Saturday, July 19, 2014

A Minor Musing And Musical Interlude Concerning Signs

Bob Mercer is sign counting. By Mercer's count, Mike Rounds and Gordon Howie are winning the political signage battle in South Dakota's United States Senate race.

@RinoMikeSD seems to have a fixation with signs.
I wish Wieland and Pressler had more signs up. In politics, out of sight is out of mind. I suspect that the ability to place signs indicates a well-organized, well-staffed campaign.

That said, I have yet to meet anyone who has voted for someone based on signage. In fact, I suspect that the number of signs a candidate has out has about as much to do with the candidate's success as the number of Twitter followers a candidate has. (Democrats better hope that thesis is incorrect. As of this posting, Rick Wieland has 3,490 followers whereas the Mike Rounds campaign account has 1,197 followers.)

Of course, It may be that I have my aversion to caring about signs only because this song was popular during my formative years.

I Try To Chart South Dakota Republicans' Worldview

School will soon be starting. I try to learn to use a few online tools each summer. This morning I looked at bubbl.us. For practice, I decided to try to organize South Dakota Republicans' worldviews and trace the connections. It's a work in progress.

South Dakota Republicans' World View
Click to enlarge.

Friday, July 18, 2014

A Short Take On John Thune And 2016

Over at Madville, Cory has begun speculating about John Thune's plans for the White House.

Can we all stipulate that Senator Thune, Representative Noem, Governor Daugaard, and U.S, Senate candidate Mike Rounds are such plastic politicians that it's a miracle South Dakota Republicans haven't all mutated or died of leukemia from drinking the BPA laced  Kool-Aid they dish out by the gallon?

In fact that miracle is so profound that were I advising Gordon Howie of God, Guns, and Gordon fame, I'd tell him to stop talking about God and focus solely on guns. (The only Gordon candidate Howie should talk about is the Barenaked Ladies album. Breathe deeply and return to the subject of the post.)

Thune looks like a movie director's ideal politician, a tall thin man with good hair and a smile ready made for a toothpaste commercial. Those physical features and a plastic nature may make him attractive to South Dakotans. Thune's plasticity does, however, make him cautions.

In a post on his New York Times blog, Ross Douthat, with only a bit of hyperbole, claims conservatives want a magic pill to have the Dow reach 35,000 and a federal budget that reduces spending to levels that existed before the New Deal. Thune may pay lip service to such bromides, but he is unlikely to feature them in a campaign. Nor is he likely to accept anything that Douthat calls "reform conservatism," especially if that reform leads to this result:
A dramatic de-cronyization and de-rentierization of public policy, extending across agriculture and food, energy and housing, higher education and high finance.
A South Dakota Republican running against cronyism would likely be read out of the party.

In short, I don't see Thune running in 2016. That race will feature Republicans using Obama's name like chum to froth up the waters in a manner that makes Sharknado seem as calm as a tiny goldfish bowl. Thune will be too cautious to embrace any idea that will move him stand out of such a Republican presidential candidate pack.

Besides, I'm betting he has a staffer or two telling him that the map looks bad for Republicans in 2016 but that no party has held the White House for more than three terms since Roosevelt and Truman held office from 1933 until 1953. The smart move might be 2020. Even then, Thune will likely advocate an agenda that in Douthat's words "is too modest to matter" rather than one that's "too immodest to succeed."

Thursday, July 17, 2014

Will Republicans Give A Warm Fuzzy To An Atheist Who Drinks Welch's?

Scoff if you will, but the question posed in this post's title may decide how every political question is answered during the next year.

According to a recent Pew Research poll, Jews, Catholics and Evangelicals earn warm rankings from Americans.
Jews, Catholics and evangelical Christians are viewed warmly by the American public. When asked to rate each group on a “feeling thermometer” ranging from 0 to 100 – where 0 reflects the coldest, most negative possible rating and 100 the warmest, most positive rating – all three groups receive an average rating of 60 or higher (63 for Jews, 62 for Catholics and 61 for evangelical Christians). And 44% of the public rates all three groups in the warmest part of the scale (67 or higher).
Hindus and Buddhists are viewed neutrally, but atheists and Muslims don't fare as well.
The public views atheists and Muslims more coldly; atheists receive an average rating of 41, and Muslims an average rating of 40. Fully 41% of the public rates Muslims in the coldest part of the thermometer (33 or below), and 40% rate atheists in the coldest part.
Meanwhile, BrandIndex finds that Americans are united by an inexplicable common affection for some popular brands.
The brands that feature in the top ten for all three political affiliations seem mostly to relate to house and home. Craftsman, Clorox, Dawn, Johnson and Johnson, Home Depot and Cheerios appear in all three lists as well as online mega-retailer Amazon. Home Depot was a new entry for all three lists.
The BrandIndex report, however, shows that Democrats are alone in having Google, PBS, and Dove as part of their top 10 brands. Independents are alone in their top 10 love for the Discovery Channel while Republicans are alone in their newly discovered top 10 taste for Welch's. (It is a positive sign for the American Republic that Fox News has dropped out the Republican top 10.)

