Monday, September 13, 2010

A Little Candle In The Darkness

This Thomas Friedman editorial quotes this Robert Samuelson editorial about the failures of school reform.  Samuelson and by extension Friedman's get to the crux of one of education's main problems.
The larger cause of failure is almost unmentionable: shrunken student motivation. Students, after all, have to do the work. If they aren't motivated, even capable teachers may fail.
Motivation comes from many sources: curiosity and ambition; parental expectations; the desire to get into a "good" college; inspiring or intimidating teachers; peer pressure. The unstated assumption of much school "reform" is that if students aren't motivated, it's mainly the fault of schools and teachers. The reality is that, as high schools have become more inclusive (in 1950, 40 percent of 17-year-olds had dropped out, compared with about 25 percent today) and adolescent culture has strengthened, the authority of teachers and schools has eroded. That applies more to high schools than to elementary schools, helping explain why early achievement gains evaporate.
 Samuelson's conclusion is spot on.
Against these realities, school "reform" rhetoric is blissfully evasive. It is often an exercise in extravagant expectations. Even if George W. Bush's No Child Left Behind program had been phenomenally successful (it wasn't), many thousands of children would have been left behind. Now Duncan routinely urges "a great teacher" in every classroom. That would be about 3.7 million "great" teachers -- a feat akin to having every college football team composed of all-Americans. With this sort of intellectual rigor, what school "reform" promises is more disillusion.
The problems facing education are structural.  All parties share blame; it's good to see someone finally including students in the equation.

Thursday, September 2, 2010

My Mother And The Economy

This Bloomberg article can hardly be accused of burying the lede.

            The U.S. economy is so bad that the chance of avoiding a double dip back into recession may actually be pretty good.

The sectors of the economy that traditionally drive it into recession are already so depressed it’s difficult to see them getting a lot worse, said Ethan Harris, head of developed markets economics research at BofA Merrill Lynch Global Research in New York. Inventories are near record lows in proportion to sales, residential construction is less than half the level of the housing boom and vehicle sales are more than 40 percent below five years ago.

I suppose I should find this reassuring.  My wife and I have jobs; we’re not out on the streets, and the kids are in college.  We’re getting by, and if things don’t get worse, we should continue to get by. 

On the other hand, Ethan Harris has never met my mother.  When, as a young plainsman, I would complain about a person or situation, Momma Plainsperson would tell me “there’s nothing so bad that there can’t be something worse.”  I complained about school lunch; my mother told me “there’s nothing so bad that there can’t be something worse.”  She was right.  The head cook who replaced the one I complained about produced thinner gruel and drier bread crusts than her predecessor.  When I complained about my first boss, my mother told me “there’s no one so bad that there can’t be someone worse.”  She was right.  I’ve had several who were far worse including one who said “ideals” when he meant “ideas.”  I believe he made this mistake because he had very few of either. 

I really can’t think of a time when my mother’s injunction has been wrong.  Bad situations have invariably gotten worse  Mom may not have economic charts and graphs on her side, but her track record has me convinced that I should worry a little more than Ethan Harris suggests.

 

Tuesday, August 31, 2010

Lincoln-Douglas Debate Applied To The Internet, Sort Of

This brief article by Alan Jacobs illustrates why I love teaching Lincoln Douglas debate.  His take on the justice, allusion to Hobbes, and reference to other "values" traditionally used in LD and their application to internet civility is a great read.  The key quotation:
I have thought a lot about why people get so hostile online, and I have come to believe it is primarily because we live in a society with a hypertrophied sense of justice and an atrophied sense of humility and charity, to put the matter in terms of the classic virtues.
Late modernity’s sense of itself is built upon achievements in justice. This is especially true of Americans. When we look back over the past century, what do we take pride in? Suffrage for women, the defeat of fascism, Brown vs. Board of Education, civil rights and especially voting rights for African-Americans. If you’re on one side of the political spectrum, you might add the demise of the Soviet empire; if you’re on the other side, you might add the expansion of rights for gays and lesbians. (Or you might add both.) The key point is that all of these are achievements in justice.

Sunday, August 29, 2010

Minor Musings That May Never Become Modest Proposals

The beginning of the school year has given me a sound beating.  I feel overwhelmed and totally unable to develop a coherent post.  Of course, one could argue that none of the posts here have been coherent , but that's a different discussion.  I decided that I would do a post with just the bullet points of stuff I've been thinking about and haven't had time to develop.  Maybe I'll come back to them.  Maybe I'll make this a weekly post.

