Friday, June 13, 2014

What's The Difference Between A Politician And A Jerk?

Based on this Eric Schwitzgebel unified theory of jerkitude, probably not much.
I submit that the unifying core, the essence of jerkitude in the moral sense, is this: the jerk culpably fails to appreciate the perspectives of others around him, treating them as tools to be manipulated or idiots to be dealt with rather than as moral and epistemic peers. This failure has both an intellectual dimension and an emotional dimension, and it has these two dimensions on both sides of the relationship. The jerk himself is both intellectually and emotionally defective, and what he defectively fails to appreciate is both the intellectual and emotional perspectives of the people around him. He can’t appreciate how he might be wrong and others right about some matter of fact; and what other people want or value doesn’t register as of interest to him, except derivatively upon his own interests. The bumpkin ignorance captured in the earlier use of ‘jerk’ has changed into a type of moral ignorance.
Some related traits are already well-known in psychology and philosophy – the ‘dark triad’ of Machiavellianism, narcissism, and psychopathy, and James’s conception of the asshole, already mentioned. But my conception of the jerk differs from all of these. The asshole, James says, is someone who allows himself to enjoy special advantages out of an entrenched sense of entitlement. That is one important dimension of jerkitude, but not the whole story. The callous psychopath, though cousin to the jerk, has an impulsivity and love of risk-taking that need be no part of the jerk’s character. Neither does the jerk have to be as thoroughly self-involved as the narcissist or as self-consciously cynical as the Machiavellian, though narcissism and Machiavellianism are common enough jerkish attributes. My conception of the ‘jerk’ also has a conceptual unity that is, I think, both theoretically appealing in the abstract and fruitful in helping explain some of the peculiar features of this type of animal, as we will see.

A Minor Musing About The State Auditor's Race

Unless South Dakota's Democrats have developed a campaign strategy that copies the time travel strategy of Charles Xavier and Magneto from X-Men: Days of Future Past, incumbent governor Dennis Daugaard will easily defeat Democrat Susan Wismer and Republicans will easily maintain dominance of the South Dakota legislature.

Given that reality, Democrats should make taking the State Auditor's office a priority. The website for the current Republican Auditor asserts
The State Auditor serves as the taxpayers' watchdog. It is the State Auditor who scrutinizes the manner in which state tax dollars are being spent. Simply stated, the Office of State Auditor is constitutionally the office of "checks and balances" of state government.
Quite frankly, it should be an easy sell that the party that controls the executive branch and the legislature should not be allowed to monitor itself. The EB-5, or whatever one wishes to call it, debacle should be all the proof that one needs to see state funds have not always been used properly.

The candidate would have to craft the message carefully; conceding that many of the other Democrats running for state office are going to lose is not the best way to build confidence or insure that the party will have a complete slate of candidates during the next election.cycle. That said, most South Dakotans know that Republicans have dominated the state for recent decades. If a candidate runs as a reformer who will make every effort to ensure that a little sunlight will shine on the darker areas of state spending, that campaign should resonate with voters.

Last night, Pat Powers sneered at idea that Democrat Angelia Schultz would run for the State Auditor position. She may not be the right person for the job, but Democrats are on the right track by creating the impression that that they believe this office is a priority.

Weiland's Populist Rhetoric May Catch On

Rick Weiland may be on to something with his "I'm a populist" rhetoric. Democratic strategist Doug Sosnick senses that the country is ready for some populist leadership:
There is a pent up desire for dramatic change that has been shaped by a confluence of major events in the United States and around the world. In the last 10 years the country has fought two wars, faced the greatest worldwide economic meltdown since the 1930s and experienced the most significant technological transformation since the Industrial Revolution. The nation has also undergone a major demographic makeover, shifting from a majority white country to an increasingly multicultural society. Throughout this period our leaders have failed to manage the pace of all this change and to face up to the severity of our challenges, resulting in disillusionment and deep divisions among the public by race, age and income.
Writing at the National Journal, Ron Fournier sums up Sosnick's analysis and adds some concrete examples:
Populists from the right and the left—from the tea party and libertarian-leaning Rand Paul to economic populist Elizabeth Warren—are positioning themselves among the insurgents. Sosnik pointed to six areas of consensus that eventually may unite the divergent populist forces:
  • A pullback from the rest of the world, with more of an inward focus.
  • A desire to go after big banks and other large financial institutions.
  • Elimination of corporate welfare.
  • Reducing special deals for the rich.
  • Pushing back on the violation of the public's privacy by the government and big business.
  • Reducing the size of government.
Thinking about traditional Republicans going on tilt over a fusion ticket combining Rand Paul and Elizabeth Warren may make me smile for the rest of the summer. (The quotation doesn't mention a fusion ticket, but a blogger can dream.

The populist agenda that Sosnick and Fournier outline should make Weiland smile as well. Weiland can take that agenda for his own, but Rounds cannot, even if one counts eliminating the Department of Education as a serious effort to reduce the size of government.

