On a serious note, I wish that I had the prophetic voice to express my outrage at BP's actions and follow the scriptural injunction to avoid sin in my anger. But when I read reports like this one from the New York Times, I become enraged and I'm more than likely guilty of some serious wrath.
New government and BP documents, interviews with experts and testimony by witnesses provide the clearest indication to date that a hodgepodge of oversight agencies granted exceptions to rules, allowed risks to accumulate and made a disaster more likely on the rig, particularly with a mix of different companies operating on the Deepwater whose interests were not always in sync. (Urbina, "In Gulf, It Was Unclear Who Was in Charge of Rig" NYT 6/5/2010 bold mine)Maybe I have read too many Spider-Man comics because I actually believe that possessing great power includes a great responsibility. Apparently comic books are for kids because huge multinational corporations and government regulators have great power but apparently don't see the need for any responsibility, unless one wants to count a slick PR stunt disguised as an apology.
I also agree with James Madison that "[i]f men were angels, no government would be necessary." Madison's use of the subjunctive mood in this passage from Federalist 51 indicates that he is well aware that humans are not angels and are, therefore, imperfect. Madison's modern insight is over two centuries old, and should urge those undertaking risky efforts such as this to follow the basics of the Hippocratic oath and make every effort to do no harm.
On this rig, however, The Times reports that the "human element [had] not been aligned with the complexity of the system." Further, hat lack of attention to detail was compounded by a woefully inadequate disaster plan.
On the Deepwater Horizon, for example, the minerals agency approved a drilling plan for BP that cited the “worst case” for a blowout as one that might produce 250,000 barrels of oil per day, federal records show. But the agency did not require the rig to create a response plan for such a situation. (emphasis added)I would be willing to grudgingly accept this disaster as an expensive mistake if I believed that the US would learn from it and make plains to move away from oil addiction. I would be overjoyed if I believed that Christians would heed Russel D Moore's warning and avoid hiding their light under a bushel by adopting the worldview of political allies on the hot button issue of the day.
I don't believe that either of those events will occur. Within thirty years, someone at a political convention will scream the equivalent of "Drill Baby, Brill!" and be hailed as an insightful populist voice of the common person. The next generation of religious leaders will trade their spiritual birthright for some political pottage. The people on the Gulf Coast will still be cleaning up the mess and trying to pick up the pieces of lives that were ruined by corporate hubris and the willful blindness of governmental overseers. It's really tough to avoid getting sinfully angry.
No comments:
Post a Comment