Dick Cheney was on the search committee to find George W. Bush’s VP. Suddenly, Dick Cheney was the best person to be VP. Our new assistant principal was on the committee to find a new assistant principal. Does that mean students sent to the principal’s office will now be waterboarded?
Wednesday, May 19, 2010
A Question Springing from A Comparison
Monday, May 17, 2010
If the classroom is important, then . . .
Why do they mow the lawn outside my classroom window when I'm trying to give a test? It seems to me that lawns can be mowed before 8:00 am or 3:30 pm. Why do they call my room to tell me kids have to leave for appointments? Shouldn't the kids have to remember their own appointments? Whey do they have announcements blaring over the loudspeaker during class time? Why can students be late to class because they have a message at the office? Why is lunch the only time that can't be altered during the school day? They tell me that classroom is important, but I can't think of a single thing that someone who doesn't teach won't use to warrant a classroom interruption., but the classroom is important.
Labels:
Education Gripes
Sunday, May 16, 2010
Is It Time To Grow Up?
I spent a good part of today getting stacks of comic books in long boxes to store so that we can celebrate graduation. Gotta love those manufactured coming of age rituals that seem to mean nothing to those who are coming of age.
While storing and sorting, I noticed that there's about five months of issues that I haven't read. I will get to some this summer, but work keeps getting in the way of reading. Besides, I could spend the time reading comics reading more substantial fiction. Also, those long boxes take up a lot of room. Further, the damned things now cost $2.99 and up. They were 12 cents when I was a kid. (By the way, why doesn't my computer keyboard have a symbol for cents?)
On the other hand, there is the cliche about one doesn't quit playing because one gets old; one gets old because one quits playing. I would hate to lose my boyish charm because I quit reading comics. Enough introspection.
While storing and sorting, I noticed that there's about five months of issues that I haven't read. I will get to some this summer, but work keeps getting in the way of reading. Besides, I could spend the time reading comics reading more substantial fiction. Also, those long boxes take up a lot of room. Further, the damned things now cost $2.99 and up. They were 12 cents when I was a kid. (By the way, why doesn't my computer keyboard have a symbol for cents?)
On the other hand, there is the cliche about one doesn't quit playing because one gets old; one gets old because one quits playing. I would hate to lose my boyish charm because I quit reading comics. Enough introspection.
Labels:
comics,
growing old,
growing up,
too much stuff
Thursday, May 13, 2010
Education: An American Tragedy
The New York Review of Books posts this E.D Hirsch review of Diane Ravitch's The Death and Life of the Great American School System: How Testing and Choice Are Undermining Education. As a teacher, I began to channel Cassius from Shakespeare's Julius Caesar when I read the following paragraphs.
As comforting as passing the blame is, however, it strikes me that Cassius in Shakespeare Julius Caesar has it right, "The fault . . .is not in our stars,/But in ourselves, . . ." I just hope we get a chance to fix the mess we created.
Yet I do not agree with Ravitch that we should chiefly rely on experienced educators. We certainly should consult them and win them over, but we have been relying on them, and they have failed us—not least in their response to the No Child Left Behind law. Ravitch strongly criticizes NCLB for its narrow emphasis on reading and math and its reduction of schooling to preparation for tests. Her analysis is factually accurate. But to understand why the law failed we need to imagine what might have happened had our experienced educators responded differently to it.Some of the blame goes to those who love what Emerson in "Self-Reliance"calls the "foolish consistency [that] is the hobgoblin of little minds. This consistency is "adored by little statesmen and philosophers and divines" I'm pretty sure that and school principals, district superintendents, and secretaries of education at all levels also have a love affair, metaphorically, of course, with that same foolish consistency.
The law would have had a much more beneficial effect if educators had reacted with more insight to its provisions. NCLB was quite right to place a dominant emphasis on the development of language ability and reading skill. Verbal skill is known to be a chief constituent of adult success and effectiveness. But verbal ability is not, as the schools wrongly assumed, simply a how-to skill. It is largely a knowledge-based skill. NCLB did not, after all, mandate that the schools must practice reading strategies at the expense of a strong curriculum in literature, history, science, and the arts—the very kind of schooling that, according to the findings of cognitive science, would raise reading abilities by systematically building background knowledge. The decision to teach strategies instead was made by experienced educators who had been indoctrinated by education schools into an anticurricular point of view, emphasizing “how to” read, and giving quite inadequate attention to what should be learned to build up needed knowledge (Hirsch, How to Save the Schools, 13/5/2010). [Bold Mine]
As comforting as passing the blame is, however, it strikes me that Cassius in Shakespeare Julius Caesar has it right, "The fault . . .is not in our stars,/But in ourselves, . . ." I just hope we get a chance to fix the mess we created.
Wednesday, May 12, 2010
Positive Peer Pressure
This Slate article contends that girls do better when surrounded by intelligent female peers whereas boys may not fair as well when confronted by intelligent male peers. I don't know enough to comment wisely on the premise or the research, but the following quotations struck me as extremely perceptive. First, it seems that a few bad apples may spoil the whole barrel.
The studies examined the academic achievement of high school students and found that being surrounded by underachieving classmates has a negative effect on girls and boys—both genders feel pressure to conform to the lower standards of their peers (Bold Mine, Italics in original) (Fisman, The Right Kind of Peer Pressure, 11/5/2010).Second, the Demotivational geniuses are correct; when people are given the opportunity to do as they please, they usually imitate each other (Despair.com, Conformity). It will be hard for anyone, especially high school students avoid that trap.
The takeaway from all of this is clear for parents looking to maximize their kids' SAT scores—surround your daughters with smart peers and make sure to keep any kid, boy or girl, away from the influence of academic laggards. Both boys (discouraged by stiff competition) and girls (deterred by peer disapproval) might also look back on the advice dispensed by Mary Pipher in the closing pages of Reviving Ophelia. Adolescents, she writes, need to "forge self-definitions independent of peer pressure." (Bold Mine) (Fisman, The Right Kind of Peer Pressure, 11/5/2010).
Labels:
Demotivation,
Education,
Gender
Tuesday, May 11, 2010
A Question In Which I Act Like A Cranky Conspiracy Theorist, Sort Of
BP is a corporation. The courts have said that corporations are individuals; therefore BP is an individual. BP has caused millions of dollars of damage to the United States . The damage may be the result of negligence or criminal activity. If true, why can’t BP the individual be declared an enemy combatant for terrorizing the United States ? The harm done by the spill is far greater than the harm that would have been done by the Times Square Bomb attempt. In fact, people actually died because of BP’s actions.
Monday, May 10, 2010
Reaping the Whirlwind???
According to this post, an Elana Kagan confirmation to the Supreme Court means that that no Protestants will be serving on the nation's highest court. Did the problem enunciated by the title of this book contribute to the situation? Just asking.
Labels:
Books,
Evangelicalism,
SCOTUS
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)