Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Quotation Of The Day: Why I Can't Be A Republican (Continued) Edition

From this Jeremiah Goulka article at The American Conservative:
I used to be a serious Republican, moderate and business-oriented, who planned for a public-service career in Republican politics. But I am a Republican no longer.
There’s an old joke we Republicans used to tell that goes something like this: “If you’re young and not a Democrat, you’re heartless. If you grow up and you’re not a Republican, you’re stupid.” These days, my old friends and associates no doubt consider me the butt of that joke. But I look on my “stupidity” somewhat differently. After all, my real education only began when I was 30 years old. . . .
I always imagined that I was full of heart, but it turned out that I was oblivious. Like so many Republicans, I had assumed that society’s “losers” had somehow earned their desserts. As I came to recognize that poverty is not earned or chosen or deserved, and that our use of force is far less precise than I had believed, I realized with a shock that I had effectively viewed whole swaths of the country and the world as second-class people.
No longer oblivious, I couldn’t remain in today’s Republican Party, not unless I embraced an individualism that was even more heartless than the one I had previously accepted. The more I learned about reality, the more I started to care about people as people, and my values shifted. Had I always known what I know today, it would have been clear that there hasn’t been a place for me in the Republican Party since the Free Soil days of Abe Lincoln.
I've never fit the description in the first paragraph. I heard and believed the second, especially when someone told me that Winston Churchill formulated the original sentiment about conservatives.

The whole article is worth a read. Goulka's life differs from mine. I grew up as a member of the rural poor without indoor plumbing not as a resident of the rich suburbs of Chicago. The solution to being poor was always to work harder. That being said, his journey away from the modern Republican party mirrors mine. His comments about the global war on terror and the callous attitude toward poverty ring especially true.




Coming Soon To A Political Commerical Near You: Buzzword Bingo

Buzzword Number 1: Cory points to a Steve Hickey Facebook post and hints that Governor Daugaard and his allies will soon be screaming "Run for the hills the sky is falling! The Unions are coming! The Unions are coming! The Horror! The Humanity! The Unions are coming!"

Buzzword Numbers 2, 3, 4: Ed Kilgore points to a Sarah Palin interview:
Not to be outdone, Sarah Palin told Bill O’Reilly yesterday that she agreed with this warning to Romney, noting Ingraham’s threats and saying: “I couldn’t have said it better myself.” She also offered these suggestions to Mitt:

Fox News’s Bill O’Reilly asked the former Alaska governor on Tuesday if Romney’s campaign — which has come under fire from Republicans — needs to go after Obama in a “more personal way” and use buzzwords like “incompetent, dangerous, socialist.”

“Those aren’t just buzzwords,” said Palin. “Those are accurate descriptions of the commander in chief.”

“He should be very aggressive, and he should be adamant in his attacks on Obama’s record, which is so dismal, his plan, or lack of a plan of Obama’s, to get his out of these woeful times,” Palin continued. “He needs to be severely aggressive.”
One apparently loses the game if one is only "moderately" aggressive or if one utters anything that can be considered substantive. At this time, it's unclear if one has to utter the phrase "God Bless America!" at the conclusion of each buzzword combination.


In South Dakota, the Bingo Debate over Referred Law 16 will probably proceed with the following vapid buzzword combinations to answer any and all attacks:
Opponent: Supporting Referred Law 16 will do nothing to help teachers to teach better nor will it help students learn more.

Governor Daugaard: We should enact Referred Law 16 because the Union of Dangerous Incompetent Socialists supports the referral. God Bless America and South Dakota! Eat your vegetables! Bingo! Winner!
Although "Eat your vegetables" isn't one of the official buzzwords, the Governor's motto on cliches will probably be "Better safe than sorry."

Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Quotation Of The Day: George Carlin On Group Identity

From the preface to Brain Droppings:
The decay and disintegration of this culture is astonishingly amusing if you are emotionally detached from it. I have always viewed it from a safe distance, knowing I don't belong; it doesn't include me, and it never has. No matter how you care to define it, I do not identify with the local group. Planet, species, race, nation, state, religion, party, union, club, association, neighborhood improvement committee; I have no interest in any of it. I love and treasure individuals as I meet them, I loathe and despise the groups they identify with  and belong to. (xii)

Monday, September 10, 2012

Let's Remember 1980 Correctly

I love history. History is a friend of mine. You, sir, aren't doing real history.

I know I'm the 7,923.696th person to modify that line from 1988. I also know that 1988 is not 1980, but this return to the late 1980 election when disco was dying, new wave was starting, and Ronald Reagan was riding his white horse to the White House frustrates me because it is so inaccurate. I don't know if Romney will successfully buy the election, but if he's not going to win with the claim that he is the next Ronald Reagan whereas Obama is the second coming of  Jimmy Carter.