1. I just watched Secretary of Education Arne Duncan and American Federation of Teachers president Randi Weingarten ABC's This Week.  I was underwhelmed.  It seems as if both believe that business model or some sort of data driven factory model will serve education.  Weingarten contends that teachers need to learn who to make teaching a science.  Since NCLB began, schools have been inundated with demands to become more scientific.  Education has not improved under the scientific regime.  Maybe it's time to stop looking at education as a science and to start treating it like a craft.  If policymakers changed their view, education might be able to adapt some guild model instead of a factory model.

2. I had a good blogging routine going, but I really had trouble making regular posts when I couldn't maintain the routine for whatever reason.  It got me thinking about how much of my life is based on routine.  That musing got me thinking about how much of my life might be a rut.  I stopped before I got too depressed.

3. I've been trying to cut back on the spending lately.  Walmart had Diet Dew, my version of Olympian gods nectar, on sale for a dollar for a 2-liter.  As I walked around the store, I noticed the local store featuring more generic versions of popular products.  That non-scientific observation got me wondering whether the corporation's economists are anticipating another economic downturn or if the local economy is far worse than I thought.

4. It's getting more and more difficult to try to find common ground with students.  I played "The Cave" from Mumford and Sons Sigh No More album because it has allusions to The Odyssey.   The band has a video on VH1's Top 20 Video Countdown, so I thought students might at least be a tad bit interested, but the class seemed underwhelmed.  It seems as if students find a comfortable niche and refuse to look beyond it.  That fact would be fine if confined to music, food choices, or which sports of follow, but it seems to apply to any form of civic engagement or cultural literacy.

5. In a similar vein, I had seven sophomores read this CNN opinion piece about a comic book featuring Islamic superheroes.  At least five of them asked me to define mosque.  Every mainstream news outlet, Channel 1, and late night talk show have covered the ongoing controversy about the mosque near the World Trade Center, but they seem oblivious.  Not only is no place like home; apparently, there's no place but home.

Sunday, August 22, 2010

A Big Sunday Geek Gear Post

Lifehacker recently requested that their readers let them know what they carry in their backpacks.  They then published some of the more clever collections.  Last year, Lifehacker editiors revealed what they carried in laptop bags. Three years ago readers revealed the contents of their "go bags."

I would like to think of myself as a minimalist, but I have a bit of survivalist streak that I think comes from reading The Road and The Odyssey.  Of course, I could be an inveterate pack rat.

Last summer I rewarded myself with a Saddleback Leather briefcase.  (Anyone who has not taught a foreign language in the past 15 years and then tries to teach a full year class in four weeks over the summer deserves a huge reward.)

The bag has four small inner pockets. I put assorted pens in one, assorted small tools like a tape measure in the second.  Another has 3x5 cards and a packet of Starbucks instant coffee; the final pocket holds my cell phone.  I usually have a timer clipped to one these pockets.  The bag has two small outer pockets.  I stick a glasses case in one of them.  The case holds some clip-on sunglasses and a lens cloth.  Bifocals are a bitch.

I use a small portable hard drive case to hold my mp3 player, head phones, and any SD cards or spare thumb/USB drives I might have.  I modified a usb case into a small survival case.  It holds a Leatherman Micra, a Leatherman P4, duct tape, matches, a small flashlight, needles, thread, and safety pins.  I bought a corduroy pencil pouch with 3 zippered compartments.  I put aspirin, Advil, antacid, gum, lip balm, and other incidentals in one.  I put pencils, highlighters, and a pencil sharpener in another.  The third compartment holds assorted cables and chargers.  Finally, I have small surge protecter with three regular outlets and two USB ports.

All of this gear goes in the bag's front partition along with a book or graphic novel.  I also carry a Levenger Circa Junior notebook.  The back inner partition holds work related material.  The back outer pocket holds assorted files or magazines or another graphic novel.  I clip an umbrella to one of the extra D rings.

I don't carry a laptop.  I use the phone to surf the web and keep track of tweets.  I have a computer and work and home,and I can't type well enough to flow a debate round, so the laptop seems to be extra weight.

I feel as if I have too much stuff, although I can honestly say that I've used nearly every item during the past year.  What is essential in a teacher's laptop bag/briefcase/satchel/backpack?  Am I missing any cool geek gear?

Thursday, August 19, 2010

Of Teaching And Testing

Today is the first day with students.  It’s a ritual; there’s a little dog and pony show, a few laughs, a few reminders, and the hope for a fresh start.  

