Saturday, July 9, 2011

Of Openness And Lobbying

The Dakota War College comments about "hopes" that South Dakota can develop an on-line database containing information on lobbyists.  DWC regular MC quotes an Argus Leader story,
"Lobbying is a great way for legislators to become informed about issues, and they do rely on them quite a bit. It's important to understand which interests are trying to influence the legislation," Quist said.
For the record the Argus article identifies "Pete Quist [as the] lead researcher for the National Institute on Money in State Politics."

MC correctly observes, "This on-line, searchable database to be open to the public can only help the process.  It is always good to know who supports what."  Openness in government is always welcome.

MC and Quist confuse me, however, with the assertions that "[l]obbying is a great way for legislators to become informed about issues" and "there [are] alot of bills that get put in the hopper every year, I can see how lobbying can help legislators understand who will [benefit] or suffer from any bill."

First, South Dakota's legislators have access to the South Dakota Legislative Research Council staff who are hired to
Provide technical assistance to legislators in a nonpartisan manner 
  • Answer questions and advise legislators in assigned subject areas 
  • Stay knowledgeable of state and federal statutes and rules in assigned subject areas 
  • Respond to information requests from legislators
Further, I've heard about these things called Google, Bing, and the Internet.  Apparently, these tools help people get information about nearly anything by typing a few relevant words in something called a search box.

Most importantly, the people most often hurt by legislation cannot afford to travel to Pierre nor do they have a lobbyist to advocate their interests.

In short, "providing information" seems to be a euphemism for "old boys network" or "protect our interests."  At my most cynical, I'd even contend that the phrase is code for "how can we best screw over our political opponents?"

MC concludes his post with an important question: "I have to wonder how much power do lobbyists [yield] in the [legislature], [compared] to the average citizen or even a elected legislator."

The indefatigable Cory Heidelberger comments,
MC, I think the answers to your closing questions are obvious. If lobbyists didn’t have more influence than the regular citizen, special interests wouldn’t pay them the big bucks to camp out in Pierre all session long.
I tend to agree with Cory's belief that corporations and other special interests would not hire lobbyists if lobbyists didn't provide a return on investment.  On the other hand, the education lobby's spectacular failures during recent legislative sessions illustrates the limits of lobbying.

Legislators seem to have a certain stubbornness that makes them immune to some lobbyists.  That stubborness makes me wonder if the more important question is who's supporting the legislator during the election and who's giving campaign contributions.  In addition to the lobbyist database, voters might benefit from knowing who gives financial support to the candidate before going to the polls.

Friday, July 8, 2011

Is Kristi Noem Playing Political Poker With My Money?

One of poker's most basic unwritten rules is never bet more than you can afford to lose. The only exception to that rule is when one is betting with someone else's money. Today's Mitchell Republic reports,
U.S. Rep. Kristi Noem, R-S.D., said any budget deal will need to include “trillions” in budget cuts before she would vote to raise the nation’s debt ceiling.
“In order for me to vote to raise the debt ceiling, we need to cut trillions and change the way we spend money in Washington, D.C. That’s what I’ll be looking for,” Noem told reporters Thursday.
In short, Noem is willing to risk default.  Most of the debate about the effects of a US government default has been theoretical.  Today, however, Kevin Drum points to a case study and its results.
Here's an interesting factlet from Bruce Bartlett. He's addressing the question of whether a "technical" default — i.e., one in which the Treasury Department misses payments to bondholders for just a few days — would affect interest rates. It turns out that we actually have a case study on just this question:
Some may think that a rise in rates would be temporary. But there was a case back in 1979 when a combination of a failure to increase the debt limit in time and a breakdown of Treasury’s machines for printing checks caused a two-week default. A 1989 academic study found that it raised interest rates by six-tenths of a percentage point for years afterward.
Six-tenths of one percent interest rate hikes sound like trouble to me especially given the current job crisis and the rising cost of food and fuel.  Drum does a little math to drive the point home.
My back-of-the-envelope chicken scratching suggests that if this happens again it would cost the government something like $50-100 billion per year. In other words, no matter what debt ceiling deal we reach, upwards of half of it could be wiped out by higher interest costs if it comes too late to prevent default on the debt.
Looking at Drum's numbers, default will cost at least $1 trillion, wiping out one-third to one-half of the cuts Noem claims she wants.  Plus, no one knows the full economic effect of rising interest rates.  If rising rates cause another economic downturn, the deficit will probably increase even with Noem's desired "trillions" in cuts.

