Thursday, June 5, 2014

A Minor Musing: Breaking The South Dakota Conservative Coalition Down To Its Constituent Parts

Since I have a little extra time and want to avoid sorting the pile of books and kipple surrounding my personal area, aka "the nest," I thought I'd engage in a fool's errand and analyze the types of conservatives populating the South Dakota's blogosphere and political offices. I'm creating some of my own titles, and, as with any such grouping, I'm painting with a broad brush.

I will try to be more nuanced than those conservatives who have destroyed the word "liberal" by applying it to anyone whose political stance was metaphorically 1/16 of an inch to left of their own. I also will not apply Ronald Reagan, Tea Party, or social conservative as titles to any of these categories. All are too malleable to be used to explain differences.

First, Ken Santema, writing at Sodak Liberty, represents a strain of conservatism rather rare to South Dakota, a libertarian of the late Goldwater vein. It is the traditional libertarian view; leave adults alone so long as they don't do physical harm to others or defraud others. Were I to venture a guess, it's a relatively small group in the South Dakota conservative coalition.

Second, the neo-Randians are a group that has done the impossible; they have further perverted Ayn Rand's already perverse philosophy. Rand believed that business equaled wealth equaled morality, but to her credit, she wanted government away from business. The neo-Randians see government as a tool to aid and assist those with wealth at the expense of everyone else. It is South Dakota's dominant strain of conservatism efficiently practiced by Governors Rounds and Daugaard.

Third, there are a few iconoclasts with South Dakota's conservative community; chief among them Representative Rev. Steve Hickey who toes a social conservative line on most hot button social issues like abortion and gay marriage but strays from orthodoxy on the death penalty and usury laws, the latter stance causing the neo-Randians considerable consternation.

Fourth, Gordon Howie and Bob Ellis call themselves Christian conservatives, but much of their writing, especially Ellis's work, puts indicates they should be called angry populists. In the 19th Century, they would have helped form the Know Nothing coalition. Steve Sibson is a little more paranoid than angry but he fits here as well.

Fifth, is the neo-Birchers, William F. Buckley and Russel Kirk relegated the original Birch group to the fringes, but frequent DWC commenter, Jammer, seems to want to bring them back:
Members of the John Birch Society are some of the strongest defenders on the US Constitution in this country. They are also solid conservatives on almost every issue. I would challenge anyone who calls themselves a Republican to review the positions of the John Birch Society and tell me how they deviate from what you believe are Republican principles. I think you will be hard pressed to find very many areas that are not in agreement with the party platform.
Sixth, while dealing with the prefix "neo," one should mention Kristi Noem who seems to have a strong neo-con streak that involves supporting a government that is small enough to go to war with every other nation on the face of the Earth and spy on every American citizen. Perpetual war and supervision, according to neo-cons, are necessary to keep Americans safe,

Seventh, there are confused conservatives. I do not mean the adjective pejoratively These are good folks who enjoy small towns, church on Sunday morning, and hunting and fishing, facts that mean they are probably smart enough not to read blogs. They are Republicans by blood and tradition. They feel their world is slowly slipping away and don't know why, so they cast about between the various conservative  camps, always hearing answers that utter the old verities but never quite fit the new conditions, This is probably the largest group of South Dakota conservatives,and the ones who have been most ill-served by the neo-Randians and the neo-cons.

Finally, I invoked William F. Buckley earlier, I don't see too many South Dakota conservatives in the Buckley tradition. The closest seems to be PNR whose recent post about Stace Nelson prompted the train of thought that led to this musing. PNR reads and quotes the National Review rather than Rush Limbaugh, Sean Hannity, or Glenn Beck. The former publication has the benefit of complete sentences and attempts mature thought; the latter three do not.

One final caveat, this list is in no particular order and will, as most lists of this kind do, reveal more about my biases than the ideas being categorized.

Wednesday, June 4, 2014

Turns Out Annette Bosworth Was Right: The Media Do Hate Women Of Substance

They like to spend time covering women who get arrested instead.

Any reading of this blog will show that I am not Susan Wismer's biggest fan. I remain unconvinced that she's the right woman to take on Dennis Daugaard, an incumbent who is surrounded by South Dakota's largest coterie of Mayberry Machiavellis.

That said, she will be the first woman to appear on the ballot for governor in the South Dakota history. South Dakota will be celebrating its quasquicentennial two days before the November 4, 2014, so we should spend some time thinking about why it took that long for a woman to be nominated for the state's top office. Heck, people in a  civilized region might even take a week off from political discussion to let her enjoy the moment. Lewis Carroll even gave us a list of things to write about:
 The time has come,' the Walrus said,
      To talk of many things:
Of shoes — and ships — and sealing-wax —
      Of cabbages — and kings —
And why the sea is boiling hot —
      And whether pigs have wings.'
Instead, more time will be spent discussing a woman who held lotteries for which no prizes were awarded, refused to pay employees, and who was today arrested for perjury. To mark the occasion, she apparently hired a photographer to follow her through the booking process, wore pearls to accentuate an outfit with a decolletage that, while revealing, was not immodest, and flashed a confident smile as she exited to courthouse.

Dr. Annette Bosworth was correct. the media may not know how to cover women of accomplishment, and if I were Susan Wismer, I'd be pretty upset at any coverage of a narcissist at my expense.

10 Questions About The November Election

Yesterday's primaries confirmed each party's nominees for governor and United States Senate but created a few new questions. Here are mine

1. Will Democratic nominee Susan Wismer actually campaign? The better question may be can she actually campaign? Primaries should have a natural side-effect of creating a campaign message, energizing volunteers, and developing a get out the vote organization. Getting 55% of the 11% of Democrats and Independents who voted is hardly evidence that she or her people have done any of those things.