Yesterday, the 2010 ACT data were released. It’s a ritual; there’s a big dog and pony show, several sorrowful condemnations of the nation’s secondary education system, and demands for wholesale change.  

According to the Wall Street Journal article “Scores Stagnate At High Schools,”  “fewer than 25% of 2010 graduates who took the ACT college-entrance exam possessed the academic skills necessary to pass entry-level courses.”  Jack Jennings, president of the Center on Education Policy, asserts that these scores indicate "High schools are the downfall of American school reform. . . ."  

First, without access to the actual data, one has to assume that ACT released the scores of only students who graduated in 2010 not students who took the test in 2010.  Large numbers of juniors take the test every spring.  Juniors have completed only 75% of their high school education; they probably shouldn’t be college ready.  Second, many seniors take the tests offered in September or October.  Once again, they have over half of their senior year to develop the requisite skills.  

ACT may have some formula to take these factors into account. Outside of Delphi, prophecy is a tricky business. I’d like to know how a testing company can determine whether a given student will or will not learn enough to prepare them for college when meteorologists have trouble accurately predicting tomorrow’s weather.  
Let’s assume that ACT has correctly ascertained that graduates are not prepared for the future, and let’s take at face value that this fact “suggests that the core courses they are taking are not sufficient to prepare them for what they will face in college or the work force."  What should the education establishment do?  I want to do my job.  I don’t want to send students out to fail.  

I’ll offer a few modest proposals.  I would guess that they will be ignored.  

First, colleges and universities should end their practice of accepting students in October or November.  No student should be accepted until April 15.  Students who have been accepted don’t need to work with the same rigor as those who are still trying to impress admission committees.  

Second, colleges and universities need to reject more applicants.  If more students saw that poor high school performance meant not being able to attend college, more students would work.  Listening to lectures is preferable to asking “Do you want fries with that?” 

Third, scrap NCLB.  Under NCLB, high schools are applying a version of the Pareto principle; 80% of the effort and resources are going to the 20% who must be brought up the proficient so that America can say 100% of its students are proficient in reading and math.  The rest of the students are given the other 20% of a school’s resources.  Moving away from NCLB will allow schools to allocate more resources to prepare students for college.  

Fourth, lengthen or alter the school year.  The WSJ article quotes Joseph Harris, director of the National High School Center at the American Institutes for Research, who says, "We have a conflict where we are trying to increase the rigor and push kids to learn more, yet we try to do all of this in the same 180 days, 40-50 minute classes we've always had.  High schools are still very traditional institutions."  

There’s no doubt in my mind that teachers and schools can and should do more.  The problem is that most solutions forced upon secondary education have worsened the situation.  This round of hand-wringing is unlikely to change that trend.

Sunday, August 15, 2010

Why Didn't We Think Of This?

Germany had its best economic performance since reunification during the past quarter.  If the country's growth rate continues over the entire year, Germany's economy will grow nearly 9 percent according to the New York Times.

The NYT reports that German officials believe that "they handled the financial crisis and the painful recession that followed it far better than the United States. . . ."  I'll leave that claim for pundits to sort out in the short term and for historians to sort out in the long term.

The German response differed from the rest of Europe's and the United States' response in several ways,  One major difference is that during the crisis Germany vastly expanded "a program paying to keep workers employed, rather than dealing with them once they lost their jobs . . . ." 

So, instead of paying money for people to have a job that consists of looking for work, spend the money to help people remain productive.  The idea of keeping people working instead of paying them to look for work makes a lot of sense especially with the pernicious effects of long term unemployment.

The March 2010 Atlantic Monthly asserts "[a]ll available evidence suggests that long bouts of unemployment—particularly male unemployment—. . . enfeeble the jobless and warp their families . . . ."  More disturbingly, the same article reports that "among teenagers, . . ., even the narrowest measure of unemployment stood at roughly 27 percent."  The article concludes that if unemployment continues at its current rates, "it is likely to warp our politics, our culture, and the character of our society for years."

Further, CNNMoney.com reports "worker productivity fell 0.9% in the second quarter."  That drop is "the first decline in eighteen months." The article contends that the drop "may be a sign that employees have finally gotten to the point where they are simply stretched too thin."

So far government stimulus money seems to have helped executives get big bonuses; it has produces frazzled workers who are happy to have jobs and fearful of losing them, and put a generation of young workers at risk. Given the political climate, it seems unlikely that additional stimulus money will be appropriated.

American leaders had one chance to respond to the economic disaster properly.  It seems they preferred to look backward and take care of their corporate paymasters instead of using common sense.