Thursday, March 24, 2011
A Really Minor Musing
One would have to be high on Koch brothers money (a little policy debate humor for the Madville Times) not to anticipate the events chronicled in this New York Times article "States Pass Budget Pain to Cities". Locally, District 18's Representative Nick Moser "would take with a grain of salt that the Legislature went up there and raised your property taxes through the roof." Technically, Moser is right; legislative action means that cities and counties will raise property taxes, so the legislature didn't. Metaphorically, I'll take him at his word. Taxes probably will go through the ceiling and fill the attic, but they probably won't go through the roof.
Labels:
Education Funding,
Minor Musings
Tuesday, March 22, 2011
No Wonder I'm Paranoid
I am not shocked when a blog at The American Conservative hopes that Republican governors will continue their assault on teachers. After all, every conservative takes as gospel that "school teachers, hardly represent a cross-section of the country on social and cultural issues. They are well to the left of most of the population." And, of course, we don't have enough to do as we try to teach history, math, science, or English; therefore, only a dupe would believe "that union-faithful teachers favor educating the young in some value-free manner." I would be remiss in my blogging duties if I did not mention that conservatives also take as gospel the assumption that every school limits itself to one or two token conservatives who are ritualistically mocked in the teachers' lounge. In short, I expect conservatives to assert I'm out to turn their children into Marxist Muslim terrorists.
On the other hand, a Diane Ravitch editorial reminds Newsweek readers that "Obama has not sought to turn back NCLB. His own approach, called Race to the Top, is even more punitive than NCLB." More frighteningly, Ravitch says,
A couple of days ago I quoted Adam Frank who wrote, "In poem or paean, in music or metaphor, in silent homage to whatever powers make sense to the heart in that moment, we may (or may not) find our way." I can think of two small pieces of literature that fit the present situation. Stanzas two and three of "The Charge of the Light Brigade" seem to fit the political situation, at least metaphorically.
On the other hand, a Diane Ravitch editorial reminds Newsweek readers that "Obama has not sought to turn back NCLB. His own approach, called Race to the Top, is even more punitive than NCLB." More frighteningly, Ravitch says,
The Obama agenda for testing, accountability, and choice bears an uncanny resemblance to the Republican agenda of the past 30 years, but with one significant difference. Republicans have traditionally been wary of federal control of the schools. Duncan, however, relishes the opportunity to promote his policies with the financial heft of the federal government.So the right wants to use local and state government to make my life miserable, and the Democrats want to use the federal government to make my life miserable.
A couple of days ago I quoted Adam Frank who wrote, "In poem or paean, in music or metaphor, in silent homage to whatever powers make sense to the heart in that moment, we may (or may not) find our way." I can think of two small pieces of literature that fit the present situation. Stanzas two and three of "The Charge of the Light Brigade" seem to fit the political situation, at least metaphorically.
The other is James 3:1 "Not many of you should presume to be teachers, my brothers, because you know that we who teach will be judged more strictly." I always thought that passage was reserved for people who taught Sunday school. I guess it applies to those of us who teach Monday through Friday school as well.'Forward, the Light Brigade!'
Was there a man dismay'd ?
Not tho' the soldier knew
Some one had blunder'd:
Theirs not to make reply,
Theirs not to reason why,
Theirs but to do & die,
. . .
Cannon to right of them
Cannon to left of them,
Cannon in front of them
Volley'd & thunder'd;
. . . .
Monday, March 21, 2011
What's in A Word?
Adrian Petersen, star running back for the Minnesota Vikings, created a bit of a dust-up when he compared the National Football League to "modern-day slavery." He has been accussed of "not thinking at all," being "an idiot," and needing "a lesson in history."
I am saddened that "[t]here are more slaves today than were seized from Africa in four centuries of the trans-Atlantic slave trade" Further, [t]he modern commerce in humans rivals illegal drug trafficking in its global reach—and in the destruction of lives." I wish more people knew that conservative estimates believe that there are 27 million people in slavery today. That number "means that there are more people in slavery today than at any other time in human history." Finally, I will grant that the word "slave" is "infamously rooted in history that [it is] are beyond nuance and context" and that using "that painful imagery in a five-second sound bite . . . was guaranteed to blow up in his face," especially since Peterson is expected to earn $10 million dollars next year.
Still, I'm bothered by the fact that everyone is going after him for the first half of the sentence and not focusing on the last half. Peterson said, "It's modern-day slavery, you know? People kind of laugh at that, but there are people working at regular jobs who get treated the same way, too." [emphasis mine]
What if Peterson had said that the NFL is like modern day sharecropping or serfdom? Granted, Peterson is going to make $10 million next season and no serf or sharecropper ever earned that much. On the other hand, he is limited to playing in the NFL. No rival football leagues exist. When he was drafted by the Minnesota Vikings, he would have had to wait for a year to play football if he had not wanted to live in Minneapolis. In short, he had to choose between playing football and working where he wanted.
