Tuesday, May 13, 2014

Quotation Of The Day: Being An Anti-Republican Edition

With the exception of voting for Obama in 2012, these Damon Linker paragraphs sum up my current political philosophy and activity:
Today, my voting record says I'm a Democrat. I voted for Kerry in 2004 and Obama in 2008 and 2012. I nearly always support Democrats in House, Senate, and gubernatorial elections. But I don't identify closely with or feel deep loyalty to the Democratic Party, its agenda, or its electoral coalition.
You could say that I'm less a Democrat than an anti-Republican. I vote the way I do because I want the GOP to lose, lose badly, and keep losing until it comes to its collective senses, which at this point seems a very long way off indeed.

A Minor Musing About Government

PNR waxes philosophic while analyzing the Stace Nelson candidacy:
I think we in this country have, for the most part, made a god out of the government as if they can solve every problem - all they need is the right bureaucracy, the right law, the right regulation, the right court decision, and everything will be good and right and true.  This idolatry of the state goes back to the kings and potentates of the ancient near east at least, and their claims of divinity.  It changed only slightly in the middle ages of Europe with its notions of divine right.  And it blossomed into the modern era in the French Revolution which, quite literally, did seek to make a religion out of the state in direct opposition to the church.  Most of what ails us in this country springs from this idolatry.
Certainly a large number of America's self-professed Christians have not taken to heart Psalm 20:7
Some trust in chariots and some in horses, but we trust in the name of the LORD our God.
I hold little hope that government will solve most or any of our problems. I do not, however, see the worship of government to be a deeper root cause of the problems facing the nation than the worship of any other false god.

The nation can no longer seriously debate about whether it is a republic or a democracy. (Whether that debate was ever necessary is a question for a different post.) The current political divisions are not about the size of or the nature of a good government. Rather, these debates seem to be about which plutocratic element gets the lion's share of the spoils. If there were no government, I'm quite certain the plutocrats would discover ways to preserve their ability to protect their frequently inherited wealth and ensure that fruits of others' labor flow to the plutocrats' coffers.

For every Tower of Babel, there is a Golden Calf (my choice for the chief god in the pantheon of ills) and an image of Baal. Further, we humans each have our share of foibles, hubris chief among them. It may or may not take a village to raise a child, but it certainly takes a pantheon of false gods to explain the problems facing the county.

Quite frankly, the current situation shows Madison's observations in Federalist 51 correct:
But what is government itself, but the greatest of all reflections on human nature? If men were angels, no government would be necessary. If angels were to govern men, neither external nor internal controls on government would be necessary. In framing a government which is to be administered by men over men, the great difficulty lies in this: you must first enable the government to control the governed; and in the next place oblige it to control itself. A dependence on the people is, no doubt, the primary control on the government; but experience has taught mankind the necessity of auxiliary precautions.
Shakespeare has Cassius tell Brutus that the fault lies not in our stars but in ourselves The largest fault might lie in the fact that we've run out of ideas for auxiliary precautions.

Monday, May 12, 2014

A Belated Musing On Ravnsborg And Relevancy

I was a little busy last week. A young plainswoman was graduating from college, sort of. (She's got one class left to take this summer.) Mrs. Plainsman and I spent last week rushing about, so we could pretend to be ready to face finals week before driving off to see her walk through the graduation line bedecked in all sorts of academic and non-academic cordage and regalia. (There's something about spending 18 hours in a car that's not conducive to getting real work done, hence last week's rush.)

I wanted to weigh in a bit on the kerfuffle surrounding Republican Senate candidate Jason Ravnsborg claiming to be the "ONLY U.S. Senate candidate with relevant military experience." I am in no position to weigh in on whether candidates' military experience qualifies them for the United States Senate. (PNR has a take here.) I do want to mention what the ad reveals about the candidate

It strikes me that the most "relevant" job a United States senator has is protecting his constituents' lives and liberties. To the best of my knowledge performing those duties entails crafting well-written legislation to serve constituents, repealing harmful legislation, and preventing the enactment of legislation detrimental to the senator's constituents. The U.S. Senate also has "advise and consent" power. (I know that in the political world the vast majority of a senator's job involves glad handing rich folk to raise money to get re-elected, but I so rarely get to wax romantically about politics that I'll ignore that detail for this post.)

The vast majority of a senator's job seems to involve parsing language. If Ravnsborg didn't anticipate that other veterans would take umbrage at his claim to be the "ONLY U.S. Senate candidate with relevant military experience," then one has to doubt that he's up to the job. "Only" is rather strong, limiting word. Further, the idea that something is relevant carries the connotation that other things, other candidates' military service in this case, are irrelevant. One does need to be a linguist to anticipate that others will take offense at the claim that their military endeavors were "irrelevant."

