First, it's always scary to be an English teacher and blog. One always rushes and dozens of embarrassing errors will be made and caught.
More importantly, it's getting tougher to deal with the belligerence behind the question "When will I need this junk?"
In a round-about way, that's the question that some of the folks on The American Scene are dealing with when they hashing over a couple of David Brooks NYT column here and here and here. (This primer on the Pew Categories might be helpful.)
While Reihan Salam seems to support the Upbeats' notions, Daniel Larison and James Poulos are more skeptical. Larison proudly describes himself as a "Downbeat," and Poulos writes,
Money, of course, ties it all together, and if someone or some group of people is unwilling to turn some possession of theirs over to money, or strongly prejudiced against doing so, Upbeat Warning Signals flash. It isn't that Upbeats care nothing, as a matter of public record, for tradition or the beautiful or their own children. Some Upbeats are the fiercest protectors of these things, . . . . But Upbeats reject protectionism and parochialism as a rule, because they see unnatural and often irrational impediments to market meritocracy. Upbeats do not like the idea that money is not really what life is all about -- not so much because they believe that it is, but because they believe that a good person who works hard to make as much money as they are able is therefore able to acquire the ingredients of the good life. . . . But the most upbeat ideal of the Upbeat is that any uprooted individual, an enterprising social atom with the right attitude and a few ethics in his or her pocket, can earn, on the open market, the pride and the money that comes with the right kind of brains.
This description of the Upbeats dovetails nicely with Wendell Berry's description of higher education. Berry asserts,
. . . the great and the would-be-great “research universities”. . . . no longer make even the pretense of preparing their students for responsible membership in a family, a community, or a polity. They have repudiated their old obligation to pass on to students at least something of their cultural inheritance. The ideal graduate no longer is to have a mind well-equipped to serve others, or to judge competently the purposes for which it may be used. Now, according to those institutions of the “cutting edge,” the purpose of education is unabashedly utilitarian. Their interest is almost exclusively centered in the technical courses called, with typical ostentation of corporate jargon, STEM: science, technology, engineering, and mathematics. The American civilization so ardently promoted by these institutions is to be a civilization entirely determined by technology, and not encumbered by any thought of what is good or worthy or neighborly or humane.
Berry's critique holds true for secondary education as well, and that fact brings about a few rather frightening thoughts. First, the humanities classes will soon become extinct. After all, knowing Shakespeare won't teach some high school grad to read a tech manual. Second, the Upbeat or materialistic mindset will continue prevail because Upbeats control the linguistic levers to extend their reach. Upbeats seem to be practitioners of framing that would do George Lakoff or even Frank Luntz proud. Poulos writes,
Opt out, and you are a protectionist, one of the fearful; opt out deliberately, as a matter of policy, and you are probably a fearmonger, too. Those with contempt for the trivial glory of worldly materialism, or disdain for consistent, hard work on behalf of not particularly desperate strangers, or an overpowering interest in their own families -- all have the onus of learning to live with, and finally live in, the world continually created and expanded and recreated by the Upbeats.
Somehow, it's tough to feel upbeat about the future if I'm supposed to turn every student into a tool that exists only to make others money.
1 comment:
Good for people to know.
Post a Comment