Tuesday, May 20, 2014

About That New Mike Rounds Ad

Rounds may have produced the most boring ad for this cycle.

I guess Mike is a leader. He's got vision too. A young woman, a senior citizen, and mature gentleman told me so. Mike smiles a friendly insurance salesman smile too. The video has him smiling that smile as he tells the audience that he approved this message.

The ad doesn't tell me where Rounds is going to lead South Dakota or the nation. No one explains what his vision is. More importantly, it doesn't give viewers a single reason to trust him. Watching well-coached people tell me to trust someone is usually a cue to distrust the candidate.

On the plus side, speech teachers have a good example of the glittering generalities propaganda technique. Absent context words like "leader" and "vision" are meaningless.

It also allows one to point out visual cues like the Voices of Freedom book box prominently displayed in the center of the frame at about 5 seconds in. I'm guessing it's this book, an oral history of the Civil Rights movement.Of course that bit of product placement might backfire. There's probably a conservative commentator somewhere who has claimed the book is full of liberal lies. Using that book box as a prop may cause some to confirm their belief Rounds is a RINO.

Either way, the ad is short, so students probably won't fall asleep.

Monday, May 19, 2014

Quotation Of The Day: Goal Of A Liberal Arts Education Edition

From this Michael S. Roth piece in the New York Times:
Liberal learning depends on absorption in compelling work. It is a way to open ourselves to the various forms of life in which we might actively participate. When we learn to read or look or listen intensively, we are, at least temporarily, overcoming our own blindness by trying to understand an experience from another’s point of view. We are not just developing techniques of problem solving; we are learning to activate potential, and often to instigate new possibilities.

Friday, May 16, 2014

An Open Letter With Some Debate Advice For 2014 U.S. Senate Candidates Not Named Rounds

Dear Dr. Bosworth and Messrs. Nelson, Ravnsborg, and Rhoden,

Let me begin with a side note, I really hate the let's-line-up-every-candidate-on-the-stage-and-have-a-reporter-ask-audience-submitted-questions format. It's not really a debate.

On to the matter at hand, allow me to state the obvious; you really are not going to beat Mike Rounds in June if you don't engage him in the debates and chip away at that smiling facade.

First, even last night's event had debate expectations. In debate, there's an element called clash. It means that all sides are discussing and hopefully disagreeing about the same topics at the same time in the discussion. Clash can't happen if you agree with the opponent or repeat his "common sense" talking point nearly as often as he uses it. (Mr. Rhoden, that last sentence applies to you.)

In last night's line-up that was called a debate, you were all given rebuttal time.  A rebuttal should involve not only "I'm correct": it should involve a strong "You're wrong and here's why" component. Most of you did well on the state budget issue, but too many of the rebuttals were speeches that repeated your talking points. You need to tell viewers why Rounds or your other opponents are wrong.

Second, you can't claim you want the debate to be about issues not personalities if you spend most of the time restating your bio or some sort of life experience. Granted, some experiences may be relevant. For example. Mr. Rhoden, you can use your experience as rancher to deal with the farm bill question. Dr. Bosworth, I'm not sure the Republican electorate is going to respond favorably to your experiences with food stamps. Mr. Nelson, you should be honored for your career in the Marine Corps, but that experience cannot be the answer for nearly every question you're asked. By the way, Dr. Bosworth, if you're going to offer an analogy, it should be analogous to the topic being discussed.

Third, none of you seemed to have anticipated any of these questions. I'll grant the climate change question was an odd choice to lead off the debate, but many of the rest seemed rather standard. Further, you didn't seem to anticipate what your opponents were going to say. Heck, I had people on Twitter telling me that Mr. Ravnsborg was going to bring up CARE before he mentioned it. By now, you should all know Rounds is going to use the line "South Dakota Common Sense," you aren't' going to beat him repeating the line. You're going to have to show he doesn't have common sense, South Dakota or otherwise.

Remember preparation and clash are the only way you're going become the 2014 Republican nominee. Rounds has an overwhelming lead. If you can't force Rounds into making an error, he's not making one.

Thursday, May 15, 2014

Republican Senate Debate: One Sentence Takes

Annette Bosworth wants to be an epic hero, but she doesn't know that epic heroes all have tragic flaws that cause spectacular downfalls.

Stace Nelson needs to upgrade his I'm a Marine and a good ol' country boy shtick.

Someone needs to tell Larry Rhoden that The Invisible Man is a good novel but being the invisible candidate means you've lost.

Rounds looked tired but did the political rope-a-dope fairly well; no one had a performance that will allow him or her to gain ground..

Jason Ravnsborg fired the best shot of the night when he used the line "skeletons and scandals," but he just doesn't seem ready for prime time.