These two totally different surveys do point to a way out of gridlock. To the best of my knowledge there are no avowed atheists or Muslims in the Republican leadership. President Obama is a Christian. If the Republican leadership in the House of Representatives and the President would all go to Home Depot, stock their carts with everyone's favorite tools, bleach, and dish soap, go to the checkout lane staffed by a Hindu clerk, and then break open a communal box of Cheerios, some issues might not seem so intractable.

I suspect, however, the political atmosphere has become so noxious that the politicians would soon begin to argue about who had purchased the biggest hammer and whether skim milk is un-American.

Bonus charts for visual learners.

Original Found Here

Original Found Here

A Minor Musing About What Happens When South Dakota Liberals And Conservatives Converse

Spending the past few days recovering from debate camp, dealing with the vagaries of international travel, and participating in the annual family gathering with Mrs. Plainsman's family didn't provide an opportunity to keep up with normal blog reading or write a post.

The reading I did provided two narratives about the practices of those who govern South Dakota. The first, if I may be allowed some poetic license, reads as follows:

In the beginning was the Janklow and he came and went as it pleased him and only him. And we said that it was good. Then came Rounds who begat Daugaard. It matters not who Daugaard will beget because the Dusty and the Marty are of the same cloth, the Gant having been shown to be unworthy.

The other narrative is a little less optimistic. South Dakota lacks transparency. It has ceased to be a government of, by, and for the citizens. Rather it is a government that exists to serve those who govern.

Given that non-Republicans outnumber Republicans and the Republicans right flank is dissatisfied, it should be possible to change a few of the players and create a new narrative. There is, however, one major problem: the political left and the disaffected right do not seem to speak the same language.

I think this is what those on the political right hear whenever liberals speak.



On the other hand, progressives hear this every time conservatives open their mouths.


Until those dissatisfied with the status quo learn to hear what is actually said instead of what they believe is being said, the South Dakota mainstream Republican narrative will likely always end with the following sentence:

And yea verily, it shall be this way forever and ever and it shall always be good for us and those like us. Amen.

Friday, July 11, 2014

A Minor Musing About Conservatives, Dictators, Sean Hannity, And Immigration

If I understand conservatives properly, they believe that too many undocumented immigrants are illegally entering the United States. This influx, according to conservatives, is causing moral and fiscal harms; therefore, the best plan is to close the borders. Since the federal government is not acting; Texas Governor Rick Perry and conservative talking head Sean Hannity have taken up arms to illustrate the correctness of the conservative cause.



On the other hand, many conservatives also believe the federal government has grown dangerously large and powerful. Many believe that President Obama is a dictator.

Given the latter beliefs and given that a closed border guarded by vigilantes like Sean Hannity or legitimate border patrol agents can keep people in as well as keep people out, why would conservatives want to close off an avenue of escape from a dictatorial regime? Creating such a situation doesn't seem conservative. It might even be less prudent than letting Sean Hannity on the river with a gun.

Thursday, July 10, 2014

Unless One Is Starving, Many Things In Education Are More Important Than School Lunch

I really shouldn't have to point out the claim this post's title makes. The fact should be rather self-evident. Unfortunately, Representative Kristi Noem (R-SD), seems fixated on school lunches.

Tweets are supposed to be short, but Noem used only 115 of her allotted 140 characters, so let's go through a short list of "issues that impact SD schools" Noem could have emphasized with a similar number of characters.
25% new superintendents
SD's teacher shortage
Students in poverty
DoE usurps federalism (It's possible I missed the memo that conservatives no longer support federalism or that Noem has renounced conservative principles.)
Testing = corp welfare (I suppose I shouldn't expect Noem to discuss this issue. Corporate welfare is the onlywelfare she supports.)
Arne Duncan's failures (Why is he the only member of the Obama administration Republicans won't criticize?)
Frankly, school lunches should have been part of the tweet only if Noem has evidence that school lunches are composed of Soylent Green. She could have edited other parts of her tweet to make room for"Soylent Green is people!.