Tuesday, March 15, 2011

A Short Musing on the Mangling of History and Literature

Michelle Bachman, the Tea Party lust object du jour, has recently been caught mangling American history. When she confuses New Hampshire and Massachusetts because both have cities named Lexington, I’m pretty sure she has failed to meet one of the Common Core Standards. I don’t get to teach history because I don’t coach a an athletic activity, so I’m not sure which standard Bachman failed to meet, but I’m pretty sure it was one of the more basic ones.  Her failure to meet basic standards becomes more obvious when one notices that she has made similar mistakes in the past.

While I will hang my head in shame and ignore both her factual errors and her misinterpretations of history, I can’t let her misappropriate literature.

Representative Bachman has called a vote on a continuing budget resolution “a mice or men moment,” concluding that her Tea Party allies must ask themselves, “Are we mice or are we men.”

Literature has two famous “of mice and men” moments. Neither involves comparing rodents to humans. The first is Robert Burns’s “To A Mouse,” the poem that has its speaker muse,
The best laid schemes o' mice an' men
Gang aft agley,
An' lea'e us nought but grief an' pain,
For promis'd joy!
Clearly, Bachman, a woman brimming with Tea Party certitude, doesn’t have enough doubts about the alleged propriety of her cause to wonder who will suffer “grief and pain” if she gets to impose her “best laid plans” on innocent Americans.

The other, is the John Steinbeck novel, Of Mice and Men. At the novel’s conclusion, George must shoot Lennie to prevent him from being taken by a lynch mob. I’m not sure Bachman wants voters comparing her to either George or Lennie, a mentally challenged man who accidently kills a young woman. Besides, I’m pretty sure that Bachman doesn’t want anyone to read Steinbeck who had some left of center ideas.

I wish Bachman and the rest of her ilk would represent their districts and stop mangling history, the constitution, and great literature. It’s obvious she neither loves nor understands any of it.

What's Worse Than an Earthquake, Tsunami, and a Nuclear Meltdown?

Wall Street. 

The cost of Japan's disasters is estimated at $170 billion.  The Wall Street bailout was $700 billion. 

More importanly, if the movie Inside Job is any indication, the the poison Wall Street used to infect America is pernicious as nuclear radition.  According to a NYT review,
The end of the film raises a disturbing question, as Mr. Damon exhorts viewers to demand changes in the status quo so that the trends associated with unchecked speculation of the kind that caused the last crisis — rising inequality, neglect of productive capacity, endless cycles of boom and bust — might be reversed.


This call to arms makes you wonder why anger of the kind so eloquently expressed in “Inside Job” has been so inchoate. And through no fault of its own, the film may leave you dispirited as well as enraged. Its fate is likely to be that of other documentaries: praised in some quarters, nitpicked in others and shrugged off by those who need its message most. Which is a shame.
The fact that the message will be "shrugged off" may be why Charles Ferguson, the film's director has concluded "none of the post-2008 reforms will prevent a repeat of another global financial crash, particularly since the U.S. money houses which survived, thanks to bailouts, are more powerful than ever."

Radiation has a half life; Wall Street greed and corruption apparently don't.

HT Roger Ebert tweet of original comparison (posted from a spot where Twitter is blocked, so I can't do the link.)

Sunday, March 13, 2011

"Mirror, Mirror" in America

For the young or non-Trek literate readers, "Mirror Mirror" is a classic episode of the original Star Trek series.  The plot featured an alternate universe with a tyrannical Empire instead of a benevolent Federation, a bearded Spock, and a Tantalus Field that the Department of Homeland Security is probably trying to develop at this very moment.  As with all Star Trek episodes, good triumphed and everyone had a laugh on the bridge.  I'm not so sure the episode Americans are experiencing now will have such a happy ending.

First, a tweet by Peter Daou points to this article that confirms that 400 Americans have more wealth than the 155 million poorest Americans. For the purposes of comparison, Irene, South Dakota, would have more economic power than the states of California, Texas, New York, Florida, Illinois, Pennsylvania, Ohio, Michigan, Georgia, the nine US states with the largest populations.

Second, the US military is actively torturing an American citizen who has been convicted of nothing.  I naively believed that the US believed that one was innocent until proven guilty.  I also thought Obama condemned torture, but I guess that was when it didn't apply to Bradley Manning who is alleged to have turned over documents to Wikileaks.  To make matters worse, the White House has apparently decided to fire P.J. Crowley who was perceptive enough to call the government's treatment of Manning "ridiculous, counterproductive and stupid."  I guess that the prohibitions against cruel and unusual punishment and the protection of free speech can be selectively applied.

Third, via The Madville Times, I discover that South Dakota's budget is twice as large as it was in 1996 but it spends half as much on tax relief for the the elderly poor.

One of the running jokes about the original Star Trek series was that characters who appeared in a red uniform would die by the end of the episode.  Somehow, it seems as if a large portion of America just got beamed down wearing a red shirt.

Friday, February 4, 2011

Thomas Hardy, Jim Bolin, and Cory Heidelberger

Jim Bolin is a friend of mine.  Cory Heidelberger is a friend of mine.  I'm probably the only person in South Dakota who can make both of  those statements.  That's a fact that scares me.