Quotations Of The Day: College Commencement And Free Speech Edition

Last week, I had wanted to write a post about Condoleezza Rice's withdrawing as the commencement speaker at Rutgers. I opposed the Iraq War from the onset, but the idea that an accomplished woman who supported the war would have nothing valuable to say struck me as foolish stubbornness that college graduates should have tempered after four years. I guess I was stuck in 1979.

Via this Andrew Sullivan post, one sees that getting commencement speakers to withdraw is all the rage., so I will let a few other folk make my point. Greg Lukianoff provides alarming analysis about the depth of the problem:
Students and faculty have the right to protest speakers and to criticize their colleges for choosing speakers they dislike. Yet to function as a true “marketplace of ideas,” the university community must be open to hearing from people from different walks of life, professions, experiences and philosophical and political points of view. When students (or faculty, who should definitely know better) work to exclude a speaker from campus, they are thinking like censors, not scholars. A scholarly community should approach speakers with even radically different points of view as opportunities to be engaged, not as a political loss that must be avoided at all costs. Exercising a little intellectual humility might lead students and faculty away from asking “what can I do to get rid of the speaker?” and towards “what might I learn if I hear this person out?” After all, if you’re only willing to hear from people with whom you agree, it’s far less likely you will learn new things.
Universities have only themselves to blame for this mess—not just for caving to pressure, but for teaching students the wrong lessons about the value of free and robust discourse. The Foundation for Individual Rights inEducation (FIRE), of which I am the president, has found speech codes—policies that heavily restrict speech that is protected under the First Amendment—at 59%of the more than 400 colleges we survey, and deals every day with campus censorship of often even mildly offensive speech. Colleges have taught a generation of students that they have a “right not to be offended.” This belief has inevitably morphed into an expectation among students that they will be confirmed in their beliefs, not challenged. It’s no wonder, then, that they apply increasingly strict purity tests to potential campus speakers.[emphasis mine]
The best phrasing comes from Olivia Nuzzi:
Millennials have grown up in a world where you are never forced to see, hear or read anything that you haven’t personally selected. 7,000 TV channels, a DVR to skip commercials, millions of websites—we have been able to curate our own little worlds using technology, wherein nothing unpleasant or offensive can creep in. So when we’re forced to sit through a commercial or, heaven forbid, listen to someone talk who isn’t Mary-freakin’-Poppins, we can’t handle it.
The entire point of college is to be exposed to different things: Different types of people, different ideas—and maybe some of those people will hail from organizations that negatively impacted poor countries, or maybe they were partly responsible for a war that ate up the country’s resources and resulted in human rights abuses and lots of needless death. But if, at the end of your time as an undergrad, you haven’t learned that oftentimes you find great wisdom in shitty people, or just that there might be some value in hearing what someone you don’t like or respect might have to say, what on earth have you learned?[emphasis mine]
Read the Sullivan post and the articles he links to.

Wednesday, May 14, 2014

YouTube Video Of The Day: Net Neutrality Explained In Three Minutes Edition

Is Susan Wismer Actually Seeking The Democratic Nomination For Governor?

I ask because I see no campaign presence anywhere and the election is less than a month away.

Granted, our household got rid of cable and are viewing only Netflix and Hulu Plus on the television, so I won't see any ads there. However, I would expect to see ads on YouTube,  but when I do a YouTube search, I see no Wismer campaign videos. I see several for Joe Lowe.

I don't read the hard copy of the local paper every day, but I have seen no ads when I do. I've driven from home to Mitchell and Sioux Falls within the past two weeks and haven't seen a road sign. The job isn't conducive to listening to the radio, so if a reader can reliably inform me of a large radio presence, I'll take that as evidence of campaigning.

During the weekend, I checked her website on my phone. Let's just say that a Scott Heidepriem endorsement should not be both the top news story and the featured element on the home page tab.

I had planned to register Republican to vote in the U.S. Senate primary and cast the most disruptive vote possible. Unfortunately, that vote would have had to go to Bosworth, but I have a conscience that I don't want troubling me for the next 20 years. Voting for Bosworth would have had that effect, not to mention the eternal damage that vote would have done to my soul.

In retrospect, I'm glad I didn't switch registration. As an independent I can vote in the Democratic primary and cast a vote for Lowe. I don't know that much about him, but at least he has something of a campaign presence. If I want a two party system in the state, having an opposition party candidate who will campaign is better than having an opposition candidate who won't.

If Wismer believes this race is about the Democratic establishment, such as it exists in South Dakota, showing that they will bring out the vote for one of their own, then Governor Daugaard may top 75% in the general election if she is the nominee. That result will not help develop a functioning two-party system within the state.