Showing posts with label False Hope. Show all posts
Showing posts with label False Hope. Show all posts

Thursday, April 28, 2011

"Useless"? College Degrees

The Daily Beast has published a list entitled The 20 Most Useless College Majors.  The writers used the following criteria:
To find the most useless degrees college students can get with their four years and hundreds of thousands of dollars, we wanted to know which majors offer not only the fewest job opportunities, but those that tend to pay the least. The Daily Beast considered the following data points, weighted equally, with each degree’s numbers compared to the average for each category, to achieve a categorical comparison that accounts for differentiation from the mean. Data are from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics and Payscale:
According the Beast, the most useless major, much to their chagrin, is journalism.  In what must be seen as bad news for South Dakota, horticulture and agriculture rank second and third.

The most interesting rankings are numbers eight and nine: mechanical engineering and chemistry, two STEM staples.  Although literature and English rank 15 and 19, I can console myself with the Beast's conclusion: "Several majors on this list—photography, literature, theater—suffer from low starting and mid- career salaries, but still show potential for job growth, and industry superstars can still make a very nice living."

I see a large number of students guided toward careers in engineering or sciences because these careers are practical.  Those offering advice need to remember that advice should be practical enough to help students realize that the most practical thing is getting both a job and a livable paycheck.

Thursday, March 24, 2011

The Problems with Solutions

In this past weekend's NYT, David Greenberg asks why last chapters of books that dissect social or political problems often fail to deliver.  Greenberg gives numerous examples to support the assertion that "[e]ven those social critics who acknowledge the difficulty of their solutions cannot help offering up the equally quixotic hope that people will somehow rise up spontaneously against the diagnosed ills."

He offers two possible reasons. One is "the sheer difficulty of devising answers to complex social problems that are sound, practicable and not blindingly obvious" especially when "those who give the most subtle diagnoses may not have the problem-solving disposition needed to come up with concrete, practical recommendations."

Greenburg  later contends that "most authors have themselves to blame."  Because they have researched and become an expert in the subject, "almost all succumb to the hubristic idea that they can find new and unique ideas for solving intractable problems."

Blogging for Mother Jones, Kevin Drum concludes, "any social or political problem that's hard enough to be interesting is also hard enough to have no obvious solutions. In fact, most of them are hard enough not to have any short-term solutions at all, obvious or not."

I'll add two more.  First, American readers won't listen to anything but an optimistic conclusion.  To his credit Greenburg hints at that possibility when he writes "[p]ractically every example of that genre, no matter how shrewd or rich its survey of the question at hand, finishes with an obligatory prescription that is utopian, banal, unhelpful or out of tune with the rest of the book."

Greenburg's examples certainly illustrate the banality.  For example, Walter Lippman concludes his 1922 Public Opinion by saying that "[t]he preceding years of world war and crisis . . .offered models of inspiration as well as despair, and a new realism might yet beat back 'the brutality and the hysteria' of modern life."  More recently,
Allan Bloom’s “Closing of the American Mind” (1987), still an influential filleting of university life, features on its last page this thought: “I still believe that universities, rightly understood, are where community and friendship can exist in our times. . . . They have served us well.” Al Gore’s Bush-era polemic “The Assault on Reason” (2007), which argues that the rise of new media, increasing income inequality and deepening partisanship have driven evidence and logic from public debate, still ends with the former vice president declaring, “I feel more confident than ever before that democracy will prevail.”
My students demand happy endings to nearly every piece of literature the read; I can't imagine them or very many other people accepting that the problem can't be easily solved.

Second,  the authors have drunk so much of the ideological Kool-Aid that prompted them to do the research that they can't or won't listen to solutions that don't fit into their framework nor will they accept solutions that come from political foes.  No one seems willing to deal with substantive arguments.  Instead, most seem to prefer to deal with only the easiest straw men.  I suppose that problem is tied to the hubris that Greenburg cites. 

Greenburg has done enough to convince me that the simple, banal, one-size-fits-all solutions are as problematic as the situations they purport to solve. Dramatic cuts to education, busting unions, mandating everyone buy insurance, or bombing the hell out Mideastern country are simple solutions, but thehaven't fixed any complex problems. 

Monday, May 3, 2010

Just When I Was Getting Ready To Convert To Cyber Utopianism--

This Foreign Policy article made me get all warm and cynical again.  The whole article is worth a read, but this summary says it all.
Two decades in, the Internet has neither brought down dictators nor eliminated borders. It has certainly not ushered in a post-political age of rational and data-driven policymaking. It has sped up and amplified many existing forces at work in the world, often making politics more combustible and unpredictable. Increasingly, the Internet looks like a hypercharged version of the real world, with all of its promise and perils, while the cyberutopia that the early Web enthusiasts predicted seems ever more illusory.
Oh well, I'm sure some administrator will figure out how to make the Internet revolutionize education and make teachers unnecessary.