Sunday, June 3, 2012

A Fat Man Analyzes Bloomberg's Proposed Biggie Drink Ban

This Wall Street Journal graphic made me think about something that I didn't want to think about: New York City Mayor Bloomberg's proposed ban on large sodas.


First, I'd feel a lot better if the sentiment ran 65% jokes, 29% against it, and 7% for it.

Second, how many of the jokes included something like "Bloomberg can have my Big Gulp when he pries it from my cold, dead fingers"?

Third,  the circled text on the right indicates that Bloomberg is going to run for President.  Why else would he want the NRA off his back?

Fourth, the circled text on the left indicates that he will ask South Dakota Governor Dennis Daugaard to be his VP.  After all, someone who understands "the direction we need to go to save the health of our children" would want to run with someone who is the only lobbyist South Dakota students have.

Finally, I want to live in a place that has solved poverty, hunger, crime, and unemployment so it can focus on the terrifying problem of  sugar abuse.  I had no idea New York City was that place.



I Muse About The Diane Ravitch vs. Tom Peters Twitter Spat

Earlier today Diane Ravitch tweeted:
I'm not sure what Peters said to prompt that response, but I'll take this tweet as one that sums up his view:
It's Sunday morning, so let's be clear; even though Diane Ravitch is doing God's work fighting against the testing for testing's sake regime, she's not God and can error.  Peters too is a mere mortal, so for all of his calls for excellence and demanding a "Wow!," he has mediocre days.

I'm a fan of both people.  I became a Peters fan 1990s when I heard him give a talk on a local PBS station.  The talk elaborated on the following paragraphs:
Can you put fun, love, passion, anarchist and thrill in your official credo, for your 10-person accounting group, your newly opened record shop, or the $50 million division you run? If not, why not?
I can read a "corporate culture" in about five minutes. So can you. Whether the subject is (a) a new restaurant, (b) a corner grocery or (c) IBM, GM or GE, you can feel the vibes in a flash. They broadcast "dull" or "exciting" with the utmost clarity. If you're bored out of your wits in the reception area (after being ''badged,'' undoubtedly), you're going to be bored out of your wits with each and every subsequent encounter. Are there exceptions to the rule? Not many.
Kawasaki wants us to be raging, inexorable thunder-lizard evangelists. Roddick hunts for anarchists. Ben Cohen and Jerry Greenfield champion weird. And I want us to breathlessly pursue dramatic failures and flirt with firing. Funny thing, neither I nor Kawasaki nor Roddick nor Cohen nor Greenfield is even being a little bit facetious.
How about it?
Peters wrote the above paragraphs in 1992.  This morning, Larry Smith wrote,
Remember that passion is necessary for a great career, but it is not sufficient. There's no magic here. Success also demands persistence, focus, discipline, independence of mind, resourcefulness, experimentation and high creativity.
"Independence of mind," "resourcefulness," "experimentation," and "high creativity" sound like qualities that broadcast excitement, so the intervening two decades don't seem to have changed the qualities Peters claims lead to excellence.

If memory serves, NCLB  and subsequent policies sprang from the poorly phrased question: "Is our children learning?"  Students and the country might be better served by adapting one of Peters's pet phrases into a question:  "how can we produce raging inexorable thunder-lizard evangelists"?

NCLB, RTTT, and whatever Romney will propose have no chance of producing "raging inexorable thunder-lizard evangelists" or "anarchists."  The policies will produce "dull" students and teachers who never ask "is it weird enough?"  Instead, those polices will continue to force schools to emphasize the "common."

Saturday, June 2, 2012

Some Speaking Advice For Jeff Barth: Remember Godwin's Law and The Maltese Falcon

I have never been an Internet sensation, so I don't know what pressures, if any, Jeff Barth faces after his campaign video went viral, but when David Montgomery reports that Barth drops the Nazi allusion "final solution," I feel the need to offer a bit of advice.

According to Montgomery,
Talking about Noem, Barth said:
“I don’t know why she doesn’t answer any of those questions about her fictitious support for a balanced budget, or her final solution for people on Medicare.” [emphasis in original]
Every high school graduate should know that the phrase final solution carries connotations of the Holocaust.

I, therefore, offer the following advice.  First, remember Godwin's Law which contains the corollary that the person who refers to Nazi's first loses the debate.

Second, listen to Sydney Greenstreet in the first two minutes of this clip.  I know Bogart goes nuts at the end of this clip and makes the craziness work, but Jeff, you are no Bogart.



Finally, remember some of us are going to vote for the person we believe has the best judgement because we won't be able to agree with anyone on all of  his or her positions.  Further, we won't know what the big issues are going to be 15 months from now, so our guess about one's judgement is as important as agreement on positions.

Random Items I Like To Blog About: Sports, Pop Culture, Communication, Literature, & Comics

I may have to break my moratorium on buying sports jerseys for an International Quidditch Association player jersey.
This summer, the IQA plans to host a Quidditch Exposition in Oxford, with the best players from the United States, France, Australia, and the United Kingdom battling for the title of best faux wizards in the league. You can support your favorite team with these jerseys, available from $49.99. If you want it emblazoned with the name of a Hogwarts alum, it will set you back $74.99. Alternatively, for $64.99, you can get a jersey featuring the name and number of an actual exposition player, with the proceeds going to support that player.
Meanwhile, in the mart of competitive e-book commerce:
In one of the truly bizarre incidents we've seen out of the e-book publishing world, a translation of Leo Tolstoy's War and Peace for Barnes & Noble's Nook platform has replaced all mentions of the word "kindled" with "Nookd."
Somebody who has sat through to many bad presentations sums up the ordeal quite well.


Finally, because it's Saturday morning, a troubling but intriguing mash-up from Comics Alliance:


Friday, June 1, 2012

English Teacher To Do List Item 1: Develop A Plan To Overcome Reader Ennui

Writing at GeekDad, Jonathan Liu, a self described "stay-at-home dad, Etch-a-Sketch artist, community agitator, board game geek, and a voracious reader" tells all English teachers that their worst fears are true. Students don't want to read most of the literature we assign, and they don't believe our assertions about beauty, depth, and literary merit.
When I was in high school and our English teacher was always talking about “literary merit,” my friends and I decided that the two main indicators of literary merit (based on the books we were assigned) were length and death. The longer the book, and the more people died, the more literary merit. Old Man and the Sea? Kind of short, relatively speaking, and not much death (unless you count the marlin and some sharks): questionable literary merit. The Great Gatsby? Not so long, but a good amount of death: yep, that’s got literary merit. Tess of the d’Urbervilles? Really long, important people die: loads of literary merit. Oh, right — and of course it ranks higher if it’s dreadfully boring, too.
I wish I had an answer for this problem.  I've tried things like substituting The Big Sleep for The Great Gatsby.  Gatsby was published in 1925; The Big Sleep in 1939. Both deal with the corruption of the American Dream; both have the dreaded literary devices that English teachers love to point out.  Chandler included a knight motif in The Big Sleep; Fitzgerald developed the symbolic unread books.  The experiment didn't go badly, but the same number of students who complained about Gatsby complained about The Big Sleep.

I suspect that Liu wold suggest I do something like substitute Maus for Night.  It's probably a serviceable idea, but I'm certain that local political realities make adopting a comic book into the curriculum an unwise battle.  Success, an unlikely eventuality, would be a Pyrrhic victory.

I believe Liu accurately described students' responses to most assigned literature. Students need to own their reading, and one of the best ways to accomplish that task is to give them the autonomy to choose what they read. I know students need to learn that there are better choices than Twilight, Harry Potter, The Hunger Games, and whatever the next hot YA read is.  Given that I read comics and find them fulfilling for the 25 minutes it takes me to get through one, I'd be a hypocrite if I didn't admit that those YA novels are probably fulfilling.

Suggestions welcome in the comments.  To do item 1A is to take a nap.  I'm not going to solve this problem this afternoon.

Quotation Of The Day: Spiritual But Not Religious Edition

David Webster contends:
. . . the idea of being “spiritual, but not religious” is, at the very least, problematic. As I suggest in the book, mind-body-spirit spirituality is in danger of making us stupid, selfish, and unhappy.
Stupid—because its open-ended, inclusive and non-judgemental attitude to truth-claims actually becomes an obstacle to the combative, argumentative process whereby we discern sense from nonsense. To treat all claims as equivalent, as valid perspectives on an unsayable ultimate reality, is not to really take any of them seriously. It promotes a shallow, surface approach, whereby the work of discrimination, of testing claims against each other, and our experience in the light of method, is cast aside in favour of a lazy, bargain-basement-postmodernist relativism.
Selfish—because the ‘inner-turn’ drives us away from concerns with the material; so much so that being preoccupied with worldly matters is somehow portrayed as tawdry or shallow. It’s no accident that we see the wealthy and celebrities drawn to this very capitalist form of religion: most of the world realizes that material concerns do matter. I don’t believe that we find ourselves and meaning via an inner journey. I’m not even sure I know what it means. While of course there is course for introspection and self-examination, this, I argue, has to be in a context of concrete social realities. [Italics in original]

Philosophy Without A License: Jobs And Money Edition

Yesterday, Politico reported:
Speaker John Boehner doesn't mince words.
Let's call bulls--- bulls---," he told House Republicans in a closed meeting this morning.  "This election is about jobs, jobs, jobs."
Whenever I hear a politician throw the BS flag, I'm reminded of the Harry G. Frankfurt classic On Bullshit.  The web version that became the book is available here.  Frankfurter opens his classic essay with a useful reminder:
One of the most salient features of our culture is that there is so much bullshit. Everyone knows this. Each of us contributes his share. But we tend to take the situation for granted. Most people are rather confident of their ability to recognize bullshit and to avoid being taken in by it. So the phenomenon has not aroused much deliberate concern, or attracted much sustained inquiry. In consequence, we have no clear understanding of what bullshit is, why there is so much of it, or what functions it serves.
Pointing out that BS is ubiquitous and ill-defined is fun, but Ed Kilgore prompts me to up my philosophical game a bit.  Kilgore writes, "So the election is “about” jobs, but not that green stuff that people do jobs to get—you know, money."  In short, people work, not just to work, but to get money to buy food, clothing, shelter, education, and entertainment.  In short Kilgore reminds readers of Aristotle's observation: "Every art and every inquiry, and similarly every action and pursuit, is thought to aim at some good . . . ."

In other words people go to work because the work gets them something not because the work is their ultimate goal.  Charles Hughes Smith adds practical perspective about the most obvious goal, money:
If you go to the Bureau of Labor Statistics Inflation Calculator and plug in $1.60 (the minimum wage in 1969 when I started working summers in high school) and select the year 1969, you find that in 2012 dollars the minimum wage should be $10 per hour if it were to match the rate considered "reasonable" 43 years ago, when the nation was significantly less wealthy and much less productive.
If the election is supposed to be about jobs, but jobs no longer fulfill the function they did 50 years ago, maybe it's time to recognize the political BS for what it is, and change the focus of the election to creating a society where jobs are a means to a better life not an end unto themselves.