(HT @coralhei for Mitchell Republic link)

Another Minor Musing About Stuff

I've previously mentioned that it frequently appears that possessions own us.  Jason Peters at The Front Porch Republic provides a reason for that phenomenon.
I am describing—or at least attempting to describe—at least two facts of human existence that I’m going to go ahead and call “mysteries.” One is that our attachment to certain objects, or objects of a certain kind or category, suggests at least this much about us: we are a species that craves presence. The other is that to us an object is never merely an object. It is always itself plus something else.

Another way to put this would be to say that, properly speaking, there is no such thing as an object. The world is not filled with objects. It is filled with images.
Peters poetically concludes,
We are creatures of flesh and blood; flesh and blood are what we crave. Not to crave them is to diminish our humanity. The boy holding out his ball cap for an autograph is behaving in accordance with his incarnate condition—that is, in accordance with his full humanity.
Somehow, this conclusion seems both correct and hopelessly optimistic.  Peters seems to gloss over the fact that attachment to physical objects seems to express fear.  The desire to possess goes deeper than angst that the object may some day be necessary.  That fear that something useful may not be available when needed prompted my parents, both children of the depression, to save nearly everything.  Taken to an extreme that fear becomes a paranoia that produces the tragic souls exhibited like zoo animals on television programs like Hoarders.

The deeper fear is the fear of human fallibility, especially the fallibility of memory. Peters alludes to that fear when he writes,
The mother mourning the death of her son will not settle for the mere mental image of him. She will have photographs—that is, images. The absent lover will not be satisfied with the memory of his beloved; he will have a token that his body can partake of, most likely a token that evokes his senses of sight and smell. And, as valuable as the email message from her may be, it isn’t the piece of paper the girl’s hand—the hand he longs to hold—moved across as she wrote.
All of these examples point to human fear that memory will fail.  Humans forget even the things we solemnly promise ourselves that we will remember.  The parent, lover, mourner, old person in a rocker can use the object to prompt memory and the solace memory provides.

The deeper fear, one that goes to the core of being human is the fear of being forgotten.  The knowledge that all memories fade and that objects prompt memory may cause humans to value possessions that others can associate with us.  After we pass, the object will survive and the object can serve as a kind of totem preserving us in memory.

Quotation of the Day: Poetic, Optimistic, Speech Teacher Edition

Brian Eno, from a LA Times interview
We are all singing. We call it speech, but we’re singing to each other, and I thought, as soon as you put spoken word onto music, you start to hear it like singing anyway. You start to develop musical value and musical weight, and you start to notice how this word falls on that beat, and so on and so on. So in a way I think I was trying to draw more attention to the fact that everybody is a singer --  everybody who uses their voice is kind of singing. And that was a big liberation for me, to realize that.

Why We Need An Economic Version Of The X-Files.

I've blogged that facts don't speak for themselves here and here.

At South Dakota Politics, Dr. Blanchard posts "The Fiscal Mess We're In" with a follow-up. Blanchard calls uses New York Times, Wall Street Journal, and Weekly Standard articles to call for cuts to entitlements including Social Security. 