More importantly, NFL players who play 5 years have a life expectancy of only 55 years, decades less than the average lifespan of 77 years. To put an NFL player's life expectancy in perspective, it's the same as a man living in Ethopia. Even those who condemn Peterson admit that "it's the players who risk bodily harm and brain damage, and are often left with chronic pain and debilitating conditions for life." Most of those players won't be millionaires, but the company store owns their bodies, if not their souls.
Too many people take a "if it's so bad, leave attitude" toward anyone who complains that working conditions are unfair. By doing so, they ignore the fact that many have to choose between a bad job and no job. No job means no food on the table and no roof over one's head. Peterson is right; a lot of people are stuck in a job that doesn't pay them enough to live, but that they can't afford to leave. It may not be slavery, but it's certainly a perversion of the American ideal. He was making a valid point, but he should have chosen his words more carefully.
I am saddened that "[t]here are more slaves today than were seized from Africa in four centuries of the trans-Atlantic slave trade" Further, [t]he modern commerce in humans rivals illegal drug trafficking in its global reach—and in the destruction of lives." I wish more people knew that conservative estimates believe that there are 27 million people in slavery today. That number "means that there are more people in slavery today than at any other time in human history." Finally, I will grant that the word "slave" is "infamously rooted in history that [it is] are beyond nuance and context" and that using "that painful imagery in a five-second sound bite . . . was guaranteed to blow up in his face," especially since Peterson is expected to earn $10 million dollars next year.
Still, I'm bothered by the fact that everyone is going after him for the first half of the sentence and not focusing on the last half. Peterson said, "It's modern-day slavery, you know? People kind of laugh at that, but there are people working at regular jobs who get treated the same way, too." [emphasis mine]
What if Peterson had said that the NFL is like modern day sharecropping or serfdom? Granted, Peterson is going to make $10 million next season and no serf or sharecropper ever earned that much. On the other hand, he is limited to playing in the NFL. No rival football leagues exist. When he was drafted by the Minnesota Vikings, he would have had to wait for a year to play football if he had not wanted to live in Minneapolis. In short, he had to choose between playing football and working where he wanted.
More importantly, NFL players who play 5 years have a life expectancy of only 55 years, decades less than the average lifespan of 77 years. To put an NFL player's life expectancy in perspective, it's the same as a man living in Ethopia. Even those who condemn Peterson admit that "it's the players who risk bodily harm and brain damage, and are often left with chronic pain and debilitating conditions for life." Most of those players won't be millionaires, but the company store owns their bodies, if not their souls.
Too many people take a "if it's so bad, leave attitude" toward anyone who complains that working conditions are unfair. By doing so, they ignore the fact that many have to choose between a bad job and no job. No job means no food on the table and no roof over one's head. Peterson is right; a lot of people are stuck in a job that doesn't pay them enough to live, but that they can't afford to leave. It may not be slavery, but it's certainly a perversion of the American ideal. He was making a valid point, but he should have chosen his words more carefully.
Labels:
middle class dying,
Wages,
words
Sunday, March 20, 2011
Why I Teach English Continued
Big boy blogger Andrew Sullivan points readers to this NPR article about the limits of science to console or make sense of an often irrational world.
That fact is both frightening and a great pity. Kids live in a world more wonderful and dangerous than anything those of us on the wrong side of 50 grew up in. They need more tools than ever to make sense of everything going on around them, No single discipline can provide those answers, but at the start of next year, most South Dakota students will be exposed to fewer tools than what I was when I went to a high school of about 60 students. That situation is also frightening and a great pity.
Science gives us so much. It is the engine of our capacities, forging tools like the life-saving technological capacity to predict tsunamis. It is also the lens of our greatest aspiration, yielding broad narratives of cosmic and planetary evolution that set our personal stories in context.
But at some point we crash up against domains where science, or at least science alone, cannot help. In those moments, when we are numb with the immediacy of great suffering, explanations can become clay on the tongue. In that shattered place, our other human talents often find their place. In poem or paean, in music or metaphor, in silent homage to whatever powers make sense to the heart in that moment, we may (or may not) find our way.
What those moments teach is that all existence is, for us, provisional. They show that we are as much creatures of experienced feeling as we are of rational thinking. They show us the full range of what it means to be human, all too human, in a world alive with tremendous power, unspeakable beauty and, sometimes, shattering terror.I doubt anyone who currently sits on a school board will consider that literature provides answers when science "becomes clay on the tongue." I'm fairly certain that they all have drunk so much STEM Kool-Aid that even this scientist's eloquent admission will have no effect. So when the budget axe falls, literature, art, and music will bear the brunt of the burden.
That fact is both frightening and a great pity. Kids live in a world more wonderful and dangerous than anything those of us on the wrong side of 50 grew up in. They need more tools than ever to make sense of everything going on around them, No single discipline can provide those answers, but at the start of next year, most South Dakota students will be exposed to fewer tools than what I was when I went to a high school of about 60 students. That situation is also frightening and a great pity.
Labels:
Why I Teach English
Friday, March 18, 2011
The Face(s) of Disillusionment
I'm not sure who produced this series that showed Bush morphing into Obama in 2009. They probably had a good reason: they could do it.
Now that Guantomo is to remain open in indefinitely, and President is winking at torture, the United States is going to attack a Muslim country without a declaration of war or "broad consultation with Congress," it seems to me that the orginal order was backwards. The series should look like this.

