In the interest of exercising that intellect, I would add something else: Write about something other than current politics. Do not limit yourself to fighting with people who are alive. Fight with some of the intellectual greats. Fight with historians, scientists, and academics. And then after you fight with them, have the decency to admit when they've kicked your ass. Do not use your platform to act like they didn't. Getting your ass kicked is an essential part of growing your intellectual muscle.One should probably let reading old books kick one's gluteal area as well.
Showing posts with label Writing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Writing. Show all posts
Thursday, May 2, 2013
Quotation Of The Day: Good Political Writing Begins With Writing About The Past Edition
From this Ta-Nehisi Coates post at The Atlantic:
Wednesday, April 3, 2013
A Minor Musing About The AP Stylebook And Labels
The AP Stylebook, the bible of newspaper folk everywhere, has decreed that the term "illegal immigrant" should no longer be used:
For many, however, the simple label frequently seems insufficient. They must create a "them" to demonize. These folks seem unsatisfied asserting Barack Obama is a Democratic politician. They want to be more forceful: Barack Obama is the anti-Christ. Since that sentiment might be seen as too dramatic, they settle for labels: Barack Obama is a Marxist Kenyan anti-colonialist politician. For local examples, read any recent post here.
It seems that the only positive labels are the ones that one gives to one's self:
I don't know if any stylebook has rules for that phrasing.
The Stylebook no longer sanctions the term “illegal immigrant” or the use of “illegal” to describe a person. Instead, it tells users that “illegal” should describe only an action, such as living in or immigrating to a country illegally.Big Boy Blogger Kevin Drum grouses a bit. His headline makes a valid point: "'Illegal Immigrant' Is Now Out, But AP Doesn't Tell Us What's In." He then goes on to bemoan the loss of a label:
AP apparently now feels that there's no acceptable way to refer to people who are in the country illegally. Neither "undocumented immigrant" nor "unauthorized immigrant," is acceptable, and neither is anything else. Labels are flatly not allowed, despite the fact that we label people all the time. Kevin Drum is a blogger. Barack Obama is a politician. Etc.As a grammar teacher, I am happy that AP has decreed that illegal describe an action rather than a person. The distinction seems intuitive. I am not unsympathetic to Drum's complaint; some term needs to replace "illegal immigrant." Further, labels are sometimes necessary. I am not just a teacher. I am an English teacher.
For many, however, the simple label frequently seems insufficient. They must create a "them" to demonize. These folks seem unsatisfied asserting Barack Obama is a Democratic politician. They want to be more forceful: Barack Obama is the anti-Christ. Since that sentiment might be seen as too dramatic, they settle for labels: Barack Obama is a Marxist Kenyan anti-colonialist politician. For local examples, read any recent post here.
It seems that the only positive labels are the ones that one gives to one's self:
I don't like labels. I am a conservative liberal radical skeptic who believes in good education for all: blog.nj.com/njv_bob_braun/…
— Diane Ravitch (@DianeRavitch) May 25, 2012
I don't know if any stylebook has rules for that phrasing.
Labels:
Diane Ravitch,
Political Labels,
Writing
Wednesday, May 30, 2012
Plains Pops: Political Anger Edition
This morning Bob Mercer expressed his continued wonderment about "[a]ll of this anger — and it is truly anger — about Gov. Dennis Daugaard making five endorsements in Republican legislative primaries."
Next fall my students will be responding to this visual writing prompt that John T. Spencer created.
Next fall my students will be responding to this visual writing prompt that John T. Spencer created.
Spencer's accurate realization that American voters are driven by anger made me want to go a bit deeper. There's the obvious exhibitions of beneficial, if not righteous, anger that both sides of the political spectrum will both claim.
One is enjoined, however, to sin not when angry; perhaps because one should avoid the foolishness that perpetual anger may lead to.
I want to see @BarackObama's college records to see how he listed his place of birth in the application.
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) May 30, 2012
In the real world, unfortunately, one can't give the Donald this response
So one will have to be satisfied with this response:
Labels:
Plains Pops,
Politics,
pop culture,
Writing
Monday, May 14, 2012
An Example Of The Need To Be A Lifelong Learner?
This David Montgomery tweet shows that some problems never go away.
Very different but equally challenging: Writing a short article based on a mountain of notes, and writing one based on not enough notes.
— David Montgomery (@rcjMontgomery) May 14, 2012
My students have the same problems. They probably don't resolve them as well as Mr. Montgomery does, but they don't limit their thesis on longer essays, and they often haven't studied enough to have enough support for their answers on essay tests.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
