Thursday, March 18, 2010

Education Reform Debate

At The New Republic’s online symposium on education reform, Kevin Carey attacks Diane Ravitch’s baseball analogy. He writes, “Diane, you live in Brooklyn--haven't you heard of the 2009 World Series Champion New York Yankees, whose nine starters averaged 25 home runs apiece during the regular season? If the teachers in the Bronx were as good as the baseball players, students there would learn much more.”

Everyone has heard of the New York Yankees. Carey, perhaps, hasn’t heard that there are small market teams that have to make do with a single all-star or three or four all-stars. Schools are small market teams who have to rely on Sabermetrics and a few defensive specialists, not the bombers who earn the Bronx its fame.

Further, the fact that the Yankees “averaged 25 home runs apiece” doesn’t really help his argument. Under most state implementations of NCLB rules a team average isn’t good enough. Every player needs to hit .300 and 25 home runs.

Wednesday, March 17, 2010

Some Observations about Technology and the Web

I've been fascinated by David Gerlenter's observations about the Internet and it's impact.

I love this assertion:

"The Internet is no topic like cellphones or videogame platforms or artificial intelligence; it's a topic like education. It's that big. Therefore beware: to become a teacher, master some topic you can teach; don't go to Education School and master nothing. To work on the Internet, master some part of the Internet: engineering, software, computer science, communication theory; economics or business; literature or design. Don't go to Internet School and master nothing. There are brilliant, admirable people at Internet institutes. But if these institutes have the same effect on the Internet that education schools have had on education, they will be a disaster."

I can't agree more that effective teachers need to know their subject matter before they teach. I also can't agree more that education schools have been a disaster for education.

The most fascinating part, however, was the assertion that the question "if this is the information age, what do our children know that our parents didn't?" has a specific answer. According to Gelernter, The answer is 'now.' They know about now." He continues, "Nowness is one of the most important cultural phenomena of the modern age"

I see nothing to argue with in these points; I am, however, frightened by them. If he is correct, then knowledge of the past and preparation for the future cease to be important. Equally important, reflection is nearly impossible if one is currently in the moment.

Gelernter, however, is optimistic: ". . . the Internet could be the most powerful device ever invented for understanding the past, and the texture of time. Once we understand the inherent bias in an instrument, we can correct it. The Internet has a large bias in favor of now. Using lifestreams (which arrange information in time instead of space), historians can assemble, argue about and gradually refine timelines of historical fact. Such timelines are not history, but they are the raw material of history. They will be bitterly debated and disputed — but it will be easy to compare two different versions (and the evidence that supports them) side-by-side. Images, videos and text will accumulate around such streams. Eventually they will become shared cultural monuments in the Cybersphere."

I'm not so sure. It seems to me that lack of knowledge of the past makes it possible to use Orwell as a blueprint not a warning. If there is no real knowledge of anything but "now," then the evidence can be massaged in a way that makes the debate and the evidence used to support each side position suspect. It will be theater not fact.

Tuesday, March 16, 2010

Today was a good day to teach mythology and drama.

First, Ross Douthat writes, "Americans believe in evil, but we’re uncomfortable with tragedy. We accept that there are wicked people in the world, with malice in their hearts and a devil whispering in their ears. But the idea that many debacles flow from choices made by decent, well-intentioned human beings is more difficult for us to wrap our minds around."

Later, Daniel Larison takes issue with Douthat's analysis about tragedy, in its literary sense, and the Iraq War here and here. Later, Rod Dreher takes up the idea of the tragic and the new revelations about the Pope and the European/German sex abuse scandal.

For at least one day this year, it was easy to show that Oedipus or Hamlet matter in the "real world."

Sunday, March 22, 2009

A Minor Observation

Yesterday I learned that pedagogue comes from the word for a slave who lead the son of his master to school. Apparently, the slave frequently carried the boy's satchel.

According the kind folks who brought us NCLB, teachers are supposed to be "scientific pedagogues" and one can't be a good teacher if one is "a sage on stage."

I looked up the etymology for sage and the word comes from words that mean "to know" or "to taste" or "to discern" or "to be wise."

Maybe I'm getting cantankerous in my old age, but I'd sooner be "wise" or "discerning" than a slave. Besides, I'm not sure anyone knows how to scientifically carry a satchel.

Saturday, March 21, 2009

A New Purpose in Life

While wasting time yesterday, I came across this article claiming to defend public schools. Although the defense may be a case of damning with faint praise, it did provide me with a goal for life. The author describes a friend as "a fine and profane rural gentleman."

Maybe it's just my cynicism, but becoming a walking oxymoron that has two positive outcomes--being both "fine" and a "gentleman"--but which allows one to have the vice of being "profane" seems like a great way to go about life. Besides, as a plainsman, I've already got the rural part down.

Thursday, August 14, 2008

Why I Teach English

This article says it better than I can.

The humanities, rightly pursued and rightly ordered, can do things, and teach things, and preserve things, and illuminate things, which can be accomplished in no other way. It is the humanities that instruct us in the range and depth of human possibility, including our immense capacity for both goodness and depravity. It is the humanities that nourish and sustain our shared memories, and connect us with our civilization’s past and with those who have come before us. It is the humanities that teach us how to ask what the good life is for us humans, and guide us in the search for civic ideals and institutions that will
make the good life ­possible.

Why I Wake Up Angry: An Anecdote Illustrating My Encounters With Fellow Educators, Especially Administrators

I recently sat through a horrible training session. It was disorganized and filled with things that get on my nerves. I had one and only one question that I wanted answered, but no one would answer it. If that session is any indication of what the year is going to be like, I'm going to make the Hulk seem as calm as a meditating Zen monk.

After thinking about that session, I was reminded of an encounter that I had with a principal several years ago. I think that it illustrates why I get angry nearly every day.

I got a new teacher desk for my classroom. I was at school a couple of weeks before school began and wanted to set up the room. The desk was locked. I looked for the keys in the envelope that had some promo materials and in a few other places before asking my principal for the keys.

He said that he had the keys but they were with a bunch of other keys for other new desks and new filing cabinets and whatever other new storage equipment came in that summer. He had to go to a meeting or something, so he'd get them to me the next day.

I did other work to get the classroom ready. After a couple of days, I still did not have the keys. I wanted to get the desk organized, so I asked again. He was still busy. I think I asked one more time before going home and swearing loudly and creatively at the walls in my apartment.

During one of the meeting days that precedes every school year, one of my colleagues who camps in the principal's office told me the principal wanted to know why I needed to lock my desk. After I explained to him that I needed to UNLOCK the desk, he went to the principal and got the keys in about five minutes. I really don't understand why "I need the keys to my desk" necessarily means I need to lock it it not unlock it. I also don't know what difference that distincion makes; teachers have all sorts of things that they don't want students to have easy access to.

It's a boring story, no gunfights or car chases or fire trucks or hookers or anything, but I have had more experiences like that than I can count. In fact, I have about 50 to 100 of these conversations every school year. I make what I think are direct and understandable statements or requests like "I need the keys to my desk" and fellow teachers and administrators assume that I really don't mean what I say or that I have said or that I intended to say something totally different.

I'm getting older and more cantankerous, so I don't handle the frustration as well as I used to. Maybe, I'll just talk to my students and ignore everyone else.