First, if Americans actually chose Reagan because he was more charismatic that Carter, then Obama will win this election hands down. Romney is robot and robots ain't charismatic.

More importantly, there was a third factor in the election that everyone but David Frum seems to have forgotten.
There is another difference, at least equally crucial and often overlooked today: 1980 was a three-way race. Reagan won a landslide of the electoral vote, but less than 51% of the popular vote. President Carter's support collapsed in the last weeks of the campaign, with dissident liberals breaking off to support the independent candidacy of John Anderson, who scored 6.6% of the vote - the third best performance by an independent since World War II, after Ross Perot in 1992 and 1996.
If Anderson had not run - if Carter had not so alienated his liberal base - what would have happened in November? Who can say - but let's remember the actual events of 1980, not a too-gratifying legend.

Quotation Of The Day: Capitalism And Education Edition

Gary Gutting explains capitalism and education::
From our infancy the market itself has worked to make us consumers, primed to buy whatever it is selling regardless of its relevance to human flourishing. True freedom requires that we take part in the market as fully formed agents, with life goals determined not by advertising campaigns but by our own experience of and reflection on the various possibilities of human fulfillment. Such freedom in turn requires a liberating education, one centered not on indoctrination, social conditioning or technical training but on developing persons capable of informed and intelligent commitments to the values that guide their lives.
This is why, especially in our capitalist society, education must not be primarily for training workers or consumers (both tools of capitalism, as Marxists might say). Rather, schools should aim to produce self-determining agents who can see through the blandishments of the market and insist that the market provide what they themselves have decided they need to lead fulfilling lives. Capitalism, with its devotion to profit, is not in itself evil. But it becomes evil when it controls our choices for the sake of profit.
The whole article is a must read. I also loved his analysis of the role of work in creating human flourishing.

Sunday, September 9, 2012

Did Mitt Romney Just Blow The "Obama Is An Atheist" Dog Whistle?

I'm a little late getting to this because I was playing debate coach on Friday and Saturday.

According to OTUS blog, Mitt Romney made the following comments when referencing the kerfuffle over God allegedly being removed from the Democratic platform:
“I will not take God out of the name of our platform,” said Romney to thunderous applause. “I will not take God off our coins and I will not take God out of my heart. We’re a nation that’s bestowed by God.”
The first two sentence set up comparisons. The implication inherent in the first sentence is that that Democrats removed God from their platform but Romney won't. The second sentence begins with another implied comparison. I'm guessing that the statement about coins refers to various lawsuits about removing "In God we trust" from currency. Romney is pandering to a crowd that assumes that the ACLU and Democrats are one in the same. In short, people who remove God from their political documents will remove God from currency and presumably, the Pledge of Allegiance. That trend creates a slippery slope that, carried out to its hyperbolic conclusion, ends with Democrats removing God from the Bible.

The comparisons between the parties in the first two clauses leave little doubt that the personal statement, "I will not take God out of my heart," is also comparative. Romney is running against not only a party but President Obama, the party's nominee. If Romney won't "take God out of his heart," the intention behind the comparison is that Obama has removed God from his heart.

At best, the phrasing is a political cheap shot aimed below the belt; at worst Romney is appropriating unto himself the power to determine the quality and depth of another person's faith, a hubris worthy of Greek tragedy.

As a side note, Romney needs to rephrase the speech to eliminate the awkward and incorrect use of the verb "bestow" which is usually used to indicate the granting of a gift or honor. For example, it is my fervent prayer that God will "bestow" upon all Americans the wisdom to distill the wheat from the chaff when political candidates utter their banal talking points.

Scripture And Song Of The Week: Matthew Edition

Matthew 13
KJV

1 The same day went Jesus out of the house, and sat by the sea side.

2 And great multitudes were gathered together unto him, so that he went into a ship, and sat; and the whole multitude stood on the shore.

3 And he spake many things unto them in parables, saying, Behold, a sower went forth to sow;

4 And when he sowed, some seeds fell by the way side, and the fowls came and devoured them up:

5 Some fell upon stony places, where they had not much earth: and forthwith they sprung up, because they had no deepness of earth:

6 And when the sun was up, they were scorched; and because they had no root, they withered away.

7 And some fell among thorns; and the thorns sprung up, and choked them:

8 But other fell into good ground, and brought forth fruit, some an hundredfold, some sixtyfold, some thirtyfold.

9 Who hath ears to hear, let him hear.