Once again Orwell is being used as a road map instead of a warning. He didn't want a Democrat who spoke eloquently about restoring hope and honor to turn into an imperialist concerned with projecting power when he closed Animal Farm with
Now that Guantomo is to remain open in indefinitely, and President is winking at torture, the United States is going to attack a Muslim country without a declaration of war or "broad consultation with Congress," it seems to me that the orginal order was backwards. The series should look like this.

Once again Orwell is being used as a road map instead of a warning. He didn't want a Democrat who spoke eloquently about restoring hope and honor to turn into an imperialist concerned with projecting power when he closed Animal Farm with
Twelve voices were shouting in anger, and they were all alike. No question, now, what had happened to the faces of the pigs. The creatures ouside looked from pig to man, and from man to pig, and from pig to man again; but already it was impossible to say which was which.I don't think Orwell knew how to prevent power from destroying a grand ideal. Apparently no one in America does either.
Labels:
Is it Weird Enough?,
Orwell
Wednesday, March 16, 2011
More Shoes and Ships and Sealing Wax along with a Few Cabbages and Kings
Tolstoy begins Anna Karenina with "Happy families are all alike; every unhappy family is unhappy in its own way." According to a Cornell University study, Twitter, divides itself into "two walled-off nations: happy people and unhappy people." Sadly, the study doesn't examine whether happy tweeters send out the same tweets while the unhappy tweeters send out unique tweets.
Big boy blogger Andrew Sullivan keeps track of those who want the United States to waste more blood and treasure in the Middle East here and here and here. Am I the only one who hears Pete Seeger singing, "When will they ever learn?"
On the bright side, researchers may have found Atlantis in Spain.
I think that I'm trying to avoid thinking about budget cuts, D-Step testing, and nuclear meltdowns
Big boy blogger Andrew Sullivan keeps track of those who want the United States to waste more blood and treasure in the Middle East here and here and here. Am I the only one who hears Pete Seeger singing, "When will they ever learn?"
On the bright side, researchers may have found Atlantis in Spain.
I think that I'm trying to avoid thinking about budget cuts, D-Step testing, and nuclear meltdowns
Tuesday, March 15, 2011
A Short Musing on the Mangling of History and Literature
Michelle Bachman, the Tea Party lust object du jour, has recently been caught mangling American history. When she confuses New Hampshire and Massachusetts because both have cities named Lexington, I’m pretty sure she has failed to meet one of the Common Core Standards. I don’t get to teach history because I don’t coach a an athletic activity, so I’m not sure which standard Bachman failed to meet, but I’m pretty sure it was one of the more basic ones. Her failure to meet basic standards becomes more obvious when one notices that she has made similar mistakes in the past.
While I will hang my head in shame and ignore both her factual errors and her misinterpretations of history, I can’t let her misappropriate literature.
Representative Bachman has called a vote on a continuing budget resolution “a mice or men moment,” concluding that her Tea Party allies must ask themselves, “Are we mice or are we men.”
Literature has two famous “of mice and men” moments. Neither involves comparing rodents to humans. The first is Robert Burns’s “To A Mouse,” the poem that has its speaker muse,
The other, is the John Steinbeck novel, Of Mice and Men. At the novel’s conclusion, George must shoot Lennie to prevent him from being taken by a lynch mob. I’m not sure Bachman wants voters comparing her to either George or Lennie, a mentally challenged man who accidently kills a young woman. Besides, I’m pretty sure that Bachman doesn’t want anyone to read Steinbeck who had some left of center ideas.
I wish Bachman and the rest of her ilk would represent their districts and stop mangling history, the constitution, and great literature. It’s obvious she neither loves nor understands any of it.
While I will hang my head in shame and ignore both her factual errors and her misinterpretations of history, I can’t let her misappropriate literature.
Representative Bachman has called a vote on a continuing budget resolution “a mice or men moment,” concluding that her Tea Party allies must ask themselves, “Are we mice or are we men.”
Literature has two famous “of mice and men” moments. Neither involves comparing rodents to humans. The first is Robert Burns’s “To A Mouse,” the poem that has its speaker muse,
The best laid schemes o' mice an' menClearly, Bachman, a woman brimming with Tea Party certitude, doesn’t have enough doubts about the alleged propriety of her cause to wonder who will suffer “grief and pain” if she gets to impose her “best laid plans” on innocent Americans.
Gang aft agley,
An' lea'e us nought but grief an' pain,
For promis'd joy!
The other, is the John Steinbeck novel, Of Mice and Men. At the novel’s conclusion, George must shoot Lennie to prevent him from being taken by a lynch mob. I’m not sure Bachman wants voters comparing her to either George or Lennie, a mentally challenged man who accidently kills a young woman. Besides, I’m pretty sure that Bachman doesn’t want anyone to read Steinbeck who had some left of center ideas.
I wish Bachman and the rest of her ilk would represent their districts and stop mangling history, the constitution, and great literature. It’s obvious she neither loves nor understands any of it.
Labels:
Literature,
Politics,
Why I'm Angry
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