It's more likely that he did know the effect that his word choice would have. He either didn't care or wanted to stir up the race. In that case, he's just another pharisaical candidate who follows the letter of Reagan's 11th commandment not to speak ill of another Republican but uses language carefully to skirt the intent. If that's the case, then he'll soon be spending all of his time glad handing rich folk to raise funds to get elected and I can go back to being cynical.

Monday, May 5, 2014

Chart Of Day: American Equivalent Of Bread And Circuses Edition

Via an Andrew Sullivan post aptly titled "You Can't Feed Your Family With A New TV"


Life's good for those who don't need to go to college, never get sick,
don't need to repair the used vehicle they bought, and never eat



Thursday, May 1, 2014

A Minor Musing About The Republican Challenge To Gordon Howie's Nominating Petitions

The only persons who root for Goliaths in the giants' conflicts with the assorted Davids are, unsurprisingly, the Goliaths.

That small fact explains why no one should be shocked that Minnehaha County Republicans or a "volunteer group" of that county's Republicans are undertaking an effort to disqualify Gordon Howie's petitions to run as an Independent for the United States Senate

State Republican Party chairperson, Craig Lawrence, claims to be worried that Howie's candidacy will give Rick Weiland an upset victory in November. From a Dakota War College post:
I [Lawrence] suggested that if he were to get 12% of the vote as he has in the past, he could be the spoiler who gives the seat back to the Democrats. He said, “I expect to get much more than 12%.”
Pat Powers concludes his post with one of those lovely either/or logical fallacies beloved of parents punishing a wayward child.
Gordon probably should figure out what party his loyalties run with. Republicans? Or the Democrats he will be aiding.
Powers is echoing the tone of Minnehaha County Republican chairperson Dave Roetman who claims,
"We're trying to make sure we heal the wounds within the party. If people are disaffected, we like to bring them back around." 
When I was a wayward child, my father undertook efforts "to bring [me] back around." To this day, I would not classify those endeavors as healing events.

The Rounds campaign claims to be polling at 61% in the Republican primary. Conservatively, that puts the Rounds over/under bet at 59.5% in the general election. Even if Howie pulls 15%, a possibility as likely as earthquake occurring every time someone reads this post, and all his votes come at the expense of Mike Rounds, the former governor will defeat Rick Weiland 44% to 41%. Even with Howie in the race, Rounds will top 50% unless his contract with Teflon expires.

I've never met Gordon Howie; I'm not going to vote for Gordon Howie if he makes the ballot. I doubt he's a friend of the blog, and my reading of his blog makes me believe that his major goal in life is to sell an unsuspecting soul a lifetime supply of snake oil.

That said, one party rule is unhealthy. South Dakota needs more candidates not fewer. If the state can't develop two major parties, then several  minor ones along with a gargantuan one will have to suffice.

The David and Goliath story resonates because it illustrates a wish that rarely is fulfilled. Some may believe the Republican effort to keep Howie off the ballot is redolent of the fear giants have of a sling and five small, smooth stones. It's not. It's just another boring example of a South Dakota political Goliath attempting to crush a David merely because he can.

Quotation Of The Day: Net Neutrality With Very Brief Comment Edition

From this IO9.com post:
[Eliminating net neutrality] is the first step toward a world where corporate monopolies on content start affecting not just what you can see and read online — but also how you gain access to it. The signal will be out there, but your ISP just won't deliver it to you.
An internet without network neutrality will look a lot like television does now. You'll depend entirely on your cable company to get broadcasts, and they will only deliver their handpicked channels in their cable packages. There will probably be a little room for the web equivalent of public access television, but it will be so underfunded and slow to load that almost nobody will see it.
The post is in response to proposed F.C.C. rules changes. This decision is just one more item on the list of reasons that makes me glad I did not vote to re-elect President Obama. I really can't imagine a Mitt Romney administration being able to give away more to corporate America than the Obama administration has during the past two years.

I'm Having Trouble Figuring Out Who's The Real Republican

Is it South Dakota legislator Charlie Hoffman who writes words like the following?
People compared to animals? No that is not right.
The giving of help to people who are hurting and need help is honorable and necessary. Certainly different levels of need are “Out There”. We as a country of individuals who value a penal system of forgiveness; instead of torture and beheadings and religious extermination, find many ways to help the needy
.
Or Annette Bosworth who believes that humans and animals both lack reasoning ability and rely on only base instinct?

Perhaps it's Sarah Palin who conflates sacraments with water boarding. (Some may deny water boarding his torture, but forcing someone to  listen to her nasal twang likely violates the Geneva Convention.)



On the other hand, I could just be remembering Dana Carvey's "Church Lady."



I wonder who could confuse me like that?



It could be the Devil or it could be a political party that really doesn't know where its soul lies.