Monday, July 4, 2011

I Must Be A Bad American

I was hoping to discover that I am a mutant because mutants get to have their own comic book and move franchises, but, alas, I have to accept that I am a bad American.

My first clue came when I learned that I hate parades more than good Americans.  I dislike Macy's Thanksgiving parade, the Tournament of Roses parade, local Independence Day parades, Moscow's May Day parade, and every other kind of parade one can name.  I had thought that I could still claim I'm a good a American because I love baseball, hot dogs--currently, I'm partial to Sonic's Chicago Dog--apple pie, and I drive GM or Ford vehicles, but those superficial exhibitions of good and decent American-ness are trumped by two other factors.

First, I want to change the national anthem.  I have this weird idea that a national anthem lyrics should be about the country as a whole not a poem based on a battle in the War of 1812.  If we're going to sing about battles, we probably should sing about the Battle of Saratoga that decided the Revolutionary War or The Battle of Gettysburg that turned the tide and preserved the Union during the Civil War.

I'm not totally alone in my desire to change the national anthem.  There's an online petition drive to change it to "America the Beautiful." As of today, there are 167 signatures.  Michael Kinsley wrote a column advocating change and analyzing replacements in 2009.  His list included "My Country 'Tis of Thee," "This Land Is Your Land," and "Simple Gifts."  I'd be fine with any or all of these, but a non-scientific poll responding to the article showed 86% want to leave the anthem as is.  I had hoped that the Christina Aguilera Super Bowl gaffes would start a push for a change, but no such luck.


I have and even weirder idea that I can't shake: one should pledge allegiance to the country before one pledges allegiance to the flag of the country.  MC at the Dakota War College wants Americans"to stand up like a first grader, place your hand over your heart and say the Pledge of Allegiance." Cory at the Madville Times is more nuanced.
As a dedicated American, the first great nationality based on rational choice rather than blood, I prefer to pledge my allegiance like a rational adult, not a first-grader. I want the words coming out of my mouth to be intelligent and sincere expressions, not knee-jerk reactions and conditioned recitations.

I enjoy leaving out the robotic pauses that strip the Pledge of meaning. (There is no comma after allegiance, flag, or republic. Try it: say the Pledge not as bad poetry, but as a sentence you would say to a friend at the kitchen table.) I especially enjoy emphasizing the most important words: the last six.
Both discuss the "under God" phrase.  I think Terry Eagleton gets it right when he writes, "[s]ocieties become truly secular not when they dispense with religion but when they are no longer greatly agitated by it."  I think the same is true for societies of faith; they are not greatly agitated by those who do not wish to make bold displays of belief. (HT Andrew Sullivan.)

Frankly, I think there's much more poetry and expression of faith in opening and conclusion of the Declaration of Independence.
We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain inalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.

That to secure these rights, governments are instituted among men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed. That whenever any form of government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the right of the people to alter or abolish it, and to institute new government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their safety and happiness.
. . . . And for the support of this Declaration, with a firm reliance on the protection of divine Providence, we mutually pledge to each other our Lives, our Fortunes and our sacred Honor.
Even with the word pledge in the last last sentence, it would probably be tough to write a pledge of allegiance based on these lines.  On the other hand, the Constitution's Preamble contains the makings of a fine pledge.  It wouldn't take much to change
We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.
to
I pledge allegiance to the Constitution and people of the United States, in order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity.
I'd much prefer reciting that pledge that affirms greatness and requires citizens to have duties, but I guess that makes me a bad American who's ashamed of his country.

Sunday, July 3, 2011

So Lint Is Really Alive?

From the IO9.com post "Our bellybuttons are home to hundreds of undiscovered species,"
The Belly Button Biodiversity project recently began taking DNA samples from people's navels to find out what bacteria is living within. Of the roughly 1,400 bacterial strains discovered thus far, at least 662 of them are completely unknown.
First, I know universities should promote inquiry at all levels and that students and professors should possess an endless curiosity, but does America really need a "Belly Button Biodiversity Project?"  The article makes a case to be made for such a project;
That's a dramatic result, but the researcher say it shouldn't necessarily be considered too surprising. Indeed, they say it's a testament to just how little we actually know about bacterial diversity. Team member Jeri Hulcr says this is the microbial equivalent of European explorers setting eyes on African game for the first time - once you get used to the fact of their existence, they quickly stop seeming all that exotic.
Still, shouldn't university types have access to a creative writing professors who could help them come up with a better name?

For example, one could call this The Fantastic Voyage Meets Star Treks Project.  The Fantastic Voyage crew could shrink down the various Starship Enterprises so it could be inserted into subjects' navels.


The various Star Trek crews could continue to "seek out new life" and boldly go where no one has gone before."


The Trek crews would have to argue about whether Kirk, Picard, Janeway, or Archer should be the lead captain, but it would be entertaining.

