Wednesday, July 9, 2014

Quotation OF The Day: An App About Nothing Edition

When one is debating Resolved:Inaction in the face of injustice makes an individual morally culpable, people of a certain age automatically think of the classic television series Seinfeld. Now there's an app for that:
"A couple of Seinfeld enthusiasts have submitted a free app to the Apple store that turns iconic characters and jokes from the show into emojis. . . .
"If approved, the app would let users send puffy shirts, junior mints, and vacuous-eyed Kramers — Kragnor, in the world of Seinfeld Current Day — to each other. No word on whether the emoijs shrink after spending time in a pool."

Tuesday, July 8, 2014

Chad Haber's Candidacy And Moral Quandaries

I am working with some young public forum and Lincoln-Douglas debaters at the South Dakota Debate Workshop being held on the South Dakota State University Campus in beautiful Brookings, South Dakota. I haven't had the time to check the news as much as I usually do because I've been giving a few lectures on debate basics,  cross-examination, and Kant's Categorical Imperative. Tomorrow the young'uns and I will discuss virtue ethics as they prepare to debate Resolved: Inaction in the face of injustice makes an individual morally culpable.

The astute reader may wonder what all of this has to do with Chad Haber's newly announced quixotic candidacy for South Dakota attorney general. Mr. Haber and Lee Stranahan are exploiting the suffering of children for political purposes.  The best analysis of Annette Bosworth's   campaign indicates that Bosworth and Haber basically view their Facebook friends and every other human as a means to financial gain not as an end unto himself or herself.

South Dakotans are, therefore, witnessing injustice and a violation of the categorical imperative.  Hence, one should question what moral duty one has to confront the injustice. One also has to question what one can do. Bosworth and Haber may have lost the necessary sense of shame that will allow them to change.

On a personal level I have a another quandary.  Do I tell the young'uns about this candidacy tomorrow and how it fits the resolution or do I say nothing because giving them the facts of Haber's candidacy will confirm their belief that politics is a circus and government is a joke?

Perhaps the best action one can perform under the circumstances is to pray for this particular circus act to be retired to the political oblivion it so richly deserves.

(Experimenting with new phone app. I apologize for formatting and other errors. I will correct later.)

Sunday, July 6, 2014

Scripture And Song For The Week: Proverbs 1 Edition

Proverbs 1
NIV
20 Out in the open wisdom calls aloud,
    she raises her voice in the public square;
21 on top of the wall she cries out,
    at the city gate she makes her speech:
22 “How long will you who are simple love your simple ways?
    How long will mockers delight in mockery
    and fools hate knowledge?
23 Repent at my rebuke!
    Then I will pour out my thoughts to you,
    I will make known to you my teachings.
24 But since you refuse to listen when I call
    and no one pays attention when I stretch out my hand,
25 since you disregard all my advice
    and do not accept my rebuke,
26 I in turn will laugh when disaster strikes you;
    I will mock when calamity overtakes you—
27 when calamity overtakes you like a storm,
    when disaster sweeps over you like a whirlwind,
    when distress and trouble overwhelm you.
28 “Then they will call to me but I will not answer;
    they will look for me but will not find me,
29 since they hated knowledge
    and did not choose to fear the Lord.
30 Since they would not accept my advice
    and spurned my rebuke,
31 they will eat the fruit of their ways
    and be filled with the fruit of their schemes.
32 For the waywardness of the simple will kill them,
    and the complacency of fools will destroy them;
33 but whoever listens to me will live in safety
    and be at ease, without fear of harm.”

Saturday, July 5, 2014

A Response To Senator Tim Begalka's Rant

Over at Dakota War College, state senator Tim Begalka went off on a rant. According to Begalka, being a "humanist and a feminist" equates to a belief that "one is all knowing and important, and God isn't." According to the senator, announcing one's belief in humanism means one is "mocking God." Humanists, he contends, condone " lying, cheating, and cover-ups" They also support a foreign policy that "coddles [and] empowers" Muslim terrorists "all the while ignoring and suppressing the torture, murder, and discrimination of Bible-believing Christians around the world." Begalka concludes with scripture: “Woe to those who call good evil and evil good.”

I don't want to put words in Begalka's mouth, a courtesy he did not extend to Democratic Secretary of State candidate Angelia Schultz whom Begalka blithely derides without a shred of evidence. The senator should, therefore, feel free to stop by and correct me in the comments.

Begalka strongly implies that faith in God is prerequisite to morality and effective public service. That view seems odd; James 2:19 states, "Thou believest that there is one God; thou doest well: the devils also believe, and tremble." One hopes that Senator Begalka would not vote for a Republican trembling demon over a human Independent atheist. (I'm trying to be kind and not force him to consider voting for a Democrat. Promoting such extreme cognitive dissonance might be dangerous.)