2. Will Gordon Howie keep Stace Nelson's 17% and can he get some of the Larry Rhoden's West River support in November? If so, the U.S. Senate race just got much more exciting.

3.Do campaigns matter? Lowe ran a far more effective public campaign that Wismer. Nelson seemed to have a better grassroots effort than Rhoden. (The latter impression is based only on East River travel and conversation.) Neither of the campaigns produced a victory, actual or perceived. Nelson's third place finish has to be seen as a loss.

4. Do enough people remember Larry Pressler to make him a factor in the U.S. Senate race?

5. Will Mike Myers stop doing push ups and develop a campaign message that gets him into double digits?

6. Can Susan Wismer take and deliver a punch? She seems to be a competent businesswoman and a good parent. (Her daughter is very polite to me on Twitter.) Those qualities, however, do not win elections. Lowe's attacks were issue based and relatively mild, so she really hasn't been tested. Further, she never responded, so it's unclear that she can hit back.

7. Rounds, Daugaard, and Noem either have enough cash or have sources that can flood their campaigns with cash; will any of their Democratic or Independent candidates be able to raise enough money to keep one of the races competitive?

8. Will the Democrats pick up seats in the legislature?

9. Can the Democrats win at least one of the statewide elections?

10. In the answer to both questions 7 and 8 is no, will the Democrats do anything to change or will they continue to cede power to Republicans and Tea Partiers?

I've left off the obvious question about Susan Wismer's running mate. Suffice it to say, it will not be any of the Democratic party's leading lights: Brendan Johnson, Stephanie Herseth-Sandlin, or Bernie Hunhoff. Also, it won't be a unity ticket with Joe Lowe.

Monday, June 2, 2014

A Preview Of Mike Rounds's Fall Campaign: Jumping The Gun Part Deux

Unless tons of fecal matter hit thousands of large spinning blades in a manner unique to human history, June 4 will dawn with Mike Rounds as the Republican nominee for the South Dakota Senate seat currently held by Tim Johnson. He will then begin his campaign against Democrat Rick Weiland and Independents Larry Pressler and Gordon Howie.

On Wednesday, Rounds will begin using the following talking points.
1. Rick Weiland is a liberal.
2. I agree with Mr. Howie that Obamacare is the worst legislation to see the light of day in my lifetime; some of Gordon's positions, however, are so far out of the mainstream that they do not reflect the values of hard working South Dakotans.
3. Larry Pressler has forgotten his South Dakota roots.
4. Rick Weiland's take it back slogan is clear evidence that Weiland is waging class warfare against South Dakota's job creators.
5. Larry Pressler will lead us to a return of failed policies of the past at a time when it imperative that this country move forward to face the 21st Century's new challenges.
6. Rick Weiland is waging war on the Second Amendment, traditional South Dakota values, and Christmas.
7, While I was working hard to create jobs in South Dakota, Rick Weiland headed an organization that killed jobs by creating onerous regulations.
8. By leaving the Republican party, both Larry Pressler and Gordon Howie have shown that they will put their ambition above principle.
9, John Thune likes me better than he likes the other candidates. He needs me there to help him put South Dakota first. My opponents will work on an agenda that Senator Thune and I know will hurt South Dakota.
10. A vote for Rick Weiland is a vote for Obamacare, activist judges, and a big government that will break the backs of our children with unsustainable debt.
Bonus Talking Point: Whenever one of his opponents uses a word that begins with the letter "E," Rounds will say something like, "My opponent is attempting to score political points by bringing up the EB-5 program which has been used in nearly every state and which, in South Dakota, has been carefully investigated. I call on my opponents to stop their negative campaigning and focus on the issues. I have been trying to run a positive campaign but my opponents insist on turning this into one of the most negative election cycles in South Dakota history.
I hope no one was expecting the fall campaign to be about policy proposals and concrete issues. Buzzwords are so much easier.

An Unreleased Annette Bosworth Ad (Sort Of)

I've been feeling a little left out of the Annette Bosworth video frenzy. Over at DWC, Pat Powers is putting them up, seemingly seconds after Bosworth posts them. Over at Madville, Cory and Toby have transcribed her videos to help voters understand her intricate policy positions, but I have done little to help South Dakotans comprehend the Bosworth video oeuvre.

I, therefore, felt fortunate that a mindless web search for Bosworth videos turned up this gem that may or may not run on election day.

Sunday, June 1, 2014

Quotation Of The Day: JRR Tolkien As Prophet Edition

Rod Dreher posts this paragraph from a letter Tolkien wrote in 1930:
“[Family life must have been different] in the days when a family had fed on the produce of the same few miles of country for six generations, and that perhaps was why they saw nymphs in the fountains and dryads in the wood – they were not mistaken for there was in a sense real (not metaphorical) connections between them and the countryside. What had been earth and air and later corn, and later still bread, really was in them. We of course who live on a standardized international diet…are artificial beings and have no connection (save in sentiment) with any place on earth. We are synthetic men, uprooted. The strength of the hills is not ours.”

Scripture And Song For The Week: Luke 9 Edition

NIV
57 As they were walking along the road, a man said to him, “I will follow you wherever you go.”
58 Jesus replied, “Foxes have dens and birds have nests, but the Son of Man has no place to lay his head.”
59 He said to another man, “Follow me.”
But he replied, “Lord, first let me go and bury my father.”
60 Jesus said to him, “Let the dead bury their own dead, but you go and proclaim the kingdom of God.”
61 Still another said, “I will follow you, Lord; but first let me go back and say goodbye to my family.”
62 Jesus replied, “No one who puts a hand to the plow and looks back is fit for service in the kingdom of God.”