Saturday, July 2, 2011

Quotation of the Week

From this post at washingtonmonthly.com
Former Sen. Alan Simpson, a Wyoming Republican, reflected this week on his party’s refusal to even consider additional revenue as part of a debt-reduction deal.
“We’re at 15 percent revenue, and historically it’s been closer to 20 percent,” says Simpson. “We’ve never had a war without a tax, and now we’ve got two,” he says. “Absolute bullshit.”

Another Obama Conflict That Apparently Is Not A War Even Though The Military Is Involved And Weapons Are Being Used

Remember "Where in the World Is Carmen Sandiego?"  Apparently President Obama wants the kids to play "Where in the World Will the Next Drone Attack Occur?"  Those playing along have learned about Afghanistan, Iraq, Pakistan, Libya, Yemen, and now Somalia.

The New York Times reports that the United States is conducting military operations in Somalia. 
The clandestine American military campaign to combat Al Qaeda’s franchise in Yemen is expanding to fight the Islamist militancy in Somalia, as new evidence indicates that insurgents in the two countries are forging closer ties and possibly plotting attacks against the United States, American officials say.

An American military drone aircraft attacked several Somalis in the militant group the Shabab late last month, the officials said, killing at least one of its midlevel operatives and wounding others.

The strike was carried out by the same Special Operations Command unit now battling militants in Yemen, and it represented an intensification of an American military campaign in a mostly lawless region where weak governments have allowed groups with links to Al Qaeda to flourish.
I'm all for students learning geography, but I also want them to learn that the President doesn't have unlimited war making powers, even if that is not a view that the President shares.  According to CNN,
Administration officials have repeatedly asserted that the U.S. role in Libya does not meet the law's definition of hostilities. The president reportedly overruled contrary legal opinions put forward by both the Pentagon and the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel in declining to seek congressional authorization.

Earlier Tuesday, top State Department legal adviser Harold Koh told members of the committee that the War Powers law does not apply to the U.S. military intervention.

Koh argued that the measure is not applicable because the U.S. role in the mission is limited in terms of its scope, means, exposure of U.S. forces, and chances of escalation.
The limited "chances of escalation" must apply only within Libya because the amorphous "War on Terrorism" seems to be expanding everywhere.

A Headline That I Never Thought I'd See And A Question For The Ages

Why is Lindsay Lohan tweeting about the Federal Reserve's monetary policy?

I'm sure some philosophy and economics majors are starting to write theses now.  I expect several academic conventions to take up the question.

Comments are open.

*This article provides an answer, unfortunately, it's such a let down.

Friday, July 1, 2011

Of Education And Graduation

Jason Peters makes a wonderful observation.
That is why we graduate rather than educate students. A graduate can hope, maybe, to pay back the loans. An educate can’t. (And it is telling—isn’t it?—that we have the noun “graduate” but not the noun “educate.”)

When Did Republicans Start Ignoring Karl Rove?

David Frum chides Karl Rove for giving good advice too late.
Karl Rove today outlines the requirements for a successful GOP campaign in 2012. Suffice to say, if Rove is right, the GOP has already stumbled into deep, deep trouble.

Rove: “The GOP nominee should fiercely challenge Mr. Obama’s policies, actions and leadership using the president’s own words, but should stay away from questioning his motives, patriotism or character. He will do this to his GOP opponent to try to draw Republicans into the mud pit. They should avoid it.”

Kind of late for that advice.
Frum goes on to give a series of examples of Republicans "questioning [Obama's] motives, patriotism or character."  A couple of examples have occurred since Rove and Frum wrote their columns. 

First, Senator John Thune accused Obama of being lazy.  The Hill reports,
One of the Senate's top Republicans on Thursday fired back at President Obama for questioning his party's work ethic, suggesting that the president should spend less time on the golf course.

"I think the best way to get an appointment with the president is to set up a tee time," Sen. John Thune (S.D.), the chairman of the Senate Republican Policy Committee, told Fox News.
Further, the New York Times reports that Pat Roberts implies that the President needs medical treatment for anger management.
Senator Pat Roberts of Kansas even suggested that the president needed some sedation before he resumed discussions with them.

“I remember when he talked to Republicans before, and all we got was a lecture,” Mr. Roberts said. “So maybe if he would just take a Valium and calm down and come down and talk to us, it might be helpful.”
One possessed of a snarky spirit might note that Senators Thune and Roberts are giving contradictory advice.  Valium might make one lethargic and "lazy."  Following Roberts advice seems to make following Thune's impossible.

On a serious level, it's good to see reminders to "stay away from questioning his motives, patriotism or character."  It's worrisome that senior legislators ignore that advice and cause one to wonder when Karl Rove became the voice of reason within the Republican Party.