Begalka's list of grievances implies that he would consider himself a Constitutional conservative. If so, one wonders how he squares the view that only believers should hold office with the Constitution. Article VI, paragraph 3 states,
The Senators and Representatives before mentioned, and the Members of the several State Legislatures, and all executive and judicial Officers, both of the United States and of the several States, shall be bound by Oath or Affirmation, to support this Constitution; but no religious test shall ever be required as a qualification to any office or public trust under the United States. [Emphasis mine.]
Scholar Stephen Prothero considers Atheism one the world's eight great religions, so banning atheists from holding elected office seems to violate the religious test clause.  Even if one discounts scholars like Prothero, Begalka is on shaky ground advocating support for only believers in God as office holders. One can be a Buddhist and not believe in any deity. A guy on a bar stool can scream that he wants no atheists in government. He has a First Amendment right to do so. An elected official ought to have more discernment as he undertakes the effort to support the Constitution. It would not be a large stretch in logic to claim Begalka supports a religious test. At the very least, one has more grounds for inferring such support from Begalka's words than he has for implying that Angelina Schultz actively mocks God and supports the murdering Christians based on the word "humanist."

Like Begalka I oppose torturing Christians. I oppose torturing anyone. Let's hope that nothing which can remotely be considered torture is going on at Guantanamo Bay and  that the United States is not rendering prisoners to governments who have no qualms about torture. That said, it's confusing why Begalka thought to include the subject in his rant. it's unclear what the South Dakota Secretary of State has to do with foreign policy about torture. The simplest answer would be that ranting rarely is conducive to logical thought.

Finally and most importantly, Angelia Schultz has never claimed to be an atheist nor has she said she supported impiety or atrocities committed against Christians abroad. Senator Begalka apparently believes he has the omniscience to know she possesses those beliefs.

Implying one is omniscient could be construed as asserting one is godlike. Were I Begalka, I would now go on a rant about hubris leading to destruction and the desire to be like God being the reason humans suffer and die. I'll forego that rant. Instead, I'll ask that everyone quit focusing on tweets and stop asserting candidates have beliefs that they likely don't hold. Again, Schultz said nothing about holding any of the beliefs or supporting any of the positions that Begalka accuses her of implicitly supporting

If everyone moves past minutia, the South Dakota Secretary of State race can be decided on the issues and the candidates' qualifications. An election held under those circumstances might qualify as a miracle and increase everyone's faith in God. At the very least, it will show that we're capable of treating our fellow humans with respect.

**Post originally read Angelina Schultz not Angelia Schultz. I apologize for the error

A Minor Musing About Education, Religion, Literature, Pat Powers, And Larry Kurtz

There's no way this post is going to make anyone happy.

This week, I started reading Cormac McCarthy's All the Pretty Horses and James K. A. Smith's How (Not) To Be Secular. This reading has caused abstract, unconnected ramblings about place and spirit to come to mind frequently. These abstractions may infect this post. I've also been reading a lot of blogs and spending a lot of time on Twitter. (Please pray for my wife's sanity because I sometimes tell her what I'm reading on the blogs and in the comments.) Now, let the metaphors and allusions begin.

A few education reforms ago, in a South Dakota education galaxy that seems far, far away, South Dakota teachers were sat down before computers, directed toward a website called Techpaths, and instructed to create curriculum maps. (To the best of my knowledge many, if not most, South Dakota districts abandoned Techpaths when the original funding disappeared.) Techpaths requires curriculum cartographers to develop essential questions as the initial step in map creation.

I rather enjoyed creating essential questions. The essential questions one creates determine how one approaches most situations, so they allow for a little introspection and guide how one constructs a unit or a full course. The asking of different essential questions also explains how different religions and philosophies can come up with radically opposed tenants. David Berge's succinct summation of Stephen Prothero's God is Not One helps make the point:
To investigate these eight religions, Prothero interrogates them with four questions: (1) what’s the problem? (2) what’s the solution? (3) how do we get from problem to solution? (4) who are some exemplars of this path?
Christians would answer these questions: (1) sin (2) salvation through Christ (3) faith and good works (4) the great saints of the church. A Buddhist would answer these questions: (1) suffering (2) nirvana (3) the Noble Eightfold Path (4) arhats, bodhisattavas, or lamas.
As this comparison makes clear, Christians and Buddhists aren't just different embodiments of the same human response to the “divine” as the Perennial Philosophers say, they are different diagnoses of the deepest problem of humanity and how it can be solved.
Blogs in the South Dakota blogosphere seems to be guided by essential questions as well. Reading Pat Powers tweets and his Dakota War College blog convince me that Powers believes that South Dakota is, or can become, a Republican Eden. His essential question seems to be "How can I keep the non-Republican serpents out this South Dakota garden paradise?" By asking how he can keep the serpent from infecting this place, he has taken on himself to do what the Almighty could not, always a risky endeavor.