Yesterday, Cory went after Jim on the Madville Times.  I wish Cory had been kinder to Jim whom I know to be a good history teacher.  I had the chance to hear some of his lectures back in the day.  I also wish Cory had shown a little less deference to Wade Pogany.  I don't recall Mr. Pogany doing that much good for the education or debate communities lately.

For his part, Jim should have been more consistent.  If the Common Core Standards that are being proposed for history are bad, the English ones should be questioned also.  After all, a fig tree can't bear olives, or a grapevine bear figs; in addition, a salt spring can't produce fresh water [James 3:12 Plainsman Paraphrase Version].  Jim also could have avoided the "San Francisco" and "heartland values" talking points.  Those phrases are part of the "plain folks" propaganda technique that every high school student should recognize and avoid.

This incident made me think about a larger point that I believe the beginning of a Thomas Hardy poem illustrates.
"HAD he and I but met,
By some old ancient inn,
We should have sat us down to wet
Right many a nipperkin!
Cory provides "[l]iberal media for Lake Herman, Madison, and the great state of South Dakota."  Jim is proudly conservative, so these two are "ranged as [political] infantry." 

South Dakota has a de facto one party political system; Republicans dominate.  Half of the Republican Party is to Jim's political right.  I think the state has about 37 liberals and 19 moderates. I'd hate to hear what the people to Jim's right would say about Cory.  The principle behind Aristotle's Golden Mean should apply to politics.  South Dakota shows what happens when the Golden Mean is absent; one is left with "tea-baggers" or "enemies of the the heartland."  Those conditions make it unlikely that members of either political persuasion will engage in any nipperkin wetting. (I'm pretty sure that both Jim and Cory are teetotallers, so I'm not sure what beverages would be in those tiny cups, but that's beside the point.)

To survive the next decades, my students will need to know more than any previous generation; they'll also need to know how to use those facts and how to come up with new ways to deal with old problems like budget deficits and clashing values.  I'm not sure they'll be able to that if they see everyone with an opposing viewpoint as an enemy.  Yet, the state seems to have created a political culture that will continue foster just such an attitude.  Hardy, were he writing today, to say that South Dakota politics, not war, is "quaint and curious."

Thursday, February 3, 2011

Thank God for Small Gifts

Via the Madville Times, I see that the South Dakota Legislature is seriously considering limiting interest rates charged by payday lenders.  The bill probably should contain a truth in advertising amendment that has them call themselves payday predators, but that’s a topic for another day.

Given that Governor Dennis Daugaard stubbornly insists on cutting funding to education at least 10% and that those cuts mean layoffs, it’s good to know that the loan sharks will have a few limits when the laid off teachers are in their clutches.  It would be better to limit payday predators and fund education fully, but the latter option doesn’t seem to be on the table, so I guess we’ll have to celebrate the small gifts.

Monday, January 24, 2011

Test Taking And Dollars

This Slate post links to a Daily Beast article about students' NAEP scores.  The top five test taking states are Massachusetts, Vermont, New Jersey, New Hampshire, and Minnesota. The younguns in the wrong reading group aka those don't take tests well live in Mississippi, Washington, D.C., West Virginia, New Mexico, and Louisiana.

Slate concludes:  "Probably not coincidentally, the list of 'smartest' states tracks pretty closely with the list of richest states, and the worst test-takers tend to live in the most impoverished areas."  The Beast gives a bit more detail concluding pointing out
. . . . the top five performing states on this list have a median household income (not adjusted for cost of living) of roughly $60,000, and 21 percent of people over age 25 have a bachelor’s degree; the bottom five are at $44,000 and 14 percent, respectively, according to 2009 US Census figures. Children who perform better on NAEP tests also tend to come from states with lower levels of student poverty.
For the record, South Dakota ranked 22nd on the NAEP and ranks 26th in child poverty.  A quick look at a chart provided by the Census Bureau seems to indicate that South Dakota ranks 26th in median income with an average income of $48,416.

I spent most of the weekend listening to high schoolers tell me that correlation does not mean causation, so I approach these numbers with a bit of trepidation.  That being said, it seems to me that the austerity effort South Dakota's governor is undertaking is going to drive people, especially high wage earners out of state.  If that happens and if the articles are correct, that means that the state's NAEP scores may soon drop as well.

Wednesday, January 19, 2011

Giving Teachers Guns: A Bad and Scary Idea

A Nebraska state legislator wants to allow teachers to carry concealed weapons.

According to a Lincoln Star Journal article bill is sponsored by Senator Mark Christianson who claims that "he introduced his bill in response to the Jan. 5 shooting at Millard South High School, where 17-year-old student Robert Butler Jr. shot Assistant Principal Vicki Kaspar and then shot Principal Curtis Case."

Christianson asserts that had his law been in effect the Millard South deaths might have been prevented, "We might have been better off.  To me, it's much better to be able to deal with the situation quickly. We can stop additional lives from being taken."

Christianson seems to be proof that American's education system has failed at least when it comes to teaching people how to think logically.

First, looking to the case at hand, "[p]olice found Butler about 45 minutes after the shooting in a parking lot about a mile from the school, dead from a self-inflicted gunshot."  If the person who shot others commits suicide, it's unlikely that the threat of being shot by others will provide a deterrent.

Second, real life is not like TV. Armed teachers firing at armed students is going to produce wounded innocents.

I have about twenty allegedly humorous reasons why having teachers bring guns to school is a bad idea, but I'll keep it simple.  This idea is one of the most inane and frightening that I've ever heard.