To his credit, Blanchard, unlike many conservatives admits that tax increases might be necessary.  I'm unsure if  Blanchard would would agree with the facts, tone, or reasoning that Robert Ferguson and Thomas Johnson present in Salon.
Between 2002 and 2007, for example, the richest 1 percent of Americans garnered 62 percent of all income gains, while the bottom 90 percent of the population saw their incomes grow by 4 percent. At the same time, thanks to the Bush tax cuts, the rich were also paying proportionately fewer taxes. Considering that ordinary Americans fronted most of the money for the bank bailouts and have endured most of the recession’s “collateral damage,” it seems only simple justice that if the program needs fixing, the best way to do it would be to raise the ceilings on earnings subject to the Social Security tax, which is currently only $106,800. That would put the burden on people who cannot plausibly claim to be suffering.
Further, Ferguson and Johnson conclude the following about entitlements:

But even now there is no near-term threat to Social Security’s solvency. In 1983, Congress enacted into law recommendations of the Greenspan Commission to raise Social Security taxes to cover the retirement bulge coming from baby boomers. Since then, the program has piled up enormous surpluses. These have been invested in government bonds, thus helping to finance the rest of the government.

The 2011 Report of the Trustees of the Social Security Trust Fund projects that the Trust Fund and interest earnings from it will suffice to cover all benefit payments until 2036. Even then, the fund would not be empty -- the report projects that tax revenues will still cover approximately 75 percent of promised benefits until 2085. Talk of the bankruptcy of Social Security is hot air.
Meanwhile, Blanchard contends,
The Democrats in Congress have agreed to promises of future spending cuts, but only in non-entitlement spending. That just begins the process whereby entitlement spending and interest on the federal debt squeezes out all other spending. Until and unless entitlement reform is really on the table, agreeing to revenue increases just compounds the problem.
Where's the economic version of Mulder and Scully?  The truth has to be out there.

Thursday, July 7, 2011

Teaching Civics May Help Preserve The Middle Class

William Damon, a professor of education at Stanford University, director of the Stanford Center on Adolescence, and a senior fellow at the Hoover Institution, worries about the recent information that students score poorly on basic civics knowledge.

Damon makes a trenchant conclusion and offers a solution that might have long term benefits beyond test scores.  He writes,
How can we do better? Of course we need to teach students the Constitution, along with its essential underlying principles such as separation of powers, representative government, and Federalism. Excellent programs for such teaching now exist. But these programs are not widely used amidst today's single-minded focus on basic skills
Those points may not be new to those who understand the idiocy behind the testing regime mandated by NCLB/RTTT.  The fact that they come from a Hoover fellow is welcome.

More importantly, Damon writes,
As for the essential matter of motivation, the only way to capture students' interest is to inspire in them some justifiable pride in their country's best traditions. Fortunately, U. S. success stories are not hard to find. In our recent history, three 20th Century cases could be taught to promote pride in the American tradition: 1) the civil rights movement that extended rights to millions of citizens in the United States; 2) victories over totalitarianism (especially fascism, communism, and other militaristic tyrannies) that extended new freedoms to millions of subjugated people in Europe and Asia; and 3) the building of a middle class that offered economic freedom to millions of ordinary citizens, and to immigrants coming to American in search of a better life as well. [Bold Mine]
I'm always a bit leery of appeals to American greatness because those phrases are often turned into jingoistic domestic political slogans that favor the Koch brothers or corporate America.  The middle class, however,  is under the most vicious assault I have seen in my nearly 54 year life.  I seriously doubt that current trends will allow any future grandchildren the opportunities to better themselves that I had.  If students are taught that the middle class was necessary for economic freedom AND that its being systematically decimated, perhaps there's a chance to reverse the current trend.

If Americans don't reverse this trend, I echo Damon's prediction for a dire future.
We live in a time marked by anxieties over many perceived threats to our way of life—terrorism, economic collapse, and climate change, to mention just a few of the widespread fears making our headlines these days. But there is a looming crisis closer at hand that poses every bit as grave a threat to the future of our way of life: the very real possibility that our democracy will be left in the hands of a citizenry unprepared to govern it and unwilling the make the sacrifices needed to preserve it. A free society requires an informed and virtuous citizenry. Failing this, as Ben Franklin long ago warned, despotism lies just around the corner.
(HT: Bruce Bawer)

My House During Costuming Season

My wife will probably be angry with me for posting this picture, so I will say two things.  First, debate season produces far more interesting pictures,  Second, if I were left to my own devices, I would probably decorate the whole house in this motif.