Tuesday, July 10, 2018

The American Republic: December 7, 1787-July, 8, 2018 RIP

It's been a heck of run, but nothing humans create lasts forever.

Yesterday, Jonathan Chait published a thought piece entitled "Will Trump Be Meeting With His Counterpart — Or His Handler? A plausible theory of mind-boggling collusion." The general theory behind Chait's piece is that Donald Trump has been a Russian asset since 1987.

Meanwhile The Daily Beast recently posted an article on the QAnon conspiracy theory. Will Sommer sums up the theory


Plotters in the deep state tried to shoot down Air Force One and foil President Trump’s North Korea summit. A cabal of global elites, including top figures in Hollywood, the Democratic Party, and the intelligence agencies, are responsible for nearly all the evil in the world. And now Trump is going to fix it all with thousands of sealed indictments, sending the likes of Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama straight to Guantanamo Bay.

Or at least that’s how the world is going for the believers of QAnon. . .

Perhaps this post's title is a bit over dramatic. The physician may have just told the Republic to go home, hug its children, and get its affairs in order. Let's run through a few reasons that these theories, plausible or not, are worrisome. (We'll leave aside the obvious point that if either is true, the Republic obviously has been destroyed.)

First, we've admittedly had nutty theories throughout our history: the Masons are running everything; electing JFK will create a Catholic theocracy, and 9/11 was an inside job come to mind rather quickly. There may have been a "Custer was set up" theory in 1876. These two theories seem different in kind and degree. Both are large, structured in a way that demands opponents prove a negative, and place rot at the very core of the government.

Second, a democratic republic exists on the premise that certain truths are shared by all. It's unclear that one who accepts the QAnon theory can even have a cup of coffee with someone who believes Chait's theory plausible. Even a young earth creationist and an atheist who accepts string theory as fact can agree that a sunset is pretty. These two camps, however, live in realities where the sky has vastly different hues.

Finally, there are a few what ifs. If Trump is impeached or indicted, how will the QAnon folk react? What will they do if he loses in 2020? Likewise, what will those who take Chait's analysis to heart do if Trump wins in 2020? What will either side do if Democrats win the House but control of the Senate rests on a handful of disputed ballots in the North Dakota Senate race?

If my Twitter feed is any indication, some folks hold the QAnon theory with a fervor that makes overzealous missionaries jealous. The Chait article is recent enough that it hasn't gained much traction, but given time, it likely will. In 1964, Barry Goldwater claimed, "Extremism in the defense of liberty is no vice. . ." He was wrong; as Aristotle showed centuries earlier, extremism is always a vice. In Federalist 10, Madison lays out the risks of faction. The factions that either of these theories create could well end the project Madison started



No comments: