."
Cory adds a broader analysis here.

Less than a month ago, Daugaard inserted himself into some legislative primaries to support establishment candidates over tea party types.  Now he's criticizing his predecessor.  Something about this situation reminded me of Machiavelli's The Prince. Machiavelli famously tells leaders to merge the primary qualities of both the lion and the fox:
A prince, therefore, being compelled knowingly to adopt the beast, ought to choose the fox and the lion; because the lion cannot defend himself against snares and the fox cannot defend himself against wolves. Therefore, it is necessary to be a fox to discover the snares and a lion to terrify the wolves.
The Governor acted the role of the lion in the primaries; those results were mixed.   Now, he's copying the sly fox.

For his sake, I hope the Governor reads the entire book; Machiavelli warns leaders to avoid being hated. The Governor seems to be picking fights that may make it impossible to avoid hatred.  Machiavelli has a solution:
. . . princes cannot help being hated by someone, they ought, in the first place, to avoid being hated by every one, and when they cannot compass this, they ought to endeavour with the utmost diligence to avoid the hatred of the most powerful.
I don't know whether Rounds or the tea party represents the "most powerful." so I suggest the Governor follow one last bit of Machiavelli's advice:
I say that a prince may be seen happy to-day and ruined to-morrow without having shown any change of disposition or character. This, I believe, arises firstly from causes that have already been discussed at length, namely, that the prince who relies entirely upon fortune is lost when it changes. I believe also that he will be successful who directs his actions according to the spirit of the times, and that he whose actions do not accord with the times will not be successful. Because men are seen, in affairs that lead to the end which every man has before him, namely, glory and riches, to get there by various methods; one with caution, another with haste; one by force, another by skill; one by patience, another by its opposite; and each one succeeds in reaching the goal by a different method. One can also see of two cautious men the one attain his end, the other fail; and similarly, two men by different observances are equally successful, the one being cautious, the other impetuous; all this arises from nothing else than whether or not they conform in their methods to the spirit of the times.
In short, the Governor seems to be trying to keep up with the spirit of the times and avoid relying on luck to keep the party behind him.  Of course, Machiavelli never held power, so it's not clear that following his advice will work, but the Governor seems to be doing his best to apply Machiavelli's principles.

*I should show the Governor a bit more respect, but when the title of the post can also be a band name for either a 1950s fold duo or a pair of 21st century hip hop artists, I just can't resist

Monday, April 23, 2012

Resentment: A Post Created Because Three Things Converged

At Slate, big boy bloggers, Matt Yglesias and Timothy Noah are discussing Noah's book The Great Divergence: America's Growing Inequality Crisis and What We Can Do about It.
Noah makes three points about inequality.  First, he concedes it's necessary in a capitalist system.  Second income inequality is growing.
Why is it necessary to reward so much more today than in 1979 the effort and skill (and dumb luck) that gets you into the top 1 percent of incomes (i.e., above about $350,000)? In 1979 the top 1 percent consumed about 10 percent of the nation’s collective income. In 2010 it consumed about 20 percent. (That includes capital gains.) Sure, the economy was in lousy shape in 1979. But the top 1 percent contented itself with 9-12 percent of the nation’s collective income for three decades prior to 1979, during the great post-World War II economic boom. Indeed, income share for the top 1 percent fell a little during that period. From the early 1930s through the late 1970s incomes in America didn’t become more unequal; they became more equal. So clearly the top earners can get by on much less without undermining capitalism.
Growing inequality matters, according to Noah, because it produces resentment.
So that’s why growing inequality isn’t necessary. Why is it worrisome?
Because it creates alienation. I worry less about the 99 percent (which, let’s face it, includes a lot of pretty affluent people) than about the bottom 60 or 50 percent. Income earners at the median have not shared in America’s prosperity. They’ve actually seen their incomes go down (after inflation) during the past decade, and over the past three decades their increases seem pitiful compared both with people earning top incomes (and here I mean not just the top 1 percent but the top 10 and even 20 percent) and with people at the median during the postwar era. For a long time economists said: Wait until productivity rebounds. Then working families will get their share. But when productivity rebounded like crazy in the aughts, working families saw no reward.
What this means is that if you’re at the median you have no positive reason to care how the economy does. Your only motivation is fear—if the economy does really badly you may lose your job. But there’s no upside.
Noah's conclusion seem to echo the findings Cory blogged about this morning at the Madville Times: the perception of unfair treatment produces resentful workers and dangerous results.  The Chrystia Freeland column that prompted Cory's post seems to support Noah's conclusions.
Does our perception of fairness influence how hard we work? Their answer is yes - workers who are underpaid don't work as hard.
The two professors' conclusion was based on the responses of experimental subjects. In his Berlin talk, Dr. Falk also cited an American real-world example that points to the same conclusion. A bitter fight between workers and management at Bridgestone/Firestone's plant in Decatur, Illinois, in the mid-1990s, including a long strike and the hiring of scabs, coincided with the production of poorer-quality tires.
"Looking before and after the strike and across plants, we find that labor strife at the Decatur plant closely coincided with lower product quality," a paper on the subject by Alan B. Krueger, a Princeton economist who is now the head of the U.S. president's Council of Economic Advisers, and Alexandre Mas, also of Princeton, reports. "Monthly data suggest that defects were particularly high around the time concessions were demanded and when large numbers of replacement workers and returning strikers worked side by side."
Workers who feel they are being treated badly aren't just unproductive; they can be downright dangerous.
The last little item about resentment causes me to think that those who have the money and make the rules should know better.  During a class discussion about Othello, I started comparing Iago to Machiavelli and was reminded that Machiavelli counselled his prince to avoid the excessive resentment of his citizens.
Nevertheless a prince ought to inspire fear in such a way that, if he does not win love, he avoids hatred; because he can endure very well being feared whilst he is not hated, which will always be as long as he abstains from the property of his citizens and subjects and from their women. But when it is necessary for him to proceed against the life of someone, he must do it on proper justification and for manifest cause, but above all things he must keep his hands off the property of others, because men more quickly forget the death of their father than the loss of their patrimony. Besides, pretexts for taking away the property are never wanting; for he who has once begun to live by robbery will always find pretexts for seizing what belongs to others; but reasons for taking life, on the contrary, are more difficult to find and sooner lapse. But when a prince is with his army, and has under control a multitude of soldiers, then it is quite necessary for him to disregard the reputation of cruelty, for without it he would never hold his army united or disposed to its duties. . . .
Returning to the question of being feared or loved, I come to the conclusion that, men loving according to their own will and fearing according to that of the prince, a wise prince should establish himself on that which is in his own control and not in that of others; he must endeavour only to avoid hatred, as is noted.
It's rare that three different items from three different sources come together with a similar conclusion: creating resentment is dangerous and should be avoided,  What's frightening is that no one seems to care.

Monday, August 15, 2011

Of Politics, Inservices, And Emapthy

I've been thinking about empathy a lot today.  Teachers in the district spent 6 hours listening to presenters tell us to be responsible for our own attitudes, listen to students, and own our mistakes.  The presenters spent much of the morning reminding teachers that classroom success demands empathy.  In fact, empathy is more important than intellect.

This evening, I came across this Ta-Neshi Coates post about Rick Perry.  Coates writes,
I don't know when people got it in their heads that there's a Wonderlic test for the presidency, but it's a notion that should be done away with immediately.
I'm sure there some level of imbecility which would be too much for Americans, but it seems that the ability to understand and speak to the ambitions of a critical mass of the electorate is much more important. Intelligence might help that effort. But empathy--or at least the ability to communicate empathy--with your audience seems much more important.
I may not be doing what I should to maintain a good attitude, but Coates's use of the term "communicate" troubles me.  Fourth grade teachers have real empathy.  Perry and other politicians seem more Machiavellian.  From chapter 18 of The Prince,
EVERY one admits how praiseworthy it is in a prince to keep faith, and to live with integrity and not with craft. . . .

Therefore it is unnecessary for a prince to have all the good qualities I have enumerated, but it is very necessary to appear to have them. And I shall dare to say this also, that to have them and always to observe them is injurious, and that to appear to have them is useful; to appear merciful, faithful, humane, religious, upright, and to be so, but with a mind so framed that should you require not to be so, you may be able and know how to change to the opposite.
Machiavelli had this one right.  Success for Perry or any other presidential candidate is not about communicating empathy; it's about appearing to have it even if one doesn't.