Wednesday, August 8, 2018

With Friends Like These...: A Musing About Dollar General Expanding In South Dakota

My grocery shopping options consist of three soulless corporations: HyVee, Walmart, and Amazon. The former offers both a "helpful smile in every aisle" and home delivery. The latter delivers to my door products not available locally, and Walmart lets me buy both the rice cooker and the rice in one trip.

There is one other option, Dollar Tree. It's never been clear if their cheap offerings offer the value that they appear to. This article about the Dollar General chain expanding in South Dakota, therefore, creates both curiosity and ambivalence. On the one hand, the stores, which sell "affordable" products, may offer shopping opportunities to communities without a grocery or clothing stores. On the other hand,

Once Dollar General picks a town for its next location, local business owners and city officials can do little to stop the chain from becoming a neighbor. 
If Dollar General can't find a spot in city limits, Colby picks a location nearby on county land. 
A store still opens, except it doesn't contribute any sales tax back to the community it serves until the land is annexed.
Forcing someone to be a neighbor doesn't square with the behavior Mr. Rogers taught especially when "smaller retailers who compete with Dollar General [lose] business because of an inability to compete with the national chain's prices."

Dollar General 's "aggressive growth plan" in South Dakota creates another concern because one of the chain's target customer base is "[p]eople who live closer to the poverty line and [shop] at Dollar General stores out of necessity. " These company calls these customers who live paycheck-to-paycheck and [rely] on government assistance their "best friends forever"

Dollar General's efforts have two likely outcomes. First, the corporation has done its homework and its new South Dakota stores will be successful. Given the chain's marketing strategy, South Dakota will, therefore, see an increase of people living at or near the poverty line, and Dollar General will have a host of new BFFs.

The second possibility is that many of the stores will fail. While that eventuality may mean that fewer South Dakotans are living in dire straits, it may also portend a larger number of towns without local grocery or clothing store because Dollar General forced local owners out of business.

Neither result bodes well for South Dakota's smaller communities.



No comments: