Monday, May 7, 2012

Still More Reasons Merit Pay Is Flawed

John T Spenser lists 10 of them here.  The most troubling and accurate include the unintended consequences.
6. Subject and Grade Differences: Core curriculum classes are different from CTE / vocational, arts, physical education and music classes.  Similarly, teaching five year olds is nothing like teaching seniors in high school.  (Now freshmen, yes, but seniors, no.) How will merit pay deal with these differences?  How will they deal with tested versus non-tested subjects?  How will they evaluate teachers whose roles are so different from one another and still claim to represent a uniform, equitable standard?
8. Innovation Suffers: Merit pay rewards teachers who use "best practices" and produce higher test scores.  As teachers feel the pressure to earn a living wage, they'll be less likely to try new practices that could potentially transform learning.
9. Merit Pay Encourages Cheating: What does Wall Street have in common with Major League Baseball?  When high-stakes extrinsic rewards were offered for short-term gains, people began to cheat.  My hope is that teachers are more ethical than that, but a merit pay system sets up an unnecessary temptation that didn't exist before.
I would add three more. First, merit pay keeps the focus on teachers not students.  At the high school level, students need to take more responsibility for their educations.  Merit pay presumes that teachers bear most, if not all, of the responsibility.

Second, merit pay will promote unrealistic expectations.  Teachers are not going to teach better after states or districts impose merit pay, but the true believers have promised that merit pay will drastically improve students' ability to learn.

Finally, merit pay will postpone effective reforms.  Schools will try this experiment for another four or five years before concluding that it has failed to reduce any reforms.  While the doomed experiment is working toward it's logical conclusion, effective reforms will not be implemented.

Quotation Of The Day: I Can't Believe I Quoted Bill O'Reilly

From his syndicated column,

First, I agree with this point about word usage, although O'Reilly's own overblown style makes the point less effective than it could be.
Let’s start with the phrase “at the end of the day.” Overused by pundits and politicians alike, those words are now making my ears bleed. Lights out on this one, please.
Second, a substantive point that should not longer have to be made, but sadly, it still does.
Obama is a Muslim. No, he’s not. His children were baptized in a Christian church. If he were a Muslim, the president would be damned just for that. He’s not a Muslim, and the folks who think he is are insane.
Finally, there's this conclusion.  I may quibble a bit and argue that the word "candidates" should be changed to"campaigns." but the point is valid.
So there you have it, from the heart. The two presidential candidates are boring enough. They don’t need any help from us. So let’s all band together and stop the tedium. Do it for your country.

Sunday, May 6, 2012

Everything Old Is New Again: Myths For Our Time?

I've been meaning to respond to the conclusion of this Alyssa Rosenberg post for a long time.  She writes,
I’m not sure we have myths to embody the new fears generated by a world that’s much larger than the village, or the disembodied terrors of the digital age.
I was going rant a bit and assert that we didn't need new myths; the old folk tales might be enough.  Further, new myths or, at the very least, new uses of the archetypes--Star Wars, the Harry Potter franchise, and superheroes--exist.

Rosenberg may not have come to the same conclusions, but she hints that she could answer her question in the same way.  In her review of The Avengers, she writes,
In The Avengers, the battle of ideas isn’t between the forces of good and evil: it’s between the people who are supposed to be allies. Captain America thinks Iron Man’s a showboat, while Tony thinks Steve is a hopeless square. They waste time tangling with Thor in a forest before recognizing their common aims. Once they do, those three men plus Dr. Banner, find themselves suspicious of a secret S.H.I.E.L.D. agenda they uncover in the course of gearing up to fight Loki. And Fury manipulates them into coming together as a team even as he tries to hold off the worst impulses of the S.H.I.E.L.D. council he must answer to.
In the aftermath of the September 11 attacks, superhero movies like Spider-Man 2, with its famous sequence of New York City subway passengers lifting up a fallen Peter Parker, were first about what other people had done to us and our capacity to recover. In The Dark Knight, Christopher Nolan’s Batman became a representative of the terrible things we’d do to ourselves and the compromises we’d make to fight back against an external threat. The Avengers takes a third path, positing superheroes as the people who will stand firm both against terrorists and our own darkest impulses and those of the people in whom we’ve invested official governmental power. They’ll be there when we need them, but they aren’t entrenching themselves, amassing power and growing corrupt. It’s in keeping with the suspicion of institutions that’s become a major theme in Whedon’s work.
At the risk of committing both sociology and philosophy without a licence, The Avengers has long been about frightening dualities.  Iron Man reveals technology's power to save, and the risks of an imperfect human possessing unheard of power.  The Hulk personifies the fears of what can happen when science and technology go awry.  The character also illustrates the fears each of us has about our own hidden demons and emptiness of being an outcast.

I don't believe I'm stretching the dichotomies too far by claiming that the comfort provided by knowing that the powerful Norse thunder god is on humanity's side is tempered by the fearful knowledge that Loki and his mischief is out there somewhere.  The humans like Nick Fury, the Black Widow, and Hawkeye use their wits, archaic tools enhanced with modern technology, or the newest gizmos to battle fears, both real and imagined, just like every single one of us.

Perhaps all of these little examples are "mentions" or "illustrations" but not "explorations," a shortcoming that many seem to use to condemn recent superhero films.  Rosenberg, however, walks right up to the edge of declaring The Avengers a myth when she concludes,
But this franchise, with its long-form exploration of a rich cast of characters and its embrace of a huge, complex universe, has unlocked, at long last, the wondrous, weird potential of comic books to transport us to other worlds and to render our own transformed.
I would take her phrasing one step further.  Comics have the potential to unlock wonder about who humans are and the nature of our world in addition to dealing with the age old questions about never being able to accomplish the good we seek to do or believe we should do.  Those questions troubled our ancestors in their villages and continue to trouble us in the digital age.  Comics, like myths, never answer those questions; they just help us think about them.

Saturday, May 5, 2012

Saturday Evening Weirdness: Theologian And Pop Star Edition

Earlier today I was confronted with this tweet.


At the time, I was contemplating the greatness of Free Comic Book Day, so I didn't give it much thought.  Since then, I have discovered work on the Interwebs that must have been created under the influence of bourbon and tequila along with some scotch and bathtub gin.

In short, it matters little whether mixing the two intoxicants is legal; on the other hand, mixing them may produce morally questionable work.

From the Reinhold Bieber Tumblr






Overview of  Reinhold Niebuhr here.  Readers will have to find Bieber info on their own.

HT: Andrew Sullivan

Happy Holiday(s)

Days like today make America great.

Those who are so inclined can experience nostalgia for a time the didn't live in, the time when horse racing was a major sport, and watch the pageantry of the Kentucky Derby.

One can celebrate Cinco de Mayo.  If one is Paula Deen, one can celebrate Sink the Mayo.

More importantly for us geeks who never grew up itls Free Comic Book Day

Enjoy the holiday of your choice.

Friday, May 4, 2012

Quotation Of The Day: Economic Policy Edition

From this New York Times article contrasting the economic problems confronting Europeans and Americans.
The huge bailouts, started in the administration of George W. Bush and continued by President Obama, worked. The banks were bailed out, and the survivors were forced to recapitalize.
The bailouts have become generally unpopular, in no small part because many banks seem to still view themselves as masters of the universe. There is nothing more grating than an ungrateful welfare recipient riding around in a chauffeured Mercedes complaining that he is not being treated fairly. But the reality then — and now — was that a modern economy must have a decently functioning financial system.
 I don't have the expertise to comment on the first paragraph.  The bolded part of the second paragraph, however, reminds me of a definition of poetry:  the best words in the best order.

A Minor Musing: Philosophy Friday Edition

On an NPR blog Adam Frank highlights a couple of important questions.  The title contains an intriguing one:  Why are scientists hating on philosophy and philosophers?
The first line asks a deeper question and one that is personally more relevant:  "What is learning for if it doesn't lead to wisdom?"  I will digress for a moment to ask Governor Daugaard how a bubble test determines either learning or wisdom.

The core of the Frank's piece, however, serves as a reminder that few disciplines are mutually exclusive.
Make no mistake, philosophy (and the philosophy of science) are not about doing science. Instead, these fields ask entirely different kinds of questions. They explore the relation between the possible and the actual, the correct links between an argument and it's conclusions or the tension between theoretical models and claims of evidence for those models.
Carbon-nanotube physicists are so deep within the traditional modes of empirical (i.e., data-driven) scientific investigation that they can happily ignore what goes on in the halls of philosophy. But . . . cosmologists can push so hard and so far at the boundaries of fundamental concepts they cross over and fall prey to their own unspoken philosophical biases and misconceptions
.Recognizing bias and respecting empirical evidence along with the classic admission that one knows far less than one thinks seem to be the most important tools to help acquire learning and gain a bit of wisdom.  I fear schools are doing everything humanly possible to dull those tools.

HT: I09.com