Rounds, of course, will spend nearly all of time trying to tell voters that Weiland will increase the size of government and hope that they will not notice that the former governor will maintain the status quo on the the other five issues

The devil, as always, is in the details, but quite frankly, this would be a platform worth supporting. If Weiland can craft the details carefully, the race  may become much more competitive,

Thursday, June 12, 2014

Chart Of The Day: Americans View Members Of The Opposite Political Party As Threats to The Nation Edition

After reading the results of this Pew Research Center Poll, it would be fun to make a snarky comment about Democrats and Republicans just not being that into each other, but this split seems a bit too serious for snark.


Andrew Sullivan contends the nation is in a cold civil war. At times Sullivan tends toward hyperbole; however, if over a third of Republicans believe Democrats are a threat to the nation's well being while over a quarter of Democrats feel the same about Republicans, then one must question if the nation has now become a house divided against itself.

The Hardest Working Candidate In South Dakota Is Supposed To Quit?

This morning Bob Mercer, presumably fully dosed on coffee and Red Bull, suggests that Rick Weiland should drop out of the United States Senate race in order to give Larry Pressler and Gordon Howie a chance to defeat Mike Rounds. Predictably, Cory Heidelberger takes umbrage while Pat Powers chortles. Were Weiland to act on Mercer's suggestion, Rounds's over/under in the November election would move from 48.5% to 69.5%.

Mercer points out "[n]o candidate for statewide office worked harder than Rick Weiland did in the past year." Therein lies the proverbial rub. The Democrats have their hardest working candidate race that will be the most difficult to win. The party rejected its second hardest working candidate Joe Lowe in favor of Susan Wismer in the gubernatorial race. In the United States House race, Corinna Robinson has been the political equivalent of Susan Storm Richards, Marvel Comics Invisible Woman. So far the party has no announced candidates for the attorney general or secretary of state races.

In a state filled with people who pride themselves on their work ethic, it is ironic that a respected political commentator would seriously urge the hardest working candidate to withdraw. Those of us who want a functioning two-party within the state find it depressing that minority parties within the state have so few candidates willing to emulate Weiland's Sisyphean efforts.

Wednesday, June 11, 2014

Quotation Of The Day: Professor Schaff Shows Governor Daugaard Is Wrong Factually And Philosophically Edition

From Professor Schaff's latest Pierre Capitol Journal column:
It is worth noting that in the influential study Academically Adrift, Richard Arum and Josipa Roska show that humanities and social science majors learn the most in college.  According to LeBar, the  Educational Testing Service, which runs some of the best known standardized tests in the nation, has data showing, “liberal arts students score significantly higher than any other field in both the verbal and analytical writing sections of the GRE [the entrance exam for most graduate programs], and philosophy students outperform accounting students in the quantitative section.”
Also, as reported by Carolyn Gregoire, according to the Association of American Colleges and Universities “humanities and social science majors earn a similar amount as pre-professional majors do over a lifetime.” Gregoeire notes that David Rubenstein, co-founder of the Carlyle Group, recently said that “career-specific skills can often be learned on the job -- whereas critical thinking and problem-solving skills are invaluable benefits of a humanities education -- as demonstrated by the many Wall Street executives who studied humanities in college.”
So why do we consistently push our “best and brightest” into STEM subjects and focus financial resources in this direction?  One cannot deny the value of mathematics, for example, which concerns about half of what our brains do.  But an overemphasis on what are deemed more “practical” subjects has distracted us from cultivating the whole human person, and our economy may pay the price.
The whole column is worth reading.

Eric Cantor, Mosul, And The February 5, 1973 Issue Of Newsweek

Two events occurred yesterday that should keep the entire blogsophere and cable talking heads busy for a long time. First, Mosul, Iraq's second largest city, fell to insurgents. Second Eric Cantor, the Republican leader in the House of Representatives.was defeated in a Republican primary.

If I grudgingly give in to my cynical nature, the former event makes me glad we have eliminated cable from our household because I will not have to listen to Lindsey Graham and other neocons advocate unrealistic, bellicose responses. The latter event will give me further reason to believe that the Tea Party has an Ayn Rand fetish that borders on obscene. If, after reading these compiled analyses and this comment section about another subject of controversy, I give my cynicism free rein, I might conclude that some on the far right will accept that humans cause global warming if those humans happen to be undocumented aliens living within the United States.

Today, however, I will hold on to the few remaining better angels in my nature and muse that that yesterday's big stories may cause us to miss something equally important. For evidence, I offer the February 5, 1973 issue of Newsweek.


As the cover would indicate, the issue devotes 9 of its 92 pages to the Viet Nam War's end. Lyndon Johnson's death and funeral earn 8 pages. The Roe v Wade Supreme Court decision rates 2 pages of coverage. The combined Agnew/Nixon scandals receive about 1 1/2 pages. In one week, America saw the end of one battle in the cultural war, the beginning of a new one, and the end of the New Deal era while the 20th Century's largest political scandal simmered. It was not a slow news cycle.

Given those historic events, readers should be forgiven if they missed an italicized, funny sounding word on the last line of page 61, jihad. That concept,or a complete perversion of that concepts, and American reaction to it have dominated American foreign policy, cost untold losses of blood and treasure, and given rise to an Orwellian national security state.

Perhaps yesterday's events aren't hiding a word or event that will dominate public discourse decades from now, but the February 5, 1973 issue of Newsweek ought to serve as reminders that historic events often hide the seeds of events that dominate the next generation's political and cultural zeitgeist.