Powers is diligent and not an ineffective gardener. Humans, however, are notoriously poor at maintaining, let alone creating, a paradise; we are much better at creating parking lots. Powers, therefore, serves up lots of what he claims to be apple pie made from trees in his paradise. He has numerous taste testers who proclaim it the best pie they've ever eaten. Some skeptics claim that the offerings remind them of mock apple pie composed primarily from Ritz crackers. Still, voter registration numbers indicate that South Dakotans are not being tempted by fruit Republicans hope to keep forbidden or at least difficult to obtain.

If I read Larry Kurtz's tweets and his interested party blog correctly, he sees South Dakota and his purpose far differently. With due apologies to Flannery O'Connor, Kurtz is asking "How can I reclaim 'territory largely held by the devil?'" O'Connor chose to shock: in her stories, the Misfit kills the family including the garrulous grandmother; the fraudulent Bible salesman steals the nihilistic philosopher's leg and leaves her stranded in the hay loft, and a bull gores Mrs. Greenleaf. It should be noted that O'Connor, who died in 1964, lived in a more genteel age.

Like O'Connor and the best contemporary performance artists of our decidedly more aggressive era, Kurtz has chosen to shock rather than sympathize, cudgel rather than comfort. Audience members may not like the performances, but when one has chosen to fight  the devil, one is engaged in a street fight not a bout conducted under the Marquis of Queensberry rules.

Yesterday, PNR enjoined us to enjoy the holiday:
So celebrate the Fourth of July, the gift this nation has been to us and to the world.
We can fight again on the fifth.
As the arguments begin anew, it seemed worthwhile to discern  how and why some folks in South Dakota blogosphere fight the way they do. Herein endth today's metablogging

Friday, July 4, 2014

Dear Susan Wismer, Please Fix Your Campaign Logo

Ken Santema is South Dakota's foremost Libertarian blogger. He may well be South Dakota's only Libertarian blogger, but let's put that discussion off for another day. I get over to Santema's corner of the interwebs rather frequently and find him to be a thoughtful commentator about South Dakota politics. He's covered live debate events and has given good reviews to Angelia Schultz, so he's not a hyper-partisan.

Today, while I sat at home and fed my cats Cheetos, Santema showed himself to be a better American than I. He went to a parade, took some pictures, posted some commentary, and made a mistake. That mistake is not his fault; the blame lies with the Wismer campaign,

Ken took and posted the following picture.

Ken Santema Photo of South Dakota Dems in Brookings Independence Day Parade
Santema then made the following observation:
One thing I found quite odd is the lack of signage for gubernatorial candidate Susan Wismer. There were at least three for Lt Gov candidate Susan Blake, plus a few who had Susan Blake shirts on. But I didn’t see any sign of Wismer. Perhaps this was just an oversight… It just seemed very odd that the Lt Gov candidate would get support; and the Gov candidate wouldn’t even get a sign on a truck
The Susan for South Dakota signs are for the Wismer/Blake ticket. Apparently, someone decided that it's self-evident that the "Susan" on the sign refers to Susan Wismer not Susy Blake. If these signs are confusing a South Dakota voter who pays more attention to politics than 98% of the state's residents, the signs need to go.

When I teach basic speech, I tell the young'uns that communication occurs when a sender sends a message, and a receiver understands the message. If the message sent is that Susie Blake has support, but Susan Wismer doesn't;that's a problem the campaign should fix. I'd suggest that people start working to fix it tonight, but this post is going up late and most normal people will be watching fireworks. Monday will be soon enough.

Look, Adele, Cher, Madonna, and Kesha can all get away with using only their given name. Those names are also a lot less common than Susan. Further, the only one of those women to be part of duo was Cher. That duo was Sonny and Cher. The members' names were far easier to differentiate than Susan and Susy.

In addition to letting people know who's on the top of the ticket, a good South Dakota Democratic strategy might include not allowing Pat Powers to say "I told you so."

I know I'm coming off snarky. I'm sorry, but I want a two-party system in the state. I have never voted straight ticket, but I really would like it if a vote for a Democrat in a statewide race were not a wasted vote.

Because Mike Larson Didn't Really Like My Last Playlist . . .

I decided to do another one with a little punk, a little folk, a little country and the Boss.