I wish I knew how to think about economics.
A NYT review of Robert H. Frank's Falling Behind: How Rising Inequality Harms the Middle Class contains two interesting stats that make me want to be a Marxist and rant against the rich.
First, "[b]etween 1949 and 1979, the rising tide of the American economy lifted all boats more or less equally. In fact, the incomes of the bottom 80 percent grew more rapidly than the incomes of the top 1 percent, and those of the bottom 20 percent grew most rapidly of all."
Second, "the richest 1 percent have seen their share of national income rise from 8.2 percent in 1980 to 17.4 percent in 2005."
The super rich are soaking up 17% of the national income which, I guess, is $13 trillion. Using a labor force of 151.4 million, that means that 1.5 million people earn $2.2 trillion. No one can claim that distribution is anyway near just.
Later, I began to think that the fault lies not in our rich stars but in ourselves. A second NYT article recounts the dilemma faced by silicon valley millionaires who don’t feel rich. ". . . [M]any . . . accomplished and ambitious members of the digital elite still do not think of themselves as particularly fortunate, in part because they are surrounded by people with more wealth — often a lot more."
I really want to laugh at these people but I can't. I don't have a million dollars, and I'm not sure if I know a millionaire, but I can identify with Tony Barbagallo.
“You look around,” Mr. Barbagallo said, “and the pressures to spend more are everywhere.” Children want the latest fashions their peers are wearing and the most popular high-ticket toys. Furniture does not seem up to snuff once you move into a multimillion-dollar home. Spouses talk, and now that resort in Mexico the family enjoyed so much last winter is not good enough when looking ahead to next year. Summer camp, a full-time housekeeper, vintage wines, country clubs: the cost of living bloats."
I can't think of a parent who doesn't fact Barbagallo's problem with his children. Even parents who don't send out kids to the Hamptons send kids to dance camps, football camps, debate camps, or music camps. These camps obliterate checkbook balances Right now, I'm looking at getting another laptop for family use.
I don't know much about vintage wines or country clubs, but gourmet coffees and dozens of other little luxuries take bigger chunks of the checkbook than Folgers regular grind.
I guess I really don't know what to think. The US's income distribution is not just and probably dangerous. Yet, most, if not all Americans, spend more than they should on luxery items.
Comments welcome, but remember bromides won't work. "Stop Spending" or "Don't Flaunt It If You Ain't Got It" isn't going to be any more effective than "Just Say No." Telling the poor not to get computers or cable TV really isn't practical, especially for those who have kids in school. "The Rich Suck" isn't an answer either.
No comments